A rebuttal of recent arguments for Maragha influence on Copernicus

@article{Blsj2018ARO,
  title={A rebuttal of recent arguments for Maragha influence on Copernicus},
  author={Viktor Bl{\aa}sj{\"o}},
  journal={Studia Historiae Scientiarum},
  year={2018}
}
  • Viktor Blåsjö
  • Published 12 December 2018
  • Physics
  • Studia Historiae Scientiarum
I reply to recent arguments by Peter Barker & Tofigh Heidarzadeh, Arun Bala, and F. Jamil Ragep claiming that certain aspects Copernicus’s astronomical models where influenced by late Islamic authors connected with the Maragha school. In particular, I argue that: the deleted passage in De revolutionibus that allegedly references unspecified previous authors on the Tusi couple actually refers to a simple harmonic motion, and not the Tusi couple; the arguments based on lettering and other… 
1 Citations

Figures from this paper

A ciência árabe na Europa renascentista: a tradição hay’a e a astronomia europeia

Tese de mestrado, Historia e Filosofia das Ciencias, Universidade de Lisboa, Faculdade de Ciencias, 2019

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 39 REFERENCES

A Critique of the Arguments for Maragha Influence on Copernicus

(ProQuest: ... denotes formulae omitted.)1. IntroductionCopernicus's planetary models exhibit some striking similarities to those of late medieval Islamic astronomers. On this basis many have

The Scientific Revolution and the Transmission Problem

Recent dialogical histories of science propose that the Scientific Revolution of the seventeenth century was shaped by contributions from different astronomical traditions of the Eurasian region –

The Rolling Device of Naṣir al-Dīn al-Ṭūsī in the De spera of Nicole Oresme?

DURING HIS CAREER AT PARIS the French Schoolman Nicole Oresme wrote a series of questiones or problems on the popular and influential De spera of Sacrobosco.1 In the final questio (No. 13), which

La Diffusione Delle Scienze Islamiche Nel Medio Evo Europeo. Convegno Internazionale Promosso Dall' Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, Fondazione Leone Caetani, e Dall' Università di Roma ``La Sapienza,'' Facoltà di Lettere, Dipartimento di Studi Orientali, Roma 2-4 Ottobre 1984.Biancamaria Scarcia Amo

Of the two divisions of the work the first deals with the nature of irony, the effort to impose the Aristotelian opposites on the definition of irony, and irony as pretense, as unmasked and as

Before Copernicus : the cultures and contexts of scientific learning in the fifteenth century

Gothic and Renaissance, but his moment passed quickly and he had a terrible press. A few decades after the church was finished the érudit of old Paris, Henri Sauval, said that it had some pretty

Copernicus and Nasīr Al-DĪn AL-TŪSĪ

In his lecture "Trepidation and Planetary Theories", delivered at an international symposium on the subject "East and West in the Middle Ages" (9-15 April 1969; Proceedings published in Rome, 1971),

Islamic Science and the Making of the European Renaissance

wealthy and had careers in Parliament, none of the members of the family were particularly distinctive or famous. Rather, Rothschild focuses on this extended family to illuminate how the

A Sixteenth-Century Arabic Critique of Ptolemaic Astronomy: The Work of Shams Al-Din Al-Khafri

Apercu de la contribution de Shams Al-Din Al-Khafri a l'elaboration de modeles geometriques du mouvement des planetes et de son analyse critique de l'oeuvre astronomique de Ptolemee

Copernicus’s Derivation of the Heliocentric Theory from Regiomontanus’s Eccentric Models of the Second Inequality of the Superior and Inferior Planets

A page of notes in Copernicus’s hand shows the origin of the numerical parameters in the Commentariolus from the Alfonsine Tables and provides evidence for the derivation of the heliocentric theory

Copernicus, Amico, Fracastoro and Ṭūsī's Device: Observations on the Use and Transmission of a Model

L'A. etudie l'hypothese d'une transmission et d'une reception du mecanisme alternatif etabli par Al-Tūsī au XIII e siecle chez Copernic, Amico et Fracastor qui font respectivement reference a ce