A rejoinder to Henschen: the issue of VAR and DSGE models

  title={A rejoinder to Henschen: the issue of VAR and DSGE models},
  author={Mariusz Maziarz and Robert Mr{\'o}z},
  journal={Journal of Economic Methodology},
  pages={266 - 268}


Response to Henschen: causal pluralism in macroeconomics
ABSTRACT In his recent paper in the Journal of Economic Methodology, Tobias Henschen puts forth a manipulationist definition of macroeconomic causality that strives for adequacy. As the notion ofExpand
The in-principle inconclusiveness of causal evidence in macroeconomics
The paper analyzes the methods that macroeconomists can use to provide evidence in support of causal hypotheses: the instrumental variable (IV) method and econometric causality tests. It argues thatExpand
The New Mechanical Philosophy
Natural and social scientists often characterize their work as a search for the mechanisms responsible for the phenomena they study. While this way of thinking about the nature of science has itsExpand
What is macroeconomic causality?
The paper aims to develop an adequate account of macroeconomic causality. It discusses the definition that is central to Woodward’s interventionist account and the definitions that can be extractedExpand
Causation, Evidence, and Inference
1. Causation in a Complex World Part I: Evidence 2. What's Wrong with Our Theories of Evidence? 3. Evidence in Context Part II: Singular Causation 4. Counterfactuals, Thought Experiments and SingularExpand
Mechanistic explanation without the ontic conception
The ontic conception of scientific explanation has been constructed and motivated on the basis of a putative lexical ambiguity in the term explanation. I raise a puzzle for this ambiguity claim, andExpand
Mechanistic Theories of Causality
Part I of this paper introduces a range of mechanistic theories of causality, including process theories and the complex-systems theories, and some of the problems they face. Part II argues thatExpand
Interpreting Causality in the Health Sciences
We argue that the health sciences make causal claims on the basis of evidence both of physical mechanisms, and of probabilistic dependencies. Consequently, an analysis of causality solely in terms ofExpand
Strategies for Discovering Mechanisms: Schema Instantiation, Modular Subassembly, Forward/Backward Chaining
  • L. Darden
  • Computer Science
  • Philosophy of Science
  • 2002
Discovery proceeds in stages of construction, evaluation, and revision. Each of these stages is constrained by what is known or conjectured about what is being discovered. A new characterization ofExpand