A critical evaluation of the evidence supporting the practice of behavioural vision therapy

@article{Barrett2009ACE,
  title={A critical evaluation of the evidence supporting the practice of behavioural vision therapy},
  author={Brendan T. Barrett},
  journal={Ophthalmic and Physiological Optics},
  year={2009},
  volume={29}
}
  • B. Barrett
  • Published 1 January 2009
  • Medicine
  • Ophthalmic and Physiological Optics
In 2000, the UK’s College of Optometrists commissioned a report to critically evaluate the theory and practice of behavioural optometry. The report which followed Jennings (2000 ; Behavioural optometry – a critical review. Optom. Pract. 1: 67) concluded that there was a lack of controlled clinical trials to support behavioural management strategies. The purpose of this report was to evaluate the evidence in support of behavioural approaches as it stands in 2008. The available evidence was… 
Examining the evidence base used by optometrists in Australia and New Zealand
TLDR
Findings highlight the need for current, critically evaluated content in optometric education and suggest that optometrists currently prefer to receive information and knowledge from an educator rather than sourcing and assessing the material independently.
Feature Article: Optometric Vision Therapy for Visual Deficits and Dysfunctions: A Suggested Model for Evidence-Based Practice
Correspondence regarding this article should be emailed to Graham T. Peachey, B.Optom, FCOVD, FACBO, at gpeachey@albury.net.au. All state ments are the author’s personal opinion and may not reflect
Efferent Vision Therapy
  • J. Rucker, P. H. Phillips
  • Medicine
    Journal of neuro-ophthalmology : the official journal of the North American Neuro-Ophthalmology Society
  • 2018
TLDR
There is insufficient evidence to recommend “vision therapy” for the treatment of learning disabilities, impaired reading, dyslexia, or ADHD, as convergence exercises effectively treat CI in healthy patients.
Vision Therapy: Are You Kidding Me? Problems with Current Studies
TLDR
There is evidence to suggest that some form of therapy is effective in reducing symptoms and clinical findings of convergence insufficiency, but there is a lack of equal comparison in order to conclude which forms of treatment are best.
What is the impact of intermittent strabismus upon the therapeutic relationship
This study asks: ‘How does intermittent strabismus impact upon the therapeutic relationship?’ A template organising style has been used to analyse child psychotherapy process records of children who
A randomised controlled trial to compare the clinical and cost-effectiveness of prism glasses, visual search training and standard care in patients with hemianopia following stroke: a protocol
TLDR
This trial aims to determine the effectiveness of prism glasses and visual scanning training compared to standard care in patients with homonymous hemianopia and without ocular motility impairment, visual inattention or pre-existent visual field impairment in a multicentre three arm individually randomised controlled trial.
Examining the evidence base used by optometrists in Australia and New Zealand
Background:  The optometrist's role in primary eye care is expanding to include not only diagnosis but also management and co‐management of a range of eye diseases and visual disorders. This role
Advances in Research in Binocular Vision
Over the last two decades, the study and treatment of binocular vision has undergone a remarkable transformation. A number or recent studies have described the importance of binocular vision and the
Children with Low Literacy and Poor Stereoacuity: An Evaluation of Complex Interventions in a Community-Based Randomized Trial
TLDR
Intervention among children with poor stereoacuity and low literacy produced small improvements in stereopsis and convergence insufficiency symptom scores and a formal randomized control trial was feasible in this setting.
Children with low literacy and poor stereoacuity: an evaluation of complex interventions in a community-based randomized trial.
TLDR
Compared to the parental literacy support group, convergence insufficiency symptoms were reduced 36 weeks post-randomization amongst those receiving the Lawson orthoptic intervention.
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 219 REFERENCES
Efficacy of vision therapy as assessed by the COVD quality of life checklist.
TLDR
The COVD-QOL can be used to measure changes in symptoms, and to objectively demonstrate quality of life changes that are achieved through optometric vision therapy, and is demonstrated to have good test-retest reliability.
Improvements in performance following optometric vision therapy in a child with dyspraxia
TLDR
Evidence supporting the use of OVT eye exercises in dyspraxia, ocular motility, accommodative dysfunction, learning difficulties and sports performance is provided.
Criteria for prescribing optometric interventions: literature review and practitioner survey
  • Claire I. O'Leary, B. Evans
  • Medicine
    Ophthalmic & physiological optics : the journal of the British College of Ophthalmic Opticians
  • 2003
TLDR
It was found that for symptomatic patients, most optometrists would correct an anomaly if it reached the ‘cut off’ point above which the anomaly would be corrected over 50% of the time that it was encountered, and there was a large variation for each category, but it was clear that the presence or absence of symptoms was an important factor for most Optometrists when deciding whether to correct a small error.
Visual training: current status in ophthalmology.
TLDR
Based on an assessment of claims and a study of published data, the consensus of ophthalmologists regarding visual training is that, except for near point of convergence exercises, visual training lacks documented evidence of effectiveness.
Randomised controlled trial of the effect of coloured overlays on the rate of reading of people with specific learning difficulties
TLDR
The conclusion that individually prescribed coloured filters can improve reading performance for reasons that cannot be solely attributed to conventional optometric factors or to placebo effects is supported.
A systematic review of the applicability and efficacy of eye exercises.
TLDR
Eye exercises have been purported to improve a wide range of conditions including vergence problems, ocular motility disorders, accommodative dysfunction, amblyopia, learning disabilities, dyslexia, asthenopia, myopia, motion sickness, sports performance, stereopsis, visual field defects, visual acuity, and general well-being.
The efficacy of sports vision practice and its role in clinical optometry *
For years it has been recognised that many sports place demands on vision and particular visual skills. There is much evidence to show that the correction of visual dysfunction such as ametropia and
Tinted lenses and related therapies for learning disabilities – a review
  • B. Evans, N. Drasdo
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Ophthalmic & physiological optics : the journal of the British College of Ophthalmic Opticians
  • 1991
TLDR
Advice is given for eye‐care practitioners who may be consulted on these therapies and a feasible explanation has been proposed in terms of ‘pattern glare’ resulting from mild hypersensitivity to epileptogenic patterns.
Vision restoration therapy (VRT) efficacy as assessed by comparative perimetric analysis and subjective questionnaires.
TLDR
Findings that VRT improves stimulus detection in HRP and TAP perimetry which were accompanied by subjective, visual improvements indicate that plasticity of temporal processing might play an important role in vision restoration after brain damage.
The effects of accommodative facility training on a group of children with impaired relative accommodation—a comparison between dioptric treatment and sham treatment
TLDR
It is indicated that accommodative facility training has a real effect on the amplitude of relative accommodation in patients with impaired relative accommodation.
...
1
2
3
4
5
...