Alkindi's Critique of Euclid's Theory of Vision

  title={Alkindi's Critique of Euclid's Theory of Vision},
  author={David C. Lindberg},
  pages={469 - 489}
ALKINDI, undoubtedly the first great philosopher of the Islamic world, was a leader in the endeavor to communicate Greek philosophy to Islam.' Not only did he participate in the translating activity of the ninth century, but he also attempted to integrate Greek philosophy with Mu'tazilite theology and thus, in Walzer's phrase, "to naturalise Greek philosophy in the Islamic world."2 Alkindi's deep respect for ancient thought is revealed in the preface to one of his works on metaphysics: 
The problem of evil
THE AUGUSTINIAN BACKGROUND The problem of evil is raised by the combination of certain traditional theistic beliefs and the acknowledgment that there is evil in the world. If, as the major
Muslim thought : its origin and achievements
Mian Mohammad Sharif's Muslim Thought: Its Origin and Achievements was first published in 1951 in Lahore, Pakistan. Discussing the most important facts about the origin and the evolution of Islamic
Form and matter
The first unquestionably big idea in the history of philosophy was the idea of form. The idea of course belonged to Plato, and was then domesticated at the hands of Aristotle, who paired form with
Galen : Ancient and Medieval Theories of Vision
Rhazes’ Al-Shukuk ’Ala Jalinus (Doubts on Galen), although an important and controversial contribution in his era and thereafter, has seldom been examined in the literature. In this article, we give
Don Juan and the Vision of Vision
Castaneda's well-known sequence of Don Juan books is used as a paradigmatic example of the relativist position and it is argued that through an intricate, complex, and ill-understood process of popularisation the authors' self-image is ultimately grounded in the theories of natural science; and these, in turn, are Ultimately grounded in their action in the world of things.
Rhazes Doubting Galen: Ancient and Medieval Theories of Vision
In this article, we give a brief account of Rhazes' life and works and provide an English translation of a passage from his “Doubts on Galen” concerning the theory of vision; Rhazes’ “Doubts on
Religious authority and the state
Religious authority and the state were conceived very differently in the Byzantine world, the Muslim world, and Latin Europe. This last was the only civilization in which the age-old and nearly
Bibliography of secondary sources
Compound Histories: Materials, Governance and Production, 1760-1840 explores the intertwined realms of production, governance and materials, placing chemists and chemistry at the center of processes
Considerations on volumetric 3D display systems
An overview of the human visual system, including a discussion of depth cues, is presented and this is followed by a review of 3D display techniques, which includes a comprehensive discussion of volumetric systems.
An information theory interpretation of relativistic phenomena
Analysis of the evolution of optical and electromagnetic theorizing is suggested to demonstrate that the choice of a mechanically compatible model of electromagnetic radiation, as has conventionally underwritten development of the light-speed postulate of special relativity, is inappropriate.


The opus Majus of Roger Bacon
The first three notes deal with Classification, Definition, and Division. In Note D, on Method, Hypothesis, Working Idea, and Theory, Professor Wolf distinguishes carefully between these four,
For Galen's similar view, see Siegel, Galen on Sense Perception
  • The Book of the Ten Treatises of the Eye ascribed to Hunain ibn Is-hdq (809-877 A.D.)
  • 1928
De multiplicatione specierum
  • Pt. II
21:39. I omit Galenists from this list, although they too may represent the influence of Alkindi. 73 See the German translation of Salah al-Dins work in J
  • Die arabischen Augendrzte, Pt. II (Leipzig: Von Veit, 1905)
  • 1907
Ueber das Leben
    Mathematici vero et physici considerantes ea, quae sunt supra naturam
    • Manifestum est autem, quod species fit a visu sicut ab aliis rebus, quia accidentia et substantie viliores visu possunt facere suas virtutes
    • 1900
    Rhodius also reproduces the material from Prop. 14 of De aspectibus in his Optica
    • Bk. I, Prop