A Note on the Higher Phylogeny of Austronesian

  title={A Note on the Higher Phylogeny of Austronesian},
  author={Bodo Winter},
  journal={Oceanic Linguistics},
  pages={282 - 287}
This paper presents a critique of Sagart's (2004) classification of the Formosan languages. Sagart proposes a subgrouping based on a set of innovations in the numeral systems of the Formosan languages. These innovations entail that the higher phylogeny of Austronesian is much more hierarchical than in other subgrouping accounts (e.g., Blust 1999, Ross 2009). According to Sagart, the innovated numeral forms can be derived from the complex numerals of the Formosan language Pazeh. A number of… Expand

Tables from this paper

Sagart (2004) introduced a radical new view of the higher-level branching of Austronesian languages that has been challenged by others, but that he has continued to maintain and develop over theExpand
Some Recent Proposals Concerning the Classification of the Austronesian Languages
The comparative method is a relatively well-defined tool that has been employed successfully in the classification of languages for two centuries. In recent years, there have been several proposalsExpand
The Higher Phylogeny of Austronesian: A Response to Winter
This paper is a response to criticism by Winter in an earlier issue of this journal of Sagart’s discussion of the higher phylogeny of Austronesian. I give examples outside of Austronesian of compoundExpand
Is Puyuma a Primary Branch of Austronesian?: A Reply to Sagart
Ross (2009) proposes the Nuclear Austronesian hypothesis, according to which the Formosan languages Puyuma, Rukai, and Tsou are each probably a primary branch of Austronesian and all AustronesianExpand
Is Puyuma a Primary Branch of Austronesian?: A Rejoinder
This paper responds to recent criticism by Teng and Ross of a critique by Sagart of Ross’s claim, based on Teng’s grammar of Puyuma, that Puyuma has escaped the mechanism reinterpretingExpand
In defense of Nuclear Austronesian (and against Tsouic)
Ross (2009) proposed the Nuclear Austronesian hypothesis, whereby Puyuma, Tsou and Rukai are each single-member first-order subgroups of Austronesian and all other Austronesian languages belong to aExpand
Is Puyuma a Primary Branch of Austronesian?
Malcom Ross's new theory of early Austronesian phylogeny is examined. I describe evidence that *-en served to mark verbs in undergoer voice, patient subject, in a language ancestral to Puyuma, asExpand
The Trans-Himalayan phylum and its implications for population
The world’s second most populous language family straddles the Himalayas along the northern and southern flanks. The Trans-Himalayan language phylum has been known by various names since it was firstExpand
East Asian Ethnolinguistic Phylogeography
The Father Tongue correlation in population genetics, the evidence for refugia during the Last Glacial Maximum and the hypothesis of language families having arisen as the result of demographic bottlenecks in prehistory are shown to be crucial to an understanding of the ethnogenesis of East Asian linguistic phyla. Expand
Reconstruction of '2' in PAN and Related Issues *
It is shown that in the Formosan languages, there is a dichotomy between two sets of numeral forms, i.e. free vs. bound numerals; both sets must be reconstructed in PAN and that the core meaning of Careduplication is iterativity but has extended into marking plurality. Expand


The Higher Phylogeny of Austronesian and the Position of Tai-Kadai
This paper presents a new higher phylogeny for the Austronesian family, based on three independent lines of evidence: the observation of a hierarchy of implications among the numerals from 5 to 10 inExpand
Proto Austronesian verbal morphology: A reappraisal
In this paper I suggest that the system of verbal morphology hitherto reconstructed for Proto Austronesian (PAn) did not yet exist in PAn. Instead, the PAn system more closely resembled the pre-PAnExpand
Austronesian historical linguistics and culture history : a festschrift for Robert Blust
This book brings together new work on Austronesian historical linguistics and culture history to honour Robert Blust. The memoirs in Part 1 reflect on Blust’s groundbreaking contributions to theseExpand
Over the past two decades, much progress has been made in the study of the aboriginal languages of Taiwan. Despite these advances, many of the fifteen surviving languages remain inadequatelyExpand
Remote Melanesia: One History or Two? An Addendum to Donohue and Denham
Blust (2005) proposed that certain typological traits in the Austronesian languages of Vanuatu and New Caledonia—here called “Remote Melanesia”—suggest Papuan contact influence in situ. Given theExpand
Disyllabic attractors and anti-antigemination in Austronesian sound change*
An overview of the historical phonology of the Austronesian languages shows certain recurrent patterns of change that resemble the synchronic notion of a conspiracy. Over 90% of all lexical bases inExpand
At sixes and sevens: the development of numeral systems in Vanuatu and New Caledonia
In a review of Lynch, Ross and Crowley’s (2002) The Oceanic languages , Robert Blust went on a self-confessed ‘major digression’ (2005:5 56). He directed attention to ‘Vanuatu and southern MelanesiaExpand
The Typology of Number Borrowing in Berber
A typology of numeral borrowing in Arabic-Berber contact is set up, showing how linguistic, social, and cognitive factors all affect the process of number borrowing and how synonymy may emerge as an unstable transitional stage in the adoption of a new system. Expand
Towards Greater Accuracy in Lexicostatistic Dating
  • M. Swadesh
  • Sociology
  • International Journal of American Linguistics
  • 1955
1 Articles bearing on lexicostatistic theory and method: WALTER W. ARNDT, Germanic Dialect Evolution in Lexico-Statistic Time Perspective, University of North Carolina Doctoral Dissertation, 1955.Expand
Loanword typology: Steps toward a systematic crosslinguistic study of lexical borrowability
This paper gives an overview of some of the general issues arising when one studies lexical borrowing across languages. It discusses the motivations and goals (Section 2), kinds of loanwords (SectionExpand