Activity Theory Is a Dead End for Cultural-Historical Psychology

@article{Toomela2000ActivityTI,
  title={Activity Theory Is a Dead End for Cultural-Historical Psychology},
  author={Aaro Toomela},
  journal={Culture \& Psychology},
  year={2000},
  volume={6},
  pages={353 - 364}
}
  • A. Toomela
  • Published 1 September 2000
  • Psychology
  • Culture & Psychology
In this article, activity theory is analysed. Specific examples for the analysis are taken from Ratner’s (2000) article on emotions. It is concluded that activity theory in general and Ratner’s approach in particular are deficient at three different levels of analysis: from a general theoretical approach to the study of mind to specific details of how particular mental phenomena and their development are studied. Reasons are proposed for why activity theory in principle cannot solve those… 
Commentary: Activity Theory is a Dead End for Methodological Thinking in Cultural Psychology Too
Reworking cultural psychology's methodology is of utmost importance if the discipline is to progress. This paper explores discussion of micro- and macro-cultural formal and informal methodologies of
Concerning Interpretations of Activity Theory
  • I. Mironenko
  • Psychology
    Integrative psychological & behavioral science
  • 2013
TLDR
It is revealed that AT is not limited to Leontiev’s approach, to explain which ideas of the founders of AT, S.L. Rubinstein and L.S. Vygotsky, were pursued and which were rejected, and to assess another important contribution to the AT trend - the theory of B.G. Ananiev.
Towards a Cultural Psychology: Meaning and Social Practice as Key Elements
Several prominent scholars in the Social Sciences have defended the need for a new way of studying the relationship between culture and the individual. Over the last three decades, it has been common
Activity Theory for the De-Structuralized Modernity.
TLDR
It is argued that the major and novel challenge for the individual is that maintaining the integrity and coherence of the a) Self-identity and b) system of links with the socio-cultural environment has become a qualitatively different issue, much more complicated and problematic than ever before.
The First Six Years: Culture’s Adventures in Psychology
The first six years of Culture & Psychologyhave been productive in the creation of an international forum of scholarly interchanges where the notion of ‘culture’ occurs in a number of different ways.
Activity Theories and the Ontology of Psychology: Learning from Danish and Russian Experiences
TLDR
The analysis goes back to Aristotle’s understanding of the freely moving animal in its ecology and introduces some dualities in the encounter between subject and object which replace the dualistic dichotomies traditionally splitting Psychology in Naturwissenchaft vs. Geisteswissenshaft.
Commentary: Vygotskian Cultural-Historical and Sociocultural Approaches Represent Two Levels of Analysis: Complementarity Instead of Opposition
Matusov distinguishes two usually counterposed modern schools of psychology that stem from Vygotsky's theory, the sociocultural and cultural-historical. I suggest that the sociocultural approach is
Learning and Expanding with Activity Theory: The Future of Activity Theory: A Rough Draft
In a previous attempt to outline the challenges facing cultural-historical activity theory, I observed two opposite tendencies in our field: One force pulls researchers toward individual applications
What are Higher Psychological Functions?
  • A. Toomela
  • Psychology
    Integrative psychological & behavioral science
  • 2016
TLDR
It is concluded that HPFs are real psychological phenomena by a set of characteristics not justified theoretically and together with the relations among them.
Current issues in cross-cultural psychology :
Psychology has long ignored culture as a source of influence on human behaviour and still takes little account of theories or data from other than Euro-American cultures. This review deals with
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 38 REFERENCES
A Cultural-Psychological Analysis of Emotions
I argue that an activity theory—which regards emotions as interdependent and interpenetrating with other cultural phenomena—is central for the cultural psychology of emotions. Activity theory
Analyzing Emotions as Culturally Constructed Scripts
In this essay, I comment on some of the points Ratner makes in his paper, ‘A Cultural-Psychological Analysis of Emotions’ (Ratner, 2000). I suggest that, as Ratner implies, emotions are best
How Culture Transforms Mind: A Process of Internalization
In this article a new definition of internalization is proposed, according to which internalization is a process whereby two different mechanisms of information processing, non-verbal ('sensory')
Cultural psychology: a once and future discipline?
  • M. Cole
  • Psychology
    Nebraska Symposium on Motivation. Nebraska Symposium on Motivation
  • 1989
TLDR
This book discusses cross-Cultural Psychology, Cognitive Development, Culture, and Schooling, and a Multilevel Methodology for Cultural Psychology.
Understanding Vygotsky: A Quest for Synthesis
Part 1: Lev Vygotsky literature and art. Part 2 The first years in Moscow 1924-1928: pedagogical psychology defectology the role of psychoanalysis the context of Vygotsky's entrance into psychology -
Gestalt Psychology: An Introduction to New Concepts in Modern Psychology
Wolfgang Koehler (1887-1967) was one of the founders of Gestalt psychology, the influential school that argues that perception is best understood as an organized pattern rather than as separate
The Principles of Psychology
I.TO give readers some idea of the contents of a good book is very often the most useful thing a reviewer can do. Unfortunately that course is not open to us in the present instance. The subject is
The Vygotsky Reader
Preface. Introduction. 1. Introduction to the Russian translation of Freuda s Beyond the pleasure principle: Lev Vygotsky and Alexander Lurina. 2. Principles of social education for deaf and dumb
Principles of Gestalt Psychology.
Routledge is now re-issuing this prestigious series of 204 volumes originally published between 1910 and 1965. The titles include works by key figures such asC.G. Jung, Sigmund Freud, Jean Piaget,
II. The Problem of the Cultural Development of the Child
*Received for publication by A. R. Luria of the Editorial Board, July 20, 1928. †Second in the series of studies on the cultural development of the child.
...
...