A Hegelian realist constructivist account of war, identity, and state formation

  title={A Hegelian realist constructivist account of war, identity, and state formation},
  author={Joseph MacKay and Jamie Levin},
  journal={Journal of International Relations and Development},
  • Joseph MacKay, J. Levin
  • Published 29 January 2018
  • Political Science
  • Journal of International Relations and Development
This article offers a realist constructivist account of armed conflict, based on the work of Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel. Hegel has received relatively little attention in mainstream IR theory. When he has been read, four readings have predominated: realist, liberal, critical, and normative. Instead, we link his thought to both realism and constructivism. For Hegel, a persistent struggle for recognition and identity between individuals and groups drives much of human interaction. In his… 
Hegel in a postcolonial world: Populist authoritarianism, postcolonialism, and the master–slave dialectic
The paper seeks to offer a Hegelian-inspired normative explanation of the utilization of postcolonial arguments by authoritarian states to challenge Western norms. In the last decades, several
Challenging the association of Hegel with political realism: the contribution of Hegel’s methodological insights to a critique of realism and a richer understanding of war and statehood
This paper challenges the association of Hegel with political realism. Many approaches rely predominantly on the Philosophy of Right ’s third part (the State) and on the Phenomenology of Spirit ’s
The conduct of history in International Relations: rethinking philosophy of history in IR theory
IR scholars have made increasingly sophisticated use of historical analysis in the last two decades. To do so, they have appealed to theories or philosophies of history, tacitly or explicitly.


Power in Realist‐Constructivist Research
Samuel Barkin is correct: constructivism and realism do have more to say to each other than the IR literature might lead one to think. What is unclear, however, is the extent to which Barkin has
Constructivist Realism or Realist‐Constructivism?
In his article “Realist Constructivism,”Barkin (2003:338) described constructivism as a cluster of research methods and analytical tools: a “set of assumptions about how to study world politics”
Modernity, Freedom, and the State: Hegel's Concept of Patriotism
Hegel's concept of patriotism helps specify an account of the just association of collective identity and state power. This concept has three main features. First, as a distinctly modern virtue,
The Hegelian state and International polities
It is a characteristic of political theory and international politics that certain well worn stereotypes are perennially wheeled out for generations of students. Some of these may be useful landmarks
Speaking and hearing' Habermasian discourse ethics, feminism and IR
It is impossible not to encounter Habermas as an important interlocutor in the fields of critical theory, feminist theory and international relations theory across which I work. He is the outstanding
Hegel, Marx, and the Concept of Immanent Critique
WITH OTHERS, MARX criticizes Hegel's Philosophy of Right for its apologetic stance regarding the status quo. For Marx as well, Hegel's political thought dogmatically assigns rationality to existing
Hegel and International Ethics
The collapse of the Eastern European communist regimes led to a re-evaluation of Hegel's philosophies as inspiration for shaping the post-communist governments. Concerned that the reappearance of
Hegel's Views on War, the State, and International Relations
In this article I argue a thesis about Hegel's views on war different from most previous interpreters, e.g., Popper and Hook on the one side and A vineri and Pelczynski on the other. In particular I
Liberal-Idealism: A Constructivist Critique
Recently, scholars have connected US constructivism to liberal-idealism. International relations theorists have branded US constructivists as “liberal theorists” for three notable reasons: (1)