A Critique of the Arguments for Maragha Influence on Copernicus

@article{Blsj2014ACO,
  title={A Critique of the Arguments for Maragha Influence on Copernicus},
  author={Viktor Bl{\aa}sj{\"o}},
  journal={Journal for the History of Astronomy},
  year={2014},
  volume={45},
  pages={183 - 195}
}
  • Viktor Blåsjö
  • Published 15 April 2014
  • Physics
  • Journal for the History of Astronomy
(ProQuest: ... denotes formulae omitted.)1. IntroductionCopernicus's planetary models exhibit some striking similarities to those of late medieval Islamic astronomers. On this basis many have concluded that he must have been influenced by them.1 We claim that no good evidence for this inference exists. Certainly there is no direct trace of it in the documentary record: the sources Copernicus supposedly copied from are not cited by him or any of his European contemporaries - despite the fact… 

Figures from this paper

A rebuttal of recent arguments for Maragha influence on Copernicus

I reply to recent arguments by Peter Barker & Tofigh Heidarzadeh, Arun Bala, and F. Jamil Ragep claiming that certain aspects Copernicus’s astronomical models where influenced by late Islamic authors

NOTES ON THE TRANSMISSION OF PTOLEMY’S ALMAGEST THE ERA OF COPERNICUS

We trace the transmission of Ptolemy‘s Almagest from the time of its composition to Arabic translations, Latin translations, and the Epitome of the Almagest by Peurbach and Regiomontanus. Along the

Birkenmajer's Copernicus: Historical Context, Original Insights, and Contributions to Current Debates

By means of a more critical assessment of his interpretation, the essay revises earlier accounts, rescuing the original insights that mark Birkenmajer's most important contributions to current debates and his efforts to reconstruct Copernicus's path to heliocentrism.

A ciência árabe na Europa renascentista: a tradição hay’a e a astronomia europeia

Tese de mestrado, Historia e Filosofia das Ciencias, Universidade de Lisboa, Faculdade de Ciencias, 2019

What we Teach in Science, and What Learners Learn: A Gap that Needs Bridging

As long has been known, there is no perfect way to teach science. This paper makes no claim to be the ‘be-all and end-all’ of science education. Rather it critically examines what we teach learners

Narratio prima. Relacja pierwsza z ksiąg O obrotach Mikołaja Kopernika

nomią Mikołaja Kopernika. Paradoksalnie to nie on obwieścił ów przewrót w astronomii, lecz młody luterański matematyk z Wittenbergi, Jerzy Joachim Retyk, publikując swoją Relację pierwszą z ksiąg O

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 12 REFERENCES

Copernicus and His Islamic Predecessors: Some Historical Remarks

Based upon research over the past half century, there has been a growing recognition that a number of mathematical models used by Copernicus had originally been developed by Islamic astronomers. This

COPERNICUS, THE MAN, THE WORK, AND ITS HISTORY

To THE MODERN SCIENTIST, the primary criterion for the quality of a theory is its capability of representing known experimental and observational facts and of predicting new facts, unknown at the

Copernicus and Astrology, with an Appendix1 of Translations of Primary Sources

Robert Westman’s massive book—The Copernican Question. Prognostication, Skepticism, and Celestial Order. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2011. xviii 681 pp. (double columns), 85 b&w

Islamic Science and the Making of the European Renaissance

wealthy and had careers in Parliament, none of the members of the family were particularly distinctive or famous. Rather, Rothschild focuses on this extended family to illuminate how the

The Solar and Lunar Theory of Ibn ash-Shāṭir: A Pre-Copernican Copernican Model

THE purpose of this note is to present the solar and lunar theory developed by the Damascene astronomer, Ibn ash-Shatir (I304-I375/6 A.D.) 1 in his Kitdb Nihdyat as-Suil fi TashTh al-UEul (A Text of

This concerns works that were available in Latin translation. All parties agree that Copernicus most likely could not read Arabic

    the relation between the models is so close that independent discovery by Copernicus is all but impossible

    • Encyclopedia of the Scientific Revolution
    • 1984

    See this work as well as Swerdlow, op. cit. (ref. 4), and Otto Neugebauer

    • 1968