A Promise Fulfilled? Open Primaries and Representation

  title={A Promise Fulfilled? Open Primaries and Representation},
  author={Karen M. Kaufmann and James G. Gimpel and Adam H. Hoffman},
  journal={The Journal of Politics},
  pages={457 - 476}
Academics and political practitioners alike have long concerned themselves with the representativeness of primary electorates. Hoping to moderate the ideological extremity of primary voters, state parties have increasingly adopted more open primary eligibility rules. This article explores the extent to which open and modified-open primaries actually attract a more representative electorate than their closed counterparts. Using state-level exit poll data from 1988 through 2000, we compare the… 

Primary Elections and Candidate Strength in

Political parties throughout Latin America rely increasingly on primary elections to select candidates for public office. Where they are adopted, primaries are generally touted as moves toward

Bringing voters back in leader selection: the open primaries of the Italian Democratic Party

According to the penalty hypothesis, primaries are considered damaging for parties because of the social and political distinctiveness of the electorate, who usually choose unpalatable candidates for

Primaries and Candidates: Examining the Influence of Primary Electorates on Candidate Ideology*

Primary elections in the United States have been under-studied in the political science literature. Using new data to estimate the ideal points of primary election candidates and constituents, we

Institution of Nomination and the Policy Ideology of Primary Electorates

Many hypothesize that the divergence between Democratic and Republican members of Congress is partly attributable to partisan primary elections. Yet most empirical evidence on the influence of

Primaries and Candidates: Examining the Influence of Primary Electorates on Candidate Ideology

Primary elections in the United States have been under-studied in the political science literature. Using new data to estimate the ideal points of primary election candidates and constituents, we

Electoral Competition with Primaries and Quality Asymmetries

We introduce primaries—both closed and open—into a Downsian model of two-party electoral competition allowing the two candidates in each party’s primary to differ in valence as well as in policy

Why primaries? The party’s tradeoff between policy and valence

Our theory studies why and when political parties choose to hold competitive primary elections. Party leaders can decide the nomination by granting resources and endorsements to a chosen candidate.

Primaries Through the Looking Glass: The Electoral Effects of Opening the Selection of Top Candidates

Abstract This article revisits the foundations of prior research on the effects of plebiscitarian selection mechanisms on candidates' electoral strength. While previous studies do not nest political

On the Representativeness of Primary Electorates

Primary voters are frequently characterized as an ideologically extreme subset of their party, and thus partially responsible for party polarization in government. This study uses a combination of



Turnout and Representation in Presidential Primary Elections

  • A. Ranney
  • Economics
    American Political Science Review
  • 1972
This paper provides a partial test of the widely-held assumption that preference primaries are the most representative element of the presidential nominating system. It notes that the average voting

The Two Electorates: Voters and Non-Voters in a Wisconsin Primary

GNE OF THE United States' most unique political institutions, the direct primary has been studied from several different perspectives. Some political scientists have focused upon the role of party

Rules Governing Presidential Primaries

  • J. Geer
  • Political Science
    The Journal of Politics
  • 1986
Many observers of American politics have been highly critical of the proliferation of primaries that occurred in the 1970s. One of the reasons given for this unfavorable assessment is that the direct

The Representativeness of Primary Elections: Ohio, 1968

Moore and Hofstetter carry further the discussion of the representativeness of direct primary voters, commenting on the Wisconsin studies and the Amsterdam studies published in Polity in 1972. Are

Ideological Representativeness of Presidential Primary Voters

Contrary to conventional wisdom and previous research, this article finds little evidence that presidential primary voters are ideologically unrepresentative. In drawing this conclusion, two

Presidential Primaries and the Dynamics of Public Choice

This innovative study blends sophisticated statistical analyses, campaign anecdotes, and penetrating political insight to produce a fascinating exploration of one of America's most controversial

Nomination Choices: Caucus and Primary Outcomes, 1976-88

Primaries and caucuses now determine the Democratic and Republican parties' presidential nominations. While several political scientists have investigated the voting behavior of individual primary

Party Competition and the Prisoner's Dilemma: An Argument for the Direct Primary

A commonly held belief among students of American politics is that competition within political parties undermines the ability of parties to foster the democratic control of government. This essay

Uninformed Choice: The Failure of the New Presidential Nominating System. By Keeter Scott and Zukin Cliff. (New York: Praeger Publishers, 1983. Pp. xx + 247. $29.95.)

Widespread reforms since 1968 have significantly transformed the presidential nominating process. Uninformed Choice evaluates the voter's role in this new system, drawing upon survey data from the

Registration, Turnout, and the Electoral Representativeness of U.S. State Electorates

This study examines state-level political participation in an analysis that integrates registration, turnout, and the representativeness of U.S. state electorates. The authors use data aggregated