A deflationary theory of reference

  title={A deflationary theory of reference},
  author={Arvid B{\aa}ve},
  • A. Båve
  • Published 1 July 2009
  • Philosophy
  • Synthese
The article first rehearses three deflationary theories of reference, (1) disquotationalism, (2) propositionalism (Horwich), and (3) the anaphoric theory (Brandom), and raises a number of objections against them. It turns out that each corresponds to a closely related theory of truth, and that these are subject to analogous criticisms to a surprisingly high extent. I then present a theory of my own, according to which the schema “That S(t) is about t” and the biconditional “S refers to x iff S… 

Why is a truth-predicate like a pronoun?

I begin with an exposition of the two main variants of the Prosentential Theory of Truth (PT), those of Dorothy Grover et al. and Robert Brandom. Three main types of criticisms are then put forward:

A Deflationist Error Theory of Properties

I here defend a theory consisting of four claims about ‘property’ and properties, and argue that they form a coherent whole that can solve various serious problems. The claims are: (1) ‘property’ is

Trivial Languages

I here present and defend what I call the Triviality Theory of Truth (TT), to be understood in analogy with Matti Eklund’s Inconsistency Theory of Truth (IT). A specific formulation of (TT) is

God and Abstract Objects

To the uninitiated, platonism, science, and Christianity might seem poles apart. Neither the average scientist nor the average Christian, after all, finds abstract objects to be relevant to his

Why are (some) Platonists so insouciant?

Some platonists truly agonize over the ontological commitments which their platonism demands of them. Peter van Inwagen, for example, confesses candidly, I am happy to admit that I am uneasy about


  • A. Båve
  • Philosophy
    American Philosophical Quarterly
  • 2019
The paper proposes a way for adherents of Fregean, structured propositions to designate propositions and other complex senses/concepts using a special kind of functor. I consider some formulations

Truth-Predicates Still Not like Pronouns: a Reply to Salis

I here respond to Pietro Salis’s objections against my original critique of the Prosentential Theory of Truth (PT). In addition, I clarify some points regarding the relationship between anaphoric

Interpersonal Sameness of Meaning for Inferential Role Semantics

This work gives a detailed structural account of meaning similarity in terms of graph theory, arguing that it makes sameness of meaning probabilistically determine co-reference.

What is deflationism about truth?

What is deflationism about truth? There are many questions that can be raised about this, given the numerous different characterizations of deflationism in the literature. Here I attend to questions

Metaethics for Neo-Pragmatists: A Pragmatic Account of Linguistic Meaning for Moral Vocabulary

.............................................................................................................................. ii Acknowledgements



Why is a truth-predicate like a pronoun?

I begin with an exposition of the two main variants of the Prosentential Theory of Truth (PT), those of Dorothy Grover et al. and Robert Brandom. Three main types of criticisms are then put forward:

A pragmatic defense of Millianism

A new kind of defense of the Millian theory of names is given, which explains intuitive counter-examples as depending on pragmatic effects of the relevant sentences, by direct application of Grice’s

A prosentential theory of truth

In a number of articles published since 1972, Dorothy Grover has developed the prosentential theory of truth. Brought together and published with a new introduction, these essays do not address

What is truth

In this collection of original papers, leading international authorities turn their attention to one of the most important questions in theoretical philosophy: what is truth? To arrive at an answer,

Speech acts

When we speak we can do all sorts of things, from aspirating a consonant, to constructing a relative clause, to insulting a guest, to starting a war. These are all, pre-theoretically, speech

Deflationism: A Use-Theoretic Analysis of the Truth-Predicate

I here develop a specific version of the deflationary theory of truth. I adopt a terminology on which deflationism holds that an exhaustive account of truth is given by the equivalence between trut

Semantics and the Philosophy of Language

One of the books you can enjoy now is semiotics and the philosophy of language here.

Reflections On Meaning

Preface 1. The Space of Issues and Options 2. A Use Theory of Meaning 3. The Pseudo-Problem of Error 4. The Sharpness of Vague Terms 5. Norms of Truth and Meaning 6. Meaning Constitution and

A critique of deflationism

L'A. critique l'approche deflationniste de la verite selon laquelle la verite est un concept simple et transparent qui ne joue aucun role substantiel en philosophie. En s'appuyant sur la possibilite

Reason's Proper Study: Essays Towards a Neo-Fregean Philosophy of Mathematics