# A Quintet of Quandaries: Five No-Go Theorems for Relational Quantum Mechanics

@article{Pienaar2021AQO, title={A Quintet of Quandaries: Five No-Go Theorems for Relational Quantum Mechanics}, author={Jacques L. Pienaar}, journal={Foundations of Physics}, year={2021} }

Relational quantum mechanics (RQM) proposes an ontology of relations between physical systems, where any system can serve as an ‘observer’ and any physical interaction between systems counts as a ‘measurement’. Quantities take unique values spontaneously in these interactions, and the occurrence of such ‘quantum events’ is strictly relative to the observing system, making them ‘relative facts’. The quantum state represents the objective information that one system has about another by virtue of…

## 16 Citations

### An attempt to understand relational quantum mechanics

- Physics
- 2022

. We search for a possible mathematical formulation of some of the key ideas of the relational interpretation of quantum mechanics and study their consequences. We also brieﬂy overview some proposals…

### Securing the objectivity of relative facts in the quantum world

- PhilosophyFoundations of Physics
- 2022

Securing the Objectivity of Relative Facts in the Quantum World Richard Healey

### Fact-nets: towards a mathematical framework for relational quantum mechanics

- Physics
- 2022

Pierre Martin-Dussaud, 2, ∗ Titouan Carette, 3, † Jan G lowacki, 4, ‡ Vaclav Zatloukal, § and Federico Zalamea 6 Institute for Gravitation and the Cosmos, The Pennsylvania State University,…

### Relational Quantum Mechanics is About Facts, Not States: A Reply to Pienaar and Brukner

- PhysicsFoundations of physics
- 2022

In recent works, Časlav Brukner and Jacques Pienaar have raised interesting objections to the relational interpretation of quantum mechanics. We answer these objections in detail and show that, far…

### (Once more) In defense of Relational Quantum Mechanics: A note on `Relative facts do not exist. Relational quantum mechanics is incompatible with quantum mechanics'

- Physics, Philosophy
- 2022

This is a short note to answer Lawrence, Markiewicz and ´Zukowski objection [see arXiv:2108.11793] to Rovelli’s theory and concerning non-contextuality.

### Relative facts do not exist. Relational Quantum Mechanics is Incompatible with Quantum Mechanics

- Physics
- 2022

Relational Quantum Mechanics poses as an interpretation of the quantum theory [see (Rovelli, 2021), to appear in the Oxford Handbook of the History of Interpretation of Quantum Physics ]. But it is…

### Perspectival Quantum Realism

- PhilosophyFoundations of Physics
- 2022

The theories of pre-quantum physics are standardly seen as representing physical systems and their properties. Quantum mechanics in its standard form is a more problematic case: here,…

### How Different Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics can Enrich Each Other: The Case of the Relational Quantum Mechanics and the Modal-Hamiltonian Interpretation

- PhysicsFoundations of Physics
- 2022

### Does Science need Intersubjectivity? The Problem of Confirmation in Orthodox Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics

- Philosophy
- 2022

What must an interpretation of quantum mechanics do in order to be considered viable? We suggest that one vitally important criterion is the following: Any successful interpretation of quantum…

### Information is Physical: Cross-Perspective Links in Relational Quantum Mechanics

- Physics
- 2022

Relational quantum mechanics (RQM) is an interpretation of quantum mechanics based on the idea that quantum states describe not an absolute property of a system but rather a relationship between…

## References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 57 REFERENCES

### Assessing relational quantum mechanics

- PhysicsSynthese
- 2022

Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) is an interpretation of quantum theory based on the idea of abolishing the notion of absolute states of systems, in favor of states of systems relative to other…

### Open Problems in Relational Quantum Mechanics

- PhilosophyJournal for General Philosophy of Science
- 2019

It is shown that it is far from clear what a relativization of states to observers exactly achieves and in what sense such an approach really advances the authors' understanding of the peculiar features of quantum phenomena, and it is argued that the claim that RQM is able to preserve locality is at best dubious.

### Can We Make Sense of Relational Quantum Mechanics?

- Philosophy
- 2018

It is claimed that there is currently no adapted locality criterion to evaluate whether the resulting interpretation is local or not, and one of its central claims concerning the possibility for an observer to have knowledge about other observer’s events is clarified.

### Rovelli’s relational quantum mechanics, anti-monism and quantum becoming

- Philosophy
- 2013

In this paper I present and defend Rovelli's relation quantum mechanics (RQM) from some foreseeable objections, so as to clarify its philosophical implications vis a vis rival interpretations. In…

### Relational quantum mechanics

- Physics
- 1996

I suggest that the common unease with taking quantum mechanics as a fundamental description of nature (the “measurement problem”) could derive from the use of an incorrect notion, as the unease with…

### The Bundle Theory Approach to Relational Quantum Mechanics

- PhilosophyFoundations of physics
- 2021

A new metaphysical interpretation of Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) in terms of mereological bundle theory is provided, claiming that a physical system in RQM can be defined as a mereological fusion of properties whose values may vary for different observers.

### A response to the Mucino-Okon-Sudarsky's Assessment of Relational Quantum Mechanics

- Physics
- 2021

The problem of quantum physics is not that we have no way of making sense of it. The problem is that we have many ways of making sense of it. But each of these comes with a high conceptual price.…

### Relational Quantum Mechanics and the Determinacy Problem

- PhysicsThe British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
- 2009

Carlo Rovelli's relational interpretation of quantum mechanics leaves us with a paradox having to do with the determinacy of measurement outcomes, which can be accepted only if the authors are willing to give up on certain elements of the ‘absolute’ view of the world.

### A Relational Formulation of Quantum Mechanics

- PhysicsScientific Reports
- 2018

Non-relativistic quantum mechanics is reformulated here based on the idea that relational properties among quantum systems, instead of the independent properties of a quantum system, are the most…

### Relational Quantum Mechanics and Probability

- PhysicsFoundations of Physics
- 2018

We present a derivation of the third postulate of relational quantum mechanics (RQM) from the properties of conditional probabilities. The first two RQM postulates are based on the information that…