ARE CURRENT CRITIQUES OF THE THEROPOD ORIGIN OF BIRDS SCIENCE? REBUTTAL TO FEDUCCIA (2002)

@inproceedings{Prum2003ARECC,
  title={ARE CURRENT CRITIQUES OF THE THEROPOD ORIGIN OF BIRDS SCIENCE? REBUTTAL TO FEDUCCIA (2002)},
  author={Richard O. Prum},
  year={2003}
}
  • R. Prum
  • Published 1 April 2003
  • Biology, Environmental Science
IN MY Perspectives in Ornithology essay (Prum 2002), I advocated that all ornithologists should be excited about research on the theropod origin of birds. Although I did address some criticisms of the theropod hypothesis, I spent most of the essay outlining the data in support of the theropod origin and, most exciting to me, describing the new directions in evolutionary ornithological research that have opened up as a consequence. I concluded that one of the most important frontiers in… 

Fossils with Feathers and Philosophy of Science

TLDR
It is demonstrated that a variation of Imre Lakatos’s model of progressive versus degenerative research programmes provides a novel and productive assessment of the debate, and established that a refurbished Lakatosian account both explains the intractability of the dispute and predicts a likely outcome for the debate about avian origins.

Rhetoric vs. reality: A commentary on “Bird Origins Anew” by A. Feduccia

TLDR
A review of the full complement of facts pertaining to the avian origins debate is provided, motivated by a Perspectives article with numerous factual inaccuracies, to address the misplaced criticisms raised in that opinion paper.

Cladistics and the Origin of Birds: A Review and Two New Analyses

TLDR
It is asked whether the hypothesis that birds are maniraptoran theropod dinosaurs (the "BMT hypothesis") is as overwhelmingly supported as some claim, and a standard matrix of 46 taxa and 208 characters from a recent paper is re analyzed.

FANTASY VS REALITY: A Critique of Smith et al.'s Bird Origins

TLDR
Adherents of the current orthodoxy of a derivation of birds from theropod dinosaurs, criticize the commentary by Feduccia and numerous papers by Lingham-Soliar using numerous mischaracterizations and misstatements of content, and illustrate their own misconceptions of the nature of the debate.

The Origin of Birds: Current Consensus, Controversy, and the Occurrence of Feathers

Research in the late 1900s has established that birds are theropod dinosaurs, with the discovery of feather preservation in non-avian theropods being the last decisive evidence for the dinosaur

Caudipteryx as a non-avialan theropod rather than a flightless bird

TLDR
There is no reason-phylogenetic, morphometric or otherwise-to conclude that Caudipteryx is anything other than a small non-avialan theropod dinosaur.

On the purported presence of fossilized collagen fibres in an ichthyosaur and a theropod dinosaur

TLDR
It is found that there is no evidence to support the idea that the integumentary structures seen in the two taxa are collagen fibres, and it is confirmed that the most parsimonious interpretation of fossilized structures that look like feather homologues in Sinosauropteryx is that they are indeed the remains of featherhomologues.

On the origin of avian flight: Compromise and system approaches

TLDR
A new compromise hypothesis of the origin of flight in birds and theropod dinosaurs is proposed based on evolutionary morphological analysis of the fore and hind limbs of extinct and extant birds, which suggests a stage of gliding flight was not necessarily passed by early birds.

THE PROBLEM OF MOLT AND PLUMAGE HOMOLOGIES AND THE FIRST PLUMAGE CYCLE

TLDR
It is suggested that birds take different lengths of time and different numbers of molts to enter the adult molt cycle and to acquire the adult plumage and that plumages or molts having the same Howell et al. term should be called "comparable,” rather than homologous.

Feathers, Dinosaurs, and Behavioral Cues: Defining the Visual Display Hypothesis for the Adaptive Function of Feathers in Non-Avian Theropods

TLDR
The visual display hypothesis is defined as predicting that theropod feathers served primarily in the creation of a visual cue capable of triggering a behavioral response in an individual perceiving this cue.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 62 REFERENCES

WHY ORNITHOLOGISTS SHOULD CARE ABOUT THE THEROPOD ORIGIN OF BIRDS

TLDR
G. Heilmann (1926) concluded that birds had evolved from ‘‘thecodonts’’—a polyphyletic garbage bag assemblage of early archosaurs, and his hypothesis was the basis of many scenarios.

Birds are Dinosaurs: Simple Answer to a Complex Problem

TLDR
The "birds are living dinosaurs" hypothesis dates back almost three decades to when John Ostrom, combining studies of his earlier discovery of the late, early Cretaceous dromaeosaur Deinonychus with his speculations on hot-blooded (endothermic) dinosaurs, presented his new dinosarurian origin of birds theory.

The origin and evolution of birds

TLDR
Ornithologist and evolutionary biologist Alan Feduccia, author of "Age of Birds," here draws on fossil evidence and studies of the structure and biochemistry of living birds to present knowledge and data on avian evolution and propose a model of this evolutionary process.

New evidence concerning avian origins from the Late Cretaceous of Patagonia

TLDR
A theropod dinosaur from Patagonia is described, Unenlagia comahuensis gen. et sp.

The Evolutionary Origin And Diversification Of Feathers

TLDR
The developmental theory proposes that feathers evolved through a series of evolutionary novelties in developmental mechanisms of the follicle and feather germ, and the discovery of primitive feather fossils on nonavian theropod dinosaurs documents that feathers evolve and diversified in nonavIAN theropods before the origin of birds and before theorigin of flight.

A morphogenetic approach to the origin and basic organization of the tetrapod limb

Two complementary approaches underlie the study of evolutionary morphology—one a direct result of the Darwinian revolution, the other with roots that can be traced back to pre-Darwinian times. The

On How an Archosaurian Scale Might Have Given Rise to an Avian Feather

TLDR
The homing ability of the neotropica~l bat Phyllostomus hastatus, with evidence for visual orientation, and the random element in bird navigation are studied.

The Evolutionary Origin of Feathers

  • P. Regal
  • Environmental Science
    The Quarterly Review of Biology
  • 1975
TLDR
The development of feathers is complex and a model is proposed that gives attention to the fundamental problems of deriving a branched structure with a cylindrical base from an elongated scale.

FLYING DROMAEOSAURS

Dromaeosaurs have been regarded as theropod dinosaurs that were among the closest avian ancestors which were strictly terrestrial having not yet evolved the ability to fly. Consequently, phylogenetic

Branched integumental structures in Sinornithosaurus and the origin of feathers

TLDR
Observations of the filamentous integumental appendages of the basal dromaeosaurid dinosaur Sinornithosaurus millenii indicate that they are compound structures composed of multiple filaments that are unique to avian feathers, which strongly corroborate the hypothesis that the integumentals of SinORNithosaurus are homologous with avan feathers.
...