A Critique of Effects-Based Thinking

@article{Storr2005ACO,
  title={A Critique of Effects-Based Thinking},
  author={J. Storr},
  journal={The RUSI Journal},
  year={2005},
  volume={150},
  pages={32 - 35}
}
  • J. Storr
  • Published 1 December 2005
  • Sociology
  • The RUSI Journal
At the time of writing, Lieutenant Co[onel Jim Storr PhD was serving with Unitedstates European Commandin Stuttgart, Germany. The views expressed in this article are his own. They do not necessariiyreflect the views of the British Army or the Ministry ofDefence. Much ink has been spilt on the subject of effects-based operations, effectsbased thinking and a cluster of related neo1ogisms.A number of conferences have been held, and no doubt much hot air generated. However, little consensus or… Expand
Scrutinising effects-based operations: On military genius, causality and friction in war
The article scrutinises a very timely phenomenon, effects-based operations. The concept has been the subject to much heated debates among the practitioners and theorists of war. By using two classicsExpand
From effects-based operations to effects-based force : on causality, complex adaptive system and the the biology of war
TLDR
The author addresses a recent force employment concept called effects-based operations, which first appeared during the 1991 war against Iraq, and suggests an organic approach to address the challenge posed by war. Expand
Communications and cohesion: a comparison between two command and control paradigms
TLDR
The object of the study was to use social network and simple time series analysis to test the assumption that organisational design factors can lead to systematic changes in the quantity, structure and type of communication. Expand
Sociotechnical Theory and NEC System Design
TLDR
This paper shows how the specification of a set of basic sociotechnical principles could help to create the initial conditions from which shared awareness and agility create self-synchronization (synergy, with simple organizations undertaking more complex tasks). Expand
Operations planning revisited: theoretical and practical implications of methodology
TLDR
Part of NATO’s contemporary planning framework, the comprehensive operations planning directive (COPD), and parts of the operation-level planning process should be revised since they suffer from methodological inconsistency, according to a “handbook of methodology” recommended to develop. Expand
Socio-technical interoperability in multi-agency operations
Interoperability is seen as directly influencing the combat effectiveness of multinational forces, acting as a ‘force multiplier’ that brings strategic, operational and tactical advantages (NATO,Expand
ICCRTS COALITION COMMAND AND CONTROL IN THE NETWORKED ERA Title : ISTAR and C 2 – A Holistic
(DSTL/QinetiQ Paper #4) The common-sense application of communications and information technologies to C2 and ISTAR has had some notable successes, but no longer seems to be giving the desiredExpand
Not as simple as it looks: led outdoor activities are complex sociotechnical systems
ABSTRACT Recent research is providing valuable insights into safety by applying sociotechnical systems (STS) theory to led outdoor activity (LOA) work systems. The LOA domain involves provision ofExpand
COALITION COMMAND AND CONTROL IN THE NETWORKED ERA
TLDR
It is argued that broadcast-based SRSs, such as the Automatic Identification System (AIS), offer significant advantages over traditional sensor-based vessel tracking and that availability of information from S RSs will impact how command decisions related to MDA are made in the future. Expand