A Distinction Without a Difference? Examining the Causal Pathways Behind Ideologically Motivated Mass Public Shootings

  title={A Distinction Without a Difference? Examining the Causal Pathways Behind Ideologically Motivated Mass Public Shootings},
  author={Joel A. Capellan and Alexei Anisin},
  journal={Homicide Studies},
  pages={235 - 255}
This study utilizes crisp-set qualitative comparative analysis to assess 306 mass shootings. We compare non-extremist and extremist mass shooters according to characteristics that capture mental health histories of offenders, their grievances, and strains. We discover that offenders who sympathized with extremism were driven by grievance against a social group and were suffering from either mental health issues or from general strain. Extremist sympathizers differ from non-extremists in the… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Mass shootings and their asymmetric effect on societal armament
  • A. Anisin
  • Sociology
    Crime, Law and Social Change
  • 2019
Mixed evidence has been found for a positive relationship between mass shootings and civilian armament. This study suggests that the causal effect of mass shootings on subsequent societal gun
Disaggregating Mass Public Shootings: A Comparative Analysis of Disgruntled Employee, School, Ideologically motivated, and Rampage Shooters
The results show that ideologically motivated shooters to be the most patient, and methodical, and as a result the most lethal shooters, while disgruntled employees, who are driven by revenge, tend to have little time to plan and consequently are the least lethal shooters.
Similar crimes, similar behaviors? Comparing lone‐actor terrorists and public mass murderers
The data inform the emerging idea that lone-actor terrorists and public mass shooters are not distinct offender types, and show little distinction in sociodemographic profiles, but significant differences in antecedent event behaviors.
Shared Struggles? Cumulative Strain Theory and Public Mass Murderers From 1990 to 2014
Scholars have urged a shift in research on mass murder from the creation of typologies to theoretically rich, data-driven comparative examinations of the phenomenon. We seek to redress such calls in
#NEVERAGAIN: Framing in Community and National News Coverage of the Parkland Mass Shootings
ABSTRACT This study examined the salience and valence of frames in community and national newspaper coverage of the 2018 Parkland shootings, after which several survivors became well-known activists.
Disaggregating Lone-actor Grievance-fuelled Violence: Comparing Lone-actor Terrorists and Mass Murderers
ABSTRACT Research suggests that lone-actor terrorists and mass murderers may be better conceptualized as lone-actor grievance-fueled violence (LAGFV) offenders, rather than as distinct types. The
An Investigation of Mass Public Shooting Attacks Against Government Targets in the United States
Abstract The current study examines mass public shooters who target government agents and institutions in the United States. This research uses a rational choice perspective to examine the incidence,
Exogenous events and media reporting of mass shootings
ABSTRACT A growing literature has revealed that not all mass shootings are covered equally by the media. Thus far, endogenous and contextual characteristics of mass shootings have been causally
Systematic Review of Mental Health Problems and Violent Extremism
ABSTRACT This systematic review assesses the impact of mental health problems upon attitudes, intentions and behaviours in the context of radicalisation and terrorism. We identified 25 studies that
Lone Wolf Riots: Social Frustration & U.S. Mass Violence
Through various life events and circumstances, some individuals find themselves at a disconnect with their surroundings—unable to relate to peers, socially awkward, and socially isolated and outcast.


Lone Wolf Terrorist or Deranged Shooter? A Study of Ideological Active Shooter Events in the United States, 1970–2014
This study explores the threat of ideological active shooter attacks in the United States. In particular, to understand if these events constitute a new brand of “lone wolf terrorism” or if they are
Routine Activities and Right-Wing Extremists: An Empirical Comparison of the Victims of Ideologically- and Non-Ideologically-Motivated Homicides Committed by American Far-Rightists
This study examines whether Criminology's Routine Activities Theory (RAT) and related Lifestyle Theory (LST) can account for variation between the attributes of victims of fatal ideologically
Distinguishing “Loner” Attacks from Other Domestic Extremist Violence
Research Summary Recent reports have suggested that “loner” extremists, or self-radicalized extremists with no ties to organized groups who commit an ideologically motivated attack on their own,
A Comparative Analysis of Suicide Terrorists and Rampage, Workplace, and School Shooters in the United States From 1990 to 2010
Results suggest that in the United States from 1990 to 2010, the differences between these offenders were largely superficial, and patterns among all four types of offenders can assist those developing security policy, conducting threat assessments, and attempting to intervene in the lives of at-risk individuals.
Characteristics of Lone-Wolf Violent Offenders: a Comparison of Assassins and School Attackers
This article is based on the idea that lone-wolf terrorists may have characteristics in common with two other types of lone-actor violent offenders:  assassins and school attackers.  We used data
The violent true believer as a "lone wolf" - psychoanalytic perspectives on terrorism.
The existing research on lone wolf terrorists and case experience are reviewed and interpreted through the lens of psychoanalytic theory, finding greater creativity and innovation than terrorist groups.
From Profiles to Pathways and Roots to Routes: Perspectives from Psychology on Radicalization into Terrorism
Attempts to profile terrorists have failed resoundingly, leaving behind a poor (and unfair) impression of the potential for a sound psychological contribution to understanding the terrorist. However,
Mass Murder: An Analysis of Extreme Violence
Mass murder involves the slaughter of four or more victims by one or a few assailants within a single event, lasting but a few minutes or as long as several hours. More than just arbitrary, using