A New Way to Analyze Paired Comparison Rules

@article{Saari2014ANW,
  title={A New Way to Analyze Paired Comparison Rules},
  author={Donald G. Saari},
  journal={Math. Oper. Res.},
  year={2014},
  volume={39},
  pages={647-655}
}
  • D. Saari
  • Published 6 January 2014
  • Physics
  • Math. Oper. Res.
The importance of “paired comparisons” has led to the development of several approaches. Missing is a common analytical way to compare techniques and explain properties. To do so, the approach developed here creates a “data space” coordinate system where data aspects that satisfy a strong transitivity condition are separated from those that represent “noise” as characterized by cyclic effects. With this system, paired comparison rules can be compared and paradoxical behavior explained. 

Figures from this paper

Explaining All Possible Paired Comparison Problems

For centuries, cycles and other anomalies have hindered the use of paired comparisons, whether it be in decision theory, voting, economics, engineering, statistics, and on and on. It is shown here

Seeking consistency with paired comparisons: a systems approach

  • D. Saari
  • Mathematics
    Theory and Decision
  • 2021
It is well known that decision methods based on pairwise rankings can suffer from a wide range of difficulties. These problems are addressed here by treating the methods as systems, where each pair

Social science puzzles: a systems analysis challenge

A common source for a wide range of problems and complexities that arise in the social sciences is an unexpected loss of needed information, but by identifying the content of the lost information, negative assertions may be replaced with positive conclusions.

The linear algebra of pairwise comparisons

Arrow, and unexpected consequences of his theorem

A new way to interpret Arrow’s impossibility theorem leads to valued insights that extend beyond voting and social choice to address other mysteries ranging from the social sciences to even the “dark

The PerronRank family: a brief review

It is shown that HodgeRank and TropicalRank are limits of PerronRank, hence the methods belong to the same family, and their implications in practice are discussed, and some open problems are states.

From Arrow’s Theorem to ‘Dark Matter’

  • D. Saari
  • Economics
    British Journal of Political Science
  • 2015
Arrow’s Impossibility Theorem and Sen’s Minimal Liberalism example impose ‘impossibility’ roadblocks on progress. A reinterpretation explained in this article exposes what causes these negative

HodgeRank Is the Limit of Perron Rank

  • N. Tran
  • Mathematics, Computer Science
    Math. Oper. Res.
  • 2016
It is shown that HodgeRank (row geometric mean), is the limit of Perron Rank (ranking with principal eigenvector) as a certain parameter k goes to 0.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 17 REFERENCES

Symmetry of Nonparametric Statistical Tests on Three Samples

Problem statement: Many different nonparametric statistical procedures can be used to analyze ranked data. Inconsistencies among the outcomes of such procedures can occur when analyzing the same

Mathematical structure of voting paradoxes

P pairwise voting is described where new results include explanations for all paradoxes, cycles, conflict between Borda and Condorcet rankings, differences among procedures using pairwise votes, and discrepancies among the societal rankings as candidates are dropped or added.

Are partwise comparisons reliable?

This work identifies an alternative, closely related decision approach that eliminates problems caused by the nature of the lost information, and shows how to compute the likelihood that an incorrect outcome will occur.

ARE PART WISE COMPARISONS RELIABLE ?

This work identifies an alternative, closely related decision approach that eliminates problems caused by the nature of the lost information, and shows how to compute the likelihood that an incorrect outcome will occur.

Dictionaries of Paradoxes for Statistical Tests on k Samples

Abstract A relationship between the Kruskal–Wallis nonparametric statistical test on k samples and the Borda positional method for voting is established and then exploited to gain a complete analysis

Disposing dictators, demystifying voting paradoxes

  • D. Saari
  • Philosophy
    Math. Comput. Model.
  • 2008

Matrix analysis

This new edition of the acclaimed text presents results of both classic and recent matrix analyses using canonical forms as a unifying theme, and demonstrates their importance in a variety of applications.

Social Choice and Individual Values

Originally published in 1951, Social Choice and Individual Values introduced "Arrow's Impossibility Theorem" and founded the field of social choice theory in economics and political science. This new