An Analysis of Errors in the Star Catalogues of Ptolemy and Ulugh Beg

  title={An Analysis of Errors in the Star Catalogues of Ptolemy and Ulugh Beg},
  author={M. I. Shevchenko},
  journal={Journal for the History of Astronomy},
  pages={187 - 201}
  • M. I. Shevchenko
  • Published 1990
  • Physics
  • Journal for the History of Astronomy
  • The main peculiarity of Ptolemy's catalogue is the mean systematic error in the longitudes of the stars exceeding 1 • Many astronomers, in a European tradition going back to Tycho Brahe, I have considered the presence of such error to be an unambiguous indication that the catalogue was borrowed and modified rather than being a product of direct observations. Analysis of the fractional degrees of star coordinates by R. R. Newtonseemingly confirmed the artificial origin of the longitudinal shift… CONTINUE READING
    21 Citations

    Figures and Tables from this paper


    Observing with the Armillary Astrolabe
    • 10
    Almagest: Analysis of method and results of star positional observations
    • Preprint no
    • 1988
    Observing with the armillary astrolabe", Journalfor the history ofastronomy xviii
    • 1987
    Die Geschichte des Ptolemaeischen Sternenkatalogs (doctoral diss
    • Grasshoff's charts
    • 1986
    The crime of Claudius Ptolemy
    • 81
    A history ofancient mathematical astronomy
    • (Berlin and New York,
    • 1975
    Toomer, 328) remarks that the method used for measuring the coordinates of a Leonis was applied to a Virginis: " ... and the brightest among those stars near the ecliptic
    • Ptolemy in Almagest VII
    • 1974
    II. In this case the astronomical refraction acts only in one direction, as the observations with an armillary sphere can begin only in the evening. On the possibility of moming observations
    • Monthly notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, cxxviii (1918),
    • 1918