A critical review of the assumptions underlying drug testing

  title={A critical review of the assumptions underlying drug testing},
  author={Deborah F. Crown and Joseph G. Rosse},
  journal={Journal of Business and Psychology},
  • D. Crown, J. Rosse
  • Published 1 September 1988
  • Law
  • Journal of Business and Psychology
Current drug screening programs are based on a set of assumptions: That drug use adversely affects productivity, that available tests are accurate and cost-effective means of detecting and reducing drug use, and that drug testing is legal. When analyzed in the light of available evidence, little support was found for these assumptions. Used properly, drug testing may play a role in the overall management of employee performance; used improperly, it represents a profound threat to individual… 
Impairment Testing: Issues and Convergence with Employee Assistance Programs
Drug testing is an increasingly popular corporate response to substance using employees. It has, however, some significant shortcomings as a means of identifying and controlling substance use. In
Drug Tests in Prevention Research
Overall, drug testing provides valuable information to researchers on preventing drug use and extends the information provided by self-reported data on drug use.
Evaluations of Drug-Testing Programs
In three experiments undergraduate students at an urban university evaluated drug-testing programs described in scenarios. Evaluations were inversely related to the false positive rate and were more
Building a socially responsive drug testing programme
States that management faces a dilemma when it rightly desires to create and maintain a drug‐free work environment. Addresses the need to test employees to ensure a safe and productive workplace
An experimental test of the impact of drug-testing programs on potential job applicants' attitudes and intentions.
The results suggest that organizations should consider the effect of drug-testing programs on potential job applicants and that further research about potential applicants' responses is needed.
Legalization of drugs: Effects on the workplace
In the last few years bipartisan support for legalizing drugs has grown to a surprising level. Because of the lack of involvement of the business community in this debate, we surveyed the human
The Effects of Drug-Testing Program Characteristics on Applicants' Attitudes Toward Potential Employment
Abstract This study is an investigation of the effects of a mandatory versus probablecause drug-testing program and the level of restrictiveness of confidentiality policy on potential applicants'
The deterrent value of drug and integrity testing
Numerous studies have shown that job applicants may react negatively to drug, integrity, and personality testing and that these negative reactions can affect their attitudes and job search behavior.
An evaluation of preemployment drug testing.
As part of a blind longitudinal study, 5,465 job applicants were tested for use of illicit drugs, and the relationships between these drug-test results and absenteeism, turnover, injuries, and


This study examines several dimensions and characteristics of drug-testing programs that are associated with personnel managers' judgments of the programs' effectiveness. The data gathered from 190
Fallibility of urine drug screens in monitoring methadone programs.
Urine specimens containing five different drugs, each at three levels of concentration with zero to five drugs in a specimen, were sent to two "approved" laboratories. In only 46.9% and 13.8%,
Crisis in drug testing. Results of CDC blind study.
These blind tests indicate that greater care is taken with known evaluation samples than with routine samples, laboratories are often unable to detect drugs at concentrations called for by their contracts, and the observed underreporting of drugs may threaten the treatment process.
The impact of pre-employment integrity testing on employee turnover and inventory shrinkage losses
A major home improvement chain located primarily in the western United States initiated the use of thePersonnel Selection Inventory, a written integrity test, as part of its pre-employment hiring
Laboratory evaluation and assistance efforts: mailed, on-site and blind proficiency testing surveys conducted by the Centers for Disease Control.
blind-survey results indicate that good performance in mailed PT does not necessarily imply good laboratory performance with routine patient specimens, and on-site surveys by trained laboratory surveyors and special mailed assistance surveys can be very effective in identifying the source of analytical errors in laboratories previously found to have performance problems.
Attitudinal Correlates of Employees' Deviance: Theft, Alcohol Use, and Nonprescribed Drug Use
  • J. Jones
  • Business
    Psychological reports
  • 1980
Sampling 39 employees from three different workplaces, statistically significant relationships between attitudes toward socially unacceptable deviant behavior, as measured by the Personnel Security Inventory, and employee on-the-job behavior in the areas of theft, alcohol use, and illicit drug use were found.
Detecting infrequent deception.
Recent proposals for using the polygraph and similar devices in routine screening have been aimed at detecting deception in situations sometimes characterized by low base rates. Equations are
Marijuana intoxication by passive inhalation: documentation by detection of urinary metabolites.
The detection of cannabinoids in the urine of this nonsmoker documents the previously anecdotal concept of the "contact high" and has implications for marijuana research and for precautions that may be necessary should marijuana become legal.