Algorithmic Bidding for Virtual Trading in Electricity Markets

  title={Algorithmic Bidding for Virtual Trading in Electricity Markets},
  author={Sevi Baltaoglu and Lang Tong and Qing Zhao},
  journal={IEEE Transactions on Power Systems},
We consider the problem of optimal bidding for virtual trading in two-settlement electricity markets. A virtual trader aims to arbitrage on differences between day-ahead and real-time market prices that are random and unknown to market participants. An online learning algorithm is proposed to maximize the cumulative payoff over a finite number of trading sessions by allocating the trader's budget among his bids for $K$ options in each session. It is shown that the expected payoff of the… 

Figures from this paper

Machine Learning-Driven Virtual Bidding With Electricity Market Efficiency Analysis
A machine learning-driven portfolio optimization framework for virtual bidding in electricity markets considering both risk constraint and price sensitivity is developed and the comprehensive empirical analysis on PJM, ISO-NE, and CAISO indicates that the proposed virtual bid portfolio optimization strategy considering the price sensitivity explicitly outperforms the one that neglects the price sensitive.
A Machine Learning Framework for Algorithmic Trading with Virtual Bids in Electricity Markets
  • Wei Wang, N. Yu
  • Computer Science
    2019 IEEE Power & Energy Society General Meeting (PESGM)
  • 2019
A mixture density network model is developed to provide robust and accurate forecasts for electricity price spread between day-ahead and real-time market and to maximize the expected net earnings of the virtual bid portfolio.
Optimal Bidding Strategy for Physical Market Participants With Virtual Bidding Capability in Day-Ahead Electricity Markets
Case studies show the effectiveness of the proposed bi-level optimization model and reveal physical MPs may choose to deploy virtual transactions in a very different way than pure financial MPs.
Stochastic Up to Congestion Bidding Strategy in the Nodal Electricity Markets Considering Risk Management
The numeral results indicate that, compared to the deterministic UTC bidding strategy, the proposed stochastic strategy can bring much higher expected profit and lower potential risks for the financial participant.
Strategic Convergence Bidding in Nodal Electricity Markets: Optimal Bid Selection and Market Implications
Convergence bidding (CB), a.k.a., virtual bidding (VB), is a market mechanism facilitated by Independent System Operators (ISOs) in wholesale electricity markets to help lower the gap between the
A Data-Driven Convergence Bidding Strategy Based on Reverse Engineering of Market Participants’ Performance: A Case of California ISO
This work uses the publicly available electricity market data to learn, characterize, and evaluate different types of convergence bidding strategies that are currently used by market participants, and proposes a new CB strategy that can significantly outperform them.
Risk-constrained Bi-level Optimization for Virtual Bidder Bidding Strategy in Day-Ahead Electricity Markets
Virtual bidders place virtual offers/bids into day-ahead electricity market, and the cleared energy is settled at the price difference between day-ahead market and real-time market. With high
Understanding the Structural Characteristics of Convergence Bidding in Nodal Electricity Markets
This article provides a methodology to identify under what conditions a CB results in price convergence, instead of price divergence, and covers the stochastic case, where the probability of price convergence (or divergence) when the system parameters are uncertain about some system parameters.
A Data-Driven Study to Discover, Characterize, and Classify Convergence Bidding Strategies in California ISO Energy Market
Three years of real-world market data from the California ISO energy market is studied to study how some of the most active market participants are using bidding strategies that do not any of the strategic bidding methods that currently exist in the literature.


Impact of virtual bidding on financial and economic efficiency of 1 wholesale electricity markets
4 Virtual bidding is a financial mechanism that allows participants to speculate on the price spread 5 between day-ahead and real-time wholesale electricity markets. We employ statistical learning
Efficiency impact of convergence bidding in the california electricity market
The California Independent System Operator (CAISO) has implemented Convergence Bidding (CB) on February 1, 2011 under Federal Energy Regulatory Commission’s September 21, 2006 Market Redesign and
Model and data analysis of two-settlement electricity market with virtual bidding
This work follows a data-driven approach to develop a two-settlement market model, and considers a game-theoretic setting with virtual bidders as strategic players to interpret the spread as a measure of the average forecast accuracy of the market and all the virtual bbiders.
Financial Arbitrage and Efficient Dispatch in Wholesale Electricity Markets
Virtual bidding is a type of transaction introduced into wholesale electricity markets to improve competition and pricing. This paper analyzes the theory behind virtual bidding and describes
Testing for Market Eciency with Transactions Costs: An Application to Convergence Bidding in Wholesale Electricity Markets
With risk neutral traders and zero transactions costs, the expected value of the dierence between the current forward price and the spot price at the delivery date of the forward contract should be
Speculative Trading and Market Performance: The Effect of Arbitrageurs on Efficiency and Market Power in the New York Electricity Market
While the effect speculators have on forward premiums (the difference between forward and expected spot prices) has been widely studied, there has been very little focus on the effect speculators
Virtual bidding and electricity market design
Inefficiencies and Market Power in Financial Arbitrage: A Study of California's Electricity Markets
For two years prior to the collapse of California's restructured electricity market, power traded in both a forward and a spot market for delivery at the same times and locations. Nonetheless, prices
Limits to arbitrage in electricity markets: A case study of MISO