A Response to a Nonresponse to Criticisms of a Nonstudy: One Humorous and One Serious Rejoinder to Slater

  title={A Response to a Nonresponse to Criticisms of a Nonstudy: One Humorous and One Serious Rejoinder to Slater},
  author={Scott O. Lilienfeld and Robert L. Spitzer and Michael Barry Miller},
  journal={The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease},
A TERRIBLE MISUNDERSTANDING It appears that there has been a terrible misunderstanding! Now that Dr. Slater has provided a full explanation of why she did not respond to our requests for documentation of her nonstudy (although her attorney was kind enough to respond to these requests by warning us promptly of potential legal action), we now feel obliged to apologize publicly to her. She seems to be correct after all: there was no study and, therefore, no evidence to document one. What led us… 
3 Citations
Lauren Slater and the Experts: Malingering, Masquerade, and the Disciplinary Control of Diagnosis
It is suggested that reading Slater's work through the lens of Tobin Siebers’s theory of “masquerade” can open progressive conversations about “illness deception,” which is an issue of central importance in disability rights, psychiatry, and political conversations.
Rosenhan Pseudopatient Study
In a famous study, professor of psychology and law David Rosenhan and seven other mentally healthy colleagues sought admission to mental hospitals to determine whether their “sanity” would be detected in these “insane” environments, and were admitted, diagnosed with schizophrenia, and ultimately discharged.


On being sane in insane places
Two matters seem to have some promise, one of which concerns the proliferation of community mental health facilities, and the need to increase the sensitivity of mental health workers and researchers to the Catch 22 position of psychiatric patients.
On pseudoscience in science, logic in remission, and psychiatric diagnosis: a critique of Rosenhan's "On being sane in insane places".
  • R. Spitzer
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Journal of abnormal psychology
  • 1975
Rosenhan's study proves that pseudopatients are not detected by psychiatrists as having simulated signs of mental illness, and this rather unremarkable finding is not relevant to the real problems of the reliability and validity of psychiatric diagnosis.
Stranger than fiction
The tale of the epic voyage made to establish the metric system is an intriguing and exciting one.
Psychology (8th ed)
  • Tavris
  • 2006
The intuitive psychologist and his shortcomings: Distortions in the attribution process. In: L Berkowitz (Ed), Advances in Experimental Social Psychology (Vol 10, pp 173–220)
  • 1977
Book's critique of psychology ignites a torrent of criticism
  • New York Times