A Partisan Model of Electoral Reform

  title={A Partisan Model of Electoral Reform},
  author={Shaun Bowler and Todd Donovan},
  journal={State Politics \& Policy Quarterly},
  pages={340 - 361}
We propose a model of public response to politicized election reform. In this model, rival partisan elites send signals on the need and consequences of a proposed reform, with partisans in public adopting those positions. We apply this to test how state use of voter identification laws corresponded with public evaluations of the conduct of a state’s elections. We find that the relationship between photo identification laws and confidence in state elections was polarized and conditioned by party… 
Federalism at a partisan’s convenience: public opinion on federal intervention in 2020 election policy
ABSTRACT President Trump’s rhetoric casting doubt on the integrity of mail-in voting ignited debates about whether the federal government should be allowed to intervene in states’ policy decisions
Partisan Strategy and the Adoption of Same-Day Registration in the American States
This study seeks to explain state adoptions of same-day registration (SDR), with a focus on determining whether the Democratic (Republican) Party’s support of (resistance to) this impactful voting
Partisanship vs. Principle: Understanding Public Opinion on Same-Day Registration
Voter access has become a deeply polarized issue in American politics. It is well known that policymakers’ positions on election laws are often dictated by whether they think the laws will help
Re-Evaluating consensus in New Zealand election reform
ABSTRACT It is commonly believed that a norm of consensus-based election reform exists in New Zealand. However, this belief has yet to be tested with systematic study of changes to the democratic
Postponing the Day of Reckoning? Examining Contextual Effects on Public Support for Voter Identification Policies†
Objective This study examines the reasons why a majority of Democrats support restrictive voter identification (ID) laws, in spite of such laws clashing with stereotypical Democratic Party interests.
Partisan Predispositions and Public Support for Making It Easier to Vote
Public opinion on high-visibility election rules can be expected to reflect elite-level party divisions. We explain how partisanship affects support for, and opposition to, low-visibility convenience
Voting Experiences, Perceptions of Fraud, and Voter Confidence
Assuring voter confidence is important for the legitimacy of democratic elections. In this paper we take advantage of a large online survey of registered voters in a single election jurisdiction,
Maine ranked-choice voting as a case of electoral-system change
Ranked-choice voting (RCV) manufactures an electoral majority in a fragmented candidate field. For RCV to pass at referendum, part of a reform coalition must be willing to lose election to the other
How do voters perceive changes to the rules of the game? Evidence from the 2014 Hungarian elections
Abstract Voters often rely on partisan attachments as they evaluate new policy proposals, but does partisanship also color their interpretation of incumbent efforts to entrench themselves in power by
Immigrant Resentment and Voter Fraud Beliefs in the U.S. Electorate
Public beliefs about the frequency of voter fraud are frequently cited to support restrictive voting laws in the United States. However, some sources of public beliefs about voter fraud have received


Electoral institutions and popular confidence in electoral processes: A cross-national analysis
There is a growing interest among comparative political scientists in electoral integrity, yet little is known about what motivates citizen confidence in the electoral process. This article explores
Why Politicians Like Electoral Institutions: Self‐Interest, Values, or Ideology?
We examine whether MPs and candidates for parliament are motivated by electoral self-interest, values, ideology, or all of these when evaluating proposals for changing electoral institutions. Using
A new barrier to participation: Heterogeneous application of voter identification policies
In democratic societies there is a tension between maximizing ballot access and minimizing voter fraud. Since the 2000 presidential election, this tension has been central to discussions about
A Principle or a Strategy? Voter Identification Laws and Partisan Competition in the American States
We undertake a comprehensive examination of restrictive voter ID legislation in the American states from 2001 through 2012. With a dataset containing approximately one thousand introduced and nearly
Election administration and perceptions of fair elections
Scholars of democracy proposes an important relationship between the quality of elections and democratic legitimacy, but there are few studies of how the conduct of elections affects perceptions of
To assure pride and confidence in the electoral process
In 2000 the American electoral system was tested by a political ordeal unlike any in living memory. Not since 1876-77 has the outcome of a national election remained so unsettled for so long. The
Public Perceptions of Electoral Fairness in Russia
RUSSIANS COULD SCARCELY BE SAID TO HAVE ‘CHOSEN’ their electoral system. The 1993 constitution (Konstitutsiya 1993), itself adopted in controversial circumstances, set out no more than a few basic
Corruption, Political Allegiances, and Attitudes Toward Government in Contemporary Democracies
Using surveys conducted in sixteen mature and newly established democracies around the globe, this study examines the effect of corruption on people's attitudes toward government. The analysis
The Logic of Institutional Preferences: German Electoral Law as a Social Choice Outcome
Institutions determine the results of social decision processes, yet institutions are themselves endogenous products of earlier social choices. This paper explores the hypothesis that participants in
Perceptions of Fairness and Support for Proportional Representation
This paper explores the causes and consequences of evaluations of the political system and support for electoral system change. In 1993, New Zealand voters adopted a referendum that fundamentally