Against the concept of ethnic conflict

@article{Gilley2004AgainstTC,
  title={Against the concept of ethnic conflict},
  author={Bruce Gilley},
  journal={Third World Quarterly},
  year={2004},
  volume={25},
  pages={1155 - 1166}
}
  • B. Gilley
  • Published 1 September 2004
  • Sociology
  • Third World Quarterly
Despite a boom in studies of ethnic conflict, the empirical and conceptual justification for this field remains weak. Not only are claims of surging ethnic conflict unsubstantiated, but the concept itself is problematic. The concept tends to homogenise quite distinct political phenomena. Making valid causal inferences about ‘ethnic conflict’ is nearly impossible as a result, a shortcoming reflected in the un‐robust nature of the literature on the subject. For both practical and normative… 
View on Taylor & Francis
sites.hks.harvard.edu
87 Citations
Background Citations
24

87 Citations

Citation Type

Citation Type

Ethnic Diversity and Overurbanization in the Middle East: (Originally) Benign Differences with (Hidden) Political Consequences
Ethnic conflicts are discussed frequently in political discourse. One particularly controversial issue is the debate over whether ethnic diversity has negative effects on political society, and…
The causes of ethnic conflict in Multi-ethnic societies
Ethnic conflicts were the main forms of political instability in the multi ethnic societies during second half of twenty century and beginning of new century. The goal of this study determinates…
Social conflict
Numerous approaches in the social sciences either refuse to consider or minimize the importance of conflict in community or else replace it with a Spencerian vision of the social struggle. Between…
Three explanations of ethnic violence in Indonesia
Between 1997 and 2002, at least 10,000 people have been killed and over a million displaced as a result of seven violent conflicts in Indonesia.1 These violent clashes have been predominantly…
Ethnic Alliances Deconstructed: The PKK Sanctuary in Iraqi Kurdistan and the Internationalization of Ethnic Conflict Revisited
Abstract This article presents a critique of how the dominant paradigms in international relations (IR)—neo-realism, neo-liberalism and systemic constructivism—approach and explain ethnic conflict.…
Interpreting the Ethnicization of Social Conflict in China: Ethnonationalism, Identity, and Social Justice
Accompanying the tremendous growth of the PRC economy has been the ethnicization of social conflicts. This chapter explores why tensions between social groups in the PRC have frequently been cast in…
An Overview of Ethnicity as a Leading Cause of Conflict in Nigeria
Nigeria is a forced marriage which did not receive the approval of the couples involved. Because of that whatever is done in Nigeria always has an ethnic undertone be it, politics, employment and…
Ethnic Diasporas and US Foreign Policy
The past two decades have witnessed a growing scholarly interest in the role that “ethnic diasporas” play in the formulation of America’s foreign policy. While the connection between these ethnic…
From Armed Conflict to War: Ethnic Mobilization and Conflict Intensification*
This article presents a new line of inquiry into ethnicity and armed conflict, asking the question: are conflicts in which rebels mobilize along ethnic lines more likely to see intensified violence…
UNDERSTANDING INTER-BRASIAN CONFLICT
The phenomenon of Sikh and Muslim conflict has been largely analysed in anthropological and sociological works in terms of a product of angry youth or ethnic hatred or religious passions. This paper…
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 47 REFERENCES
WHAT ROLE DOES PREJUDICE PLAY IN ETHNIC CONFLICT
▪ Abstract The extensive literatures on prejudice and ethnic conflict exist largely in isolation from one another. This essay attempts to bridge the gap between the social-psychological study of…
Ethnic Conflict in Malaysia Revisited
  • H. Singh
  • Political Science, Sociology
  • 2001
The ethnic paradigm has dominated political science analysis of societal conflict in west Malaysia. This perspective regards socio-political tensions to be a function of the competition between the…
Democratization, Political Institutions, and Ethnic Conflict
Although there has been much debate about whether democratization causes ethnic conflict, and many comparativists have argued about which kinds of political institutions are best for managing…
Ethnicity, Political Systems, and Civil Wars
The effect of ethnic division on civil war and the role of political systems in preventing these conflicts are analyzed, using the importance of religious polarization and animist diversity to…
The International Dimensions of Ethnic Conflict: Concepts, Indicators, and Theory
One of the growing debates among students of international politics concerns the precise linkage between ethnic conflict and international conflict. The present investigation attempts to contribute…
Do Ethnic and Nonethnic Civil Wars Have the Same Causes?
A booming quantitative literature on large-scale political violence has identified important economic and political determinants of civil war. That literature has treated civil war as an aggregate…
Can Institutions Resolve Ethnic Conflict
High-quality institutions -- reflected in such factors as rule of law, bureaucratic quality, freedom from government expropriation, and freedom from government repudiation of contracts -- mitigate…
Ethnic Minorities and the Clash of Civilizations: A Quantitative Analysis of Huntington's Thesis
Samuel Huntington's ‘clash of civilizations’ thesis has sparked considerable debate. Huntington argues that post-Cold War conflicts will revolve primarily around civilizations. This article uses the…
From Voting to Violence: Democratization and Nationalist Conflict
From Voting to Violence examines the ways in which democratization can exacerbate nationalist fervor and ethnic conflict if the conditions promoting a successful transition are not in place. The book…
The Warrior's Honor: Ethnic War and the Modern Conscience
Ignatieff charts the rise of the new moral interventionists who believe that other people's misery concerns us all, introduces the new ethnic warriors who have escalated post-modern war to an…
...
...