A Proposal to Reduce the Age Discrimination in Canadian Minor Hockey

  title={A Proposal to Reduce the Age Discrimination in Canadian Minor Hockey},
  author={William Hurley and D. U. Lior and Steven Tracze},
  journal={Canadian Public Policy-analyse De Politiques},
There is strong relationship between birthmonth and the chance that a Canadian minor hockey player will play at an elite level. Players born in the early months of the year have an advantage. This is generally attributed to the slotting system: the way in which minor hockey groups players into age divisions. In this paper we first review the evidence. We then argue that there is more to the explanation of this relative age effect than just the slotting system; it also depends on early streaming… 

Tables from this paper

The Holdup System for Grouping Minor Hockey Participants Into Age Divisions

In almost all minor sports programs where there is early competitive stream-ing, including hockey, soccer, and baseball, players born early in the year are more likely to reach elite levels than

Equitable birthdate categorization systems for organized minor sports competition

Too Late for Talent to Kick In? The Relative Age Effect in Argentinian Male Football

Does a young football (soccer) player’s birthdate affect his prospects in the sport? Scholars have found a correlation between early births in the competition year among young players within the same

Too late for talent to kick in? The relative age effect in Argentinian male football

Does a young football (soccer) player’s birthdate affect his prospects in the sport? Scholars have found a correlation between early births in the competition year among young players within the same

Constituent year effect in international handball at high level

The criterion used by the International Handball Federation for the admission of participants in the Championships at junior levels is based on the ascription of players born during two consecutive

A behavioural dynamic model of the relative age effect

This model effectively replicates the birth month distribution of Canadian National Hockey League players when driven by Canadian birth distributions and uses this model to evaluate three policies that aim to lessen the relative age effect (RAE) in Canadian youth hockey.

A Closer Look at the Relative Age Effect in the National Hockey League

At young ages, a few extra months of development can make a big difference in size, strength, and athletic ability. A child who turns 5 years old in January will be nearly 20% older by the time a

Relative age effects in Elite Chinese soccer players: Implications of the ‘one-child’ policy

Results showed a clear and obvious RAE for all age groups with the observed birthdate distributions for each age group significantly different from expected distributions (p<0.05), and noticed a differential RAE according to the players’ position on the field as reflected in different effect sizes.

The Relative Age Effect On The Selection In The Slovakia National Football Teams

Summary The focus of this research was to determine the relative age effect (RAE) on selection in the Slovakia national football teams. A factor that may have a significant impact on the quality of

Evidence for the Relative Age Effect in the Spanish Professional Soccer League

It is concluded that the relative age effect is consistent and exists throughout Spanish soccer, whether at youth or professional levels, while in clubs the effect continued to be significantly present in all cases investigated.



Birthdate and success in minor hockey: The key to the NHL

Previous research (Barnsley, Thompson, & Barnsley, 198S) demonstrated an extremely strong linear relationship between the month of birth (from January to December) and the likelihood of playing in

“Born to Play Ball” The Relative Age Effect and Major League Baseball

The records of 837 major league baseball players were examined in order to determine whether the Little League age eligibility criterion, based on the month of birth, affected participation rate at

Does Age of Entrance Affect School Achievement?

Baer's research (2) seemed to support this conclusion. Using matched pairs of subjects who were at the same grade level, Baer matched two groups of students on the variables of sex and mental age. He

The Effect of Age at School Entry on Educational Attainment: An Application of Instrumental Variables with Moments from Two Samples

This paper tests the hypothesis that compulsory school attendance laws, which typically require school attendance until a specified birthday, induce a relationship between the years of schooling and

More on the Relative Age Effect,” Canadian Association for Health, Physical Education, and Recreation 53:21-24

  • 1987

Growth and Development in Children, 8th ed

  • New York: Year Book Medical Publishers.
  • 1986

The Novem System: a practical solution to age grouping.

“ More on the Relative Age Effect , ”

  • Canadian Association for Health , Physical Education , and Recreation
  • 1987

Hockey Success and Birthdate: The Relative Age Effect,

  • Canadian Association for Health, Physical Education, and Recreation,
  • 1985

A Review of the Need to Change the Age Divisions and/or Age

  • Determination Dates in Canadian Hockey,” report to the Canadian Hockey Association,
  • 1996