Abuse of Dominance in Technology-Enabled Markets: Established Standards Reconsidered?

  title={Abuse of Dominance in Technology-Enabled Markets: Established Standards Reconsidered?},
  author={Miguel Leal Rato and Nicolas Petit},
  journal={European Competition Journal},
  pages={1 - 65}
This paper seeks to examine whether the legal standards underpinning the application of Article 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) need to be revisited in light of the alleged specificities of “technology-enabled” markets. To this end, the paper is divided in seven parts. Following this short introduction (A), the paper offers first a definition of the very notion of “technology-enabled” markets (B). Then, it questions whether competition agencies should depart… 

Two-Sided Markets and the Challenge of Turning Economic Theory into Antitrust Policy

The award of the Nobel Prize in Economics to Professor Jean Tirole in 2014 has generated intense interest about his brainchild theory of two-sided markets. Against this background, this article

Antitrust Enforcement and Standard Essential Patents

9 Introduction Part I. 11 Standards-Setting and Competition Policy Part II. 15 The Standards-Setting Process A. 15 Economic Benefits of Formal Standardisation i. 15 Formal Standardisation and its

Antitrust rules and Intellectual Property Rights in the EU and the US – Towards convergence?

In light of the exponential increase of the number of investigations raising the issue of how to reconcile competition rules and Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs), it is now clear that the area of

Optimal enforcement of competition policy: the commitments procedure under uncertainty

The introduction of a commitments procedure in EU antitrust policy (Article 9 of Council Regulation 1/2003) has entitled the the European Commission to extensively settle cases of alleged

The Hidden Costs of Free Goods: Implications for Antitrust Enforcement

Today a growing number of goods and services are provided in the marketplace free of charge; indeed, free or the appearance of free, have become part of our ecosystem. More often than not, free goods

Google Search and the Law on Dominance in the EU. An Assessment of the Compatibility of Current Methodology with Multi-Sided Platforms in Online Search

Business platforms that utilise, or are based upon, internet technology are omnipresent in consumers daily lives. Since the dawn of the World Wide Web, the amount of web content has increased

Technology Giants, the Moligopoly Hypothesis and Holistic Competition: A Primer

This paper shows that the technology giants that antitrust agencies tend to characterize as entrenched monopolists can also be seen as firms engaged in a process of vibrant oligopolistic competition.

A comparative analysis of the electricity and telecommunications regulations of the UK and Germany - cross country and cross sectoral lessons

The lack of complete harmonization at EU level during the electricity and telecommunications reforms allowed for regulatory competition between the Member States. The aim of the thesis is to explore

Neutrality, Fairness or Freedom? Principles for Platform Regulation

The need for online platform regulation has been a topic of scholarly debate. However, reality is now catching up to and even overtaking the academic writing on this subject. France has adopted a law

The Google Saga: episode I

ABSTRACT After 8 years of investigation, the European Commission decided that Google has abused its market dominance by giving prominent placement in its search results to its own comparison shopping



An Economic Definition of Predation: Pricing and Product Innovation

Many forms of business conduct have been attacked as predatory since the passage of the Sherman Act' in 1890. Neither the courts2 nor legal and economic scholars,3 however, agree on a general

Frand Commitments—The Case for Antitrust Intervention

There are currently a number of high-profile competition law disputes relating to commitments given by owners of patents that are essential to a technical standard to license on “fair, reasonable and

Frand Commitments and EC Competition Law: A Reply to Philippe Chappatte

The paper asserts that antitrust intervention to enforce FRAND commitments is justified by “strong policy reasons”, namely, the risk of consumer harm absent intervention, and the need for “a clear legal precedent set by the Commission in this field”.

Excessive Prices: Using Economics to Define Administrable Legal Rules

European competition laws condemn as ‘exploitative abuses’ the pricing policies of dominant firms that may result in a direct loss of consumer welfare. Article 82(a) of the EC Treaty, for example,

Price Discrimination Under Ec Competition Law: Another Antitrust Theory in Search of Limiting Principles

Price discrimination is one of the most complex areas of EC competition law. There are several reasons for this. First, the concept of price discrimination covers many different practices (discounts

Should Innovation Rationalize Supra-Competitive Prices? A Skeptical Speculation

A recent criticism of competition policy is that antitrust authorities shouldn't focus their concern on prices, since the welfare losses of prices are trivial compared to longer run innovation

Dynamic Competition in Antitrust Law

How would competition policy be shaped if it were to explicitly favor Schumpeterian (dynamic) competition over neoclassical (static) competition? Schumpeterian competition is the kind of competition

When are Excessive Prices Unfair?

A dominant firm can abuse its position by charging unfair prices under EU competition law. According to the Court of Justice of the European Union in United Brands, a price is abusive if (1) the

Checks and Balances: European Competition Law and the Rule of Law

The rule of law is an eminently European concept. It may well have been exported around the world, achieving constitutional status in some jurisdictions, but it was first discussed by Aristotle and