An Institutionalization Effect: The Impact of Mental Hospitalization and Imprisonment on Homicide in the United States, 1934-2001

  title={An Institutionalization Effect: The Impact of Mental Hospitalization and Imprisonment on Homicide in the United States, 1934-2001},
  author={Bernard E. Harcourt},
  journal={Social Science Research Network},
  • B. Harcourt
  • Published 1 March 2007
  • Psychology, Law
  • Social Science Research Network
Previous research overwhelmingly shows that incarceration led to lower rates of violent crime during the 1990s, but finds no evidence of an effect prior to 1991. This raises what Steven Levitt calls “a real puzzle.” This study offers the solution to that puzzle: the fatal error with prior research is that it used exclusively rates of imprisonment, rather than a measure that combines institutionalization in both prisons and mental hospitals. Using state-level panel data regressions over the… 
Pre-Medicated Murder: Violence and the Degree to Which the Mentally Ill Can Refuse Treatment
Allowing voluntarily committed patients to refuse medication may entice some to enter in-patient facilities, but the brief and optional exposure to medication and their side effects may actually discourage treatment and increase violence.
The Mirror Image of Asylums and Prisons
This article analyzes trends in prison rates and mental hospital rates in France since the earliest available statistics. It shows that, on almost two centuries of data and amidst an agitated
The mirror image of asylums and prisons: A study of institutionalization trends in France (1850–2010)
This article analyzes trends in prison rates and mental hospital rates in France since the earliest available statistics. It shows that, on almost two centuries of data and amidst an agitated
The impact of prison deinstitutionalization on community treatment services
BackgroundWith one in every 108 Americans behind bars, the deinstitutionalization of prisons is a pressing issue for all those facing the daunting challenges of successfully reintegrating
Does Homicide Influence Psychiatric Hospitalization to a Mental Health Facility? A Mathematical Approach
There is a psychology of homicide that is unfolding in Jamaica and people are negatively influenced by the homicide pandemic, which is still accounting for psychiatric disorders among Jamaicans.
The Mirror Image of Asylums and Prisons - An International Study
It is shown how, on almost two centuries of data, every French prison trend is compensated by an inverse asylum trend, with no obvious, direct, explanation.
Chronicles of A Death Row Exoneree: Life Prior, During, and After a Wrongful Conviction
Little is known about the individuals who have been wrongfully convicted and sentenced to death in the United States. Research on capital punishment focuses heavily quantitative data and legal
Penrose's law: Methodological challenges and call for data.
  • M. Kalapos
  • Medicine
    International journal of law and psychiatry
  • 2016
Institutional Castling: Military Enlistment and Mass Incarceration in the United States
It is shown how institutional castling—the shifting prominence of competing institutions in the lives of specific demographic groups—has affected the underlying risk of military employment and penal confinement.
The Effect of 'Failed' Community Mental Health Centers on Non-White Mortality
Though there is little evidence that access to a CMHC impacted mortality rates in the white population, large and robust effects are found for the non-white population, with CMHCs reducing suicide and homicide rates by 8% and 14%, respectively.


Rates of imprisonment and psychiatric hospitalization in the United States
The relationship between penal and therapeutic custodial populations bears not only upon theories of social control, but also upon the validity of prison population rates as social indicators.
From the Asylum to the Prison: Rethinking the Incarceration Revolution. Part II: State Level Analysis
The United States exhibited wildly erratic behavior regarding the institutionalization of persons deemed deviant during the 20 century. During the first half of the century, the country
Crime and the Use of Prisons in the United States: A Time Series Analysis
A recent article by David Biles reported a positive relationship between crime and imprisonment, using cross-sectional data from the United States, Australia, and Canada. This article extends his
The Weak Effect of Imprisonment on Crime: 1971–1998
Objective. This article studies the impact of increasing incarceration rates on crime rates. First we seek to replicate the findings of previous studies utilizing the pooled, fixed–effects models
Crime is the Problem: Homicide, Acquisitive Crime, and Economic Conditions
A question that emerges from recent research on the relationship between economic conditions and street crimes committed for monetary gain concerns the effect of changing economic conditions on
Modeling the Relationship between the Criminal Justice and Mental Health Systems1
Using a panel of cities, the article reveals strong cross‐system effects and that racial composition strongly influences jail capacity and through this effect, both jail and hospital admissions are influenced.
Prison Conditions, Capital Punishment, and Deterrence
Previous research has attempted to identify a deterrent effect of capital punishment. We argue that the quality of life in prison is likely to have a greater impact on criminal behavior than the
Prison population growth and crime reduction
The impact of state prison populations on crime is typically estimated by applying the lambda, the individual crime rate, of prisoners or arrestees. We outline the problems with this approach,
Does the death penalty save lives? In recent years, a new round of research has been using annual time-series panel data from the 50 U.S. states for 25 or so years from the 1970s to the late 1990s
The Limited Importance of Prison Expansion
Introduction over the past twenty years , the fifty American states have engaged in one of the great policy experiments of modern times. In an attempt to reduce intolerably high levels of reported