A Vast Graveyard of Undead Theories

@article{Ferguson2012AVG,
  title={A Vast Graveyard of Undead Theories},
  author={Christopher J. Ferguson and Moritz Heene},
  journal={Perspectives on Psychological Science},
  year={2012},
  volume={7},
  pages={555 - 561}
}
  • C. Ferguson, M. Heene
  • Published 1 November 2012
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Perspectives on Psychological Science
Publication bias remains a controversial issue in psychological science. The tendency of psychological science to avoid publishing null results produces a situation that limits the replicability assumption of science, as replication cannot be meaningful without the potential acknowledgment of failed replications. We argue that the field often constructs arguments to block the publication and interpretation of null results and that null results may be further extinguished through questionable… Expand

Topics from this paper

Crisis in Cognitive Science? Rise of the Undead Theories
TLDR
In this symposium the speakers consider whether current theories offered by psychological science are valuable, whether there might be inherent obstacles which are preventing the identification of valuable theories, and whether psychological theory even matters at all. Expand
A Defense of Publishing Nonsignificant (ns) Results
An argument is advanced for the propositions that a lack of statistically significant findings does not automatically justify rejecting a scientific article for publication or mean that the findingsExpand
Addressing the theory crisis in psychology.
TLDR
Recommendations for addressing the "replication crisis" are critically revisited, including the proposal to distinguish exploratory from confirmatory research, and the preregistration of hypotheses and analysis plans. Expand
Editorial Decisions May Perpetuate Belief in Invalid Research Findings
TLDR
It is shown that belief in an invalidated finding falls sharply when a critical failed replication is published in the same – versus different – journal as the original finding, and when the authors of the original find acknowledge that the new findings invalidate their conclusions. Expand
Negativland - a home for all findings in psychology
  • K. Laws
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • BMC psychology
  • 2013
TLDR
A serious challenge for psychologists to get their house in-order is to make sure that replications and null findings find a home in psychology rather than remain the authors' dirty little secrets that further eat away at the credibility of their science. Expand
Making replication mainstream
TLDR
There are no theoretical or statistical obstacles to making direct replication a routine aspect of psychological science, and the need for an integrative summary of replication studies is addressed. Expand
From Discovery to Justification: Outline of an Ideal Research Program in Empirical Psychology
TLDR
It is argued that the replicability crisis is “home-made” because more sophisticated strategies can deliver results the successful replication of which is sufficiently probable, and can be overcome by integrating empirical results into genuine research programs. Expand
Welcoming Quality in Non-Significance and Replication Work, but Moving Beyond the p-Value
The self-correcting nature of psychological and educational science has been seriously questioned. Recent special issues of Perspectives on Psychological Science and Psychology of Aesthetics,Expand
Falsification by Atrophy: The Kuhnian Process of Rejecting Theory in US Criminology
Thomas Kuhn posits that the structure of science promotes revolutionary discovery. The decision of a scientific community to discard the status quo in favour of a revolutionary paradigm isExpand
The Epistemic Importance of Establishing the Absence of an Effect
There is evidence suggesting that to the extent that scientists subscribe to a philosophy of science, most are likely to cite Popper’s falsificationism as their practiced methodology (e.g., Mulkay &Expand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 73 REFERENCES
The Theory of Reasoned Action
Although Fishbein and Ajzen’s theory of reasoned action has been a leading theory in social psychology for the last few decades, it also has been an object of criticism for much of that period andExpand
Consequences of Prejudice Against the Null Hypothesis
The consequences of prejudice against accepting the null hypothesis were examined through (a) a mathematical model intended to stimulate the research-publication process and (b) case studies ofExpand
Publication bias in psychological science: comment on Ferguson and Brannick (2012).
TLDR
It is shown how idiosyncratic choices on the part of Ferguson and Brannick led to an erroneous conclusion, and that many of the claims they made are without empirical support, even though they could have tested these claims empirically and that they may be misleading. Expand
Fearing the Future of Empirical Psychology: Bem's (2011) Evidence of Psi as a Case Study of Deficiencies in Modal Research Practice
In this methodological commentary, we use Bem's (2011) recent article reporting experimental evidence for psi as a case study for discussing important deficiencies in modal research practice inExpand
False-Positive Psychology
TLDR
It is shown that despite empirical psychologists’ nominal endorsement of a low rate of false-positive findings, flexibility in data collection, analysis, and reporting dramatically increases actual false- positive rates, and a simple, low-cost, and straightforwardly effective disclosure-based solution is suggested. Expand
Publication decisions revisited: the effect of the outcome of statistical tests on the decision to p
TLDR
Evidence that published results of scientific investigations are not a representative sample of results of all scientific studies is presented and practice leading to publication bias have not changed over a period of 30 years is indicated. Expand
There Is Nothing So Theoretical as a Good Method
  • A. Greenwald
  • Sociology, Medicine
  • Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science
  • 2012
TLDR
There is multidecade durability of theory controversies in psychology, demonstrated here in the subdisciplines of cognitive and social psychology and in an analysis of the last two decades of Nobel awards in physics, chemistry, and medicine. Expand
Some Theories are Unfalsifiable
Trafimow (2009) claims that there are no unfalsifiable theories: To test any theory, one must make auxiliary assumptions, and with sufficient creativity about auxiliary assumptions one could alwaysExpand
Publication Bias: The "File-Drawer" Problem in Scientific Inference
Publication bias arises whenever the probability that a study is published depends on the statistical significance of its results. This bias, often called the file-drawer effect since the unpublishedExpand
The earth is round (p < .05)
After 4 decades of severe criticism, the ritual of null hypothesis significance testing (mechanical dichotomous decisions around a sacred .05 criterion) still persists. This article reviews theExpand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...