Advanced Analysis Cognition: Improving the Cognition of Intelligence Analysis

  title={Advanced Analysis Cognition: Improving the Cognition of Intelligence Analysis},
  author={Christel Kampman and Charles A Mangio and Melinda Marsh},
Abstract : A prior effort, State of Knowledge Relative to Intelligence Analysis, was initially motivated by the fact that seemingly little change had resulted from numerous studies of the intelligence community. Starting with Pearl Harbor, the U.S. intelligence community has often faced criticism for failing to predict or warn of future events. Though the criticisms have come from different groups, a certain commonality exists among the proposals for change in the intelligence community. The… 
1 Citations

Tables from this paper

User-Centered Design and Experimentation to Develop Effective Software for Evidence-Based Reasoning in the Intelligence Community: The TRACE Project

The trackable reasoning and analysis for crowdsourcing and evaluation project takes a user-centered design approach combined with rigorous experimentation to ascertain effective structured techniques to support high-quality reasoning.



Challenges for Cognition in Intelligence Analysis

Intelligence analysis is a high-stakes domain that poses challenges to effective individual and collaborative cognition. The design of support tools and analytical pedagogy could benefit from an

When Everything is Intelligence - Nothing is Intelligence

Abstract : This engaging, anecdote-rich essay, was delivered as a keynote speech on 23 May 2002 at the Kent Center Conference on "Understanding and Teaching Intelligence Analysis: A Discipline for

Revisiting the psychology of intelligence analysis: from rational actors to adaptive thinkers.

Traditional judgment and decision making research serves as a starting point, though recent developments in decision science advance additional relevant perspectives that are critical to improving intelligence analysis.

Outsmarting IQ: The Emerging Science of Learnable Intelligence

Since the turn of the century, the idea that intellectual capacity is fixed has been generally accepted. But increasingly, psychologists, educators, and others have come to challenge this premise.

Human Processes in Intelligence Analysis: Phase I Overview

An overview of the results of a study to develop a framework for understanding human processes in intelligence analysis and some of the implications of the cognitive model for training developments, system development, and organizational control of intelligence production are explored.

Intelligence Analysis and Judgmental Calibration

Intelligence analysis often requires making not only a prediction but also a rough estimate of the probability of the predicted outcome. Yet, a substantial body of evidence suggests that experts tend

The Group Matters: A Review of Processes and Outcomes in Intelligence Analysis

The work of intelligence analysts is fundamentally cognitive in nature. Intelligence analysis consists largely of identifying problems, generating and evaluating hypotheses, identifying and assessing

Towards a New Theory of Intelligence Failure? The Impact of Cognitive Closure and Discourse Failure

Abstract Oscar Wilde captures the deep challenges relating to intelligence when he states that, ‘it is the spectator, and not life, that art really mirrors’. This statement elucidates the negative

The Cognitive Bases of Intelligence Analysis.

Abstract : This report summarizes the background research that led to development of the Strategic Intelligence Analysis Handbook which was also developed under this contract. The goal of the

Curing Analytic Pathologies: Pathways to Improved Intelligence Analysis

Abstract : As a result of a number of analytic projects for different intelligence agencies, a major focus of my work during the past several years has involved examining the practice of analysis