A critical commentary on follow-up studies and “desistance” theories about transgender and gender-nonconforming children

@article{TempleNewhook2020ACC,
  title={A critical commentary on follow-up studies and “desistance” theories about transgender and gender-nonconforming children},
  author={Julia Temple Newhook and Jake Pyne and Kelley Winters and Stephen Feder and Cindy Holmes and Jemma Tosh and Mari-Lynne Sinnott and Ally Jamieson and Sarah Pickett},
  journal={International Journal of Transgenderism},
  year={2020},
  volume={19},
  pages={212 - 224}
}
ABSTRACT Background: It has been widely suggested that over 80% of transgender children will come to identify as cisgender (i.e., desist) as they mature, with the assumption that for this 80%, the trans identity was a temporary “phase.” This statistic is used as the scientific rationale for discouraging social transition for pre-pubertal children. This article is a critical commentary on the limitations of this research and a caution against using these studies to develop care recommendations… 
A critical commentary on “A critical commentary on follow-up studies and “desistence” theories about transgender and gender non-conforming children”
The article entitled “A critical commentary on followup studies and “desistence” theories about transgender and gender non-conforming children” by Temple Newhook et al. (2018) is a plea to abandon
Rethinking 'need' for clinical support in transgender and gender non-conforming children without clinical classification: Learning from 'the paper I almost wrote'.
TLDR
It is argued that specialist psychological support and care should be driven by the needs of the individual child, as determined by the child and those involved with their care, rather than being provided because of the child's gender diversity.
Importance of being persistent. Should transgender children be allowed to transition socially?
TLDR
There is no evidence that social transition per se leads to unnecessary medical transition; so should a child persist, those who have enabled social transition should not be held responsible for unnecessary bodily harm.
A critical commentary on ‘rapid-onset gender dysphoria’
The term ‘rapid-onset gender dysphoria’ (ROGD) was coined in 2016 to describe an alleged epidemic of youth coming out as trans ‘out of the blue’ due to social contagion and mental illness. The term
The myth of persistence: Response to “A critical commentary on follow-up studies and ‘desistance’ theories about transgender and gender non-conforming children” by Temple Newhook et al. (2018)
ABSTRACT Temple Newhook et al. (2018) provide a critique of recent follow-up studies of children referred to specialized gender identity clinics, organized around rates of persistence and desistance.
‘We just want the best for this child’: contestations of intersex/DSD and transgender healthcare interventions
TLDR
An analytical comparison of the debates reveals that contradictory perceptions of gender, the malleability of bodies and the autonomy of children/adolescents guide the arguments.
The Bioethical Dilemma of Gender-Affirming Therapy in Children and Adolescents
Since the establishment of the first transgender clinic in the United States in 2007, over sixty clinics associated with children’s hospitals have opened across the nation and are seeing very young
The article ‘Sex, gender and gender identity’ fails to adequately engage with the extant scientific literature
The recent paper titled ‘Sex, gender and gender identity: a re-evaluation of the evidence’, which appeared as a Special Article in the BJPsych Bulletin, contains concerning misrepresentations of the
Reconsidering Informed Consent for Trans-Identified Children, Adolescents, and Young Adults.
TLDR
The data on suicide and the limitations of the Dutch studies that have been the basis for interventions are discussed and beliefs about gender-affirmative care need to be separated from the established facts are separated.
Informed Consent for Transgendered Patients
  • S. Levine
  • Medicine
    Journal of sex & marital therapy
  • 2019
TLDR
This article reviews the history of informed consent, presents the conflicts of ethical principles, and presents three categories of risk that must be appreciated before informed consent is accomplished.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 104 REFERENCES
Ethical issues raised by the treatment of gender-variant prepubescent children.
TLDR
There is no expert clinical consensus regarding the treatment of prepubescent children who meet diagnostic criteria for what was referred to in both DSM-IV-TR and ICD-10 as gender identity disorder in children and now in DSM-5 as gender dysphoria.
Prepubertal social gender transitions: What we know; what we can learn—A view from a gender affirmative lens
TLDR
Recommendations are made to support social transitions in prepubertal gender-expansive children, when appropriate, as a facilitator of gender health, defined as a child's opportunity to live in the gender that feels most authentic.
Guidance and Ethical Considerations for Undertaking Transgender Health Research and Institutional Review Boards Adjudicating this Research
TLDR
Nine guidelines are developed to create a set of provisional criteria for Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) to refer to when assessing the ethical orientation of transgender health research proposals.
Appropriate Therapeutic Care for Families with Pre-Pubescent Transgender/Gender-Dissonant Children
In recent years, a new phenomenon has been observed in U.S. culture, that of pre-pubescent children transitioning socially from one gender role to another, with the support of their families. As this
Social Transition: Supporting Our Youngest Transgender Children
TLDR
Evidence is provided in support of social transition, a completely reversible intervention associated with lower rates of depression and anxiety in transgender prepubescent children, in this issue of Pediatrics.
Standards of Care for the Health of Transsexual, Transgender, and Gender-Nonconforming People, Version 7
TLDR
This version of the SOC recognizes that treatment for gender dysphoria has become more individualized, and can be used to help patients consider the full range of health services open to them, in accordance with their clinical needs and goals for gender expression.
The Gender Affirmative Model: What We Know and What We Aim to Learn
in which he stated: ‘‘Cur-rently experts can’t tell apart kids who outgrow gender dysphoria (desisters) from those who do not (persisters), and how to treat them is controversial’’ [Drescher, 2013,
Desisting and persisting gender dysphoria after childhood: A qualitative follow-up study
TLDR
Both persisters and desisters stated that the changes in their social environment, the anticipated and actual feminization or masculinization of their bodies, and the first experiences of falling in love and sexual attraction had influenced their gender related interests and behaviour, feelings of gender discomfort and gender identification.
Transgender Youth: The Building Evidence Base for Early Social Transition.
  • J. Turban
  • Psychology
    Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
  • 2017
Transgender Youth of Color and Resilience: Negotiating Oppression and Finding Support
This qualitative study explored the resilience of 13 transgender youth of color in the southeastern region of the U.S. The definition of resilience framing this study was a participant’s ability to
...
...