A Problem with Referendums

  title={A Problem with Referendums},
  author={Dean Lacy and Emerson M. S. Niou},
  journal={Journal of Theoretical Politics},
  pages={31 - 5}
When some voters have nonseparable preferences across multiple binary issues, majority rule may not select a Condorcet winning set of outcomes when one exists, and the social choice may be a Condorcet loser or Pareto-dominated by every other set of outcomes. We present an empirical example of one such paradox from voting on the Internet. We evaluate potential solutions to the problem of nonseparable preferences in referendums, including set-wise voting, sequential voting, and vote-trading… 

Tables from this paper

Cost-conscious voters in referendum elections
In referendum elections, voters are frequently required to register simultaneous yes/no votes on multiple proposals. The separability problem occurs when a voter’s preferred outcome on a proposal or
Pareto efficiency in multiple referendum
We consider situations of multiple referendum: finitely many yes-or-no issues have to be socially assessed from a set of approval ballots, where voters approve as many issues as they want. Each
The Mathematics of Referendum Elections and Separable Preferences
Summary Voters in referendum elections are often required to cast simultaneous ballots on several possibly related questions or proposals. The separability problem occurs when a voter's preferences
Issue-by-issue voting : an experimental evaluation
Multiple referenda consists in making a common decision about each of a set of binary issues, given the preferences of a set of voters. Asking voters for their preferences on all combinations of
Voting Behavior in One-Shot and Iterative Multiple Referenda
We consider a set of voters making a collective decision via simultaneous vote on two binary issues. Voters' preferences are captured by payoffs assigned to combinations of outcomes for each issue
Searching for a Compromise in Multiple Referendum
We consider a multiple referendum setting where voters cast approval ballots, in which they either approve or disapprove of each of finitely many dichotomous issues. A program is a set of socially
The potential of iterative voting to solve the separability problem in referendum elections
In referendum elections, voters are often required to register simultaneous votes on multiple proposals. The separability problem occurs when a voter’s preferred outcome on one proposal depends on
How Does Separability Affect The Desirability Of Referendum Election Outcomes?
Recent research has shown that in referendum elections, the presence of interdependence within voter preferences can lead to election outcomes that are undesirable and even paradoxical. However, most
Nonseparable Preferences and Issue Packaging in Elections
In this chapter we develop a model in which candidates have fixed positions on a single issue dimension on which one candidate has an advantage by being closer to the median voter. The disadvantaged
Referendum Paradox for Party-List Proportional Representation
It is shown that the outcome of PLPR may be Pareto dominated by the multiple referendum outcome defined as the issue-wise majority will in the whole electorate, known as the PLPR paradox.


Collective Choice, Separation of Issues and Vote Trading
In legislatures and committees, a number of issues are voted on separately, leading to an outcome consisting of positions on each of these issues. I investigate the effects this separation of issues
Voting on Referenda: The Separability Problem and Possible Solutions
Abstract Assume that voters choose between yes (Y) and no (N) on two related propositions in a referendum, where YN, for example, signifies voting Y on the first and N on the second. If a voter's
Vote Trading and the Voting Paradox: A Proof of Logical Equivalence
In a recent paper concerned with legislative vote trading, Riker and Brams demonstrated "... . the paradox of logrolling: that rational trades by all members [may] make everyone worse off."' In
The Paradox of Vote Trading
Although, conventionally, vote trading in legislatures has been condemned as socially undesirable by both scholars and lay citizens, a recently popular school of scholarship has argued that vote
The paradox of multiple elections
Abstract. Assume that voters must choose between voting yes (Y) and voting no (N) on three propositions on a referendum. If the winning combination is NYY on the first, second, and third
Voters in mass elections are notorious for their apparent lack of information about relevant political matters. While some scholars argue that an electorate of well-informed voters is necessary for
Structure-Induced Equilibria and Perfect-Foresight Expectations
This paper extends the work on structure-induced equilibria by explicitly considering voters' expectations. The standard assumption of myopic expectations is contrasted with the alternative
A Comparison of Efficiency of Multicandidate Electoral Systems
A variety of electoral systems for single-winner, multicandidate elections are evaluated according to their tendency to (a) select the Condorcet candidate-the candidate who could beat each of the
Yes-no voting
Yes-No (Y-N) voting is a voting method for choosing a governing coalition in a parliament after the seating of its members. Each member can designate a party to be Y (it must be included in the
The universal-instability theorem
When individual or corporate creatures with partly conflicting preferences cooperate or compromise, form an alliance or make a deal, they exchange support across issues: they support a package of