A Contest for Legitimacy: The Divestment Movement and the Fossil Fuel Industry

  title={A Contest for Legitimacy: The Divestment Movement and the Fossil Fuel Industry},
  author={Julie Ayling},
  journal={Sustainability Law \& Policy eJournal},
  • Julie Ayling
  • Published 10 August 2017
  • Sociology
  • Sustainability Law & Policy eJournal
The divestment movement has sought to influence attitudes to fossil fuels by framing producer companies as pariahs and as unnecessary and redundant. In response, the fossil fuel industry has engaged in a direct and aggressive attack on the divestment movement. This article considers the relationship between the movement and the industry as a contest for legitimacy for both the organizations and the norms they advocate. Through a case study of the coal discourse in Australia from 2013 to 2016… 

Divesting from Climate Change: The Road to Influence

Is fossil fuels divestment likely to achieve its aims? This article evaluates the rationales for divestment in terms of their capacity to give the campaign influence. It focuses on the direct effects

Impacts of the Fossil Fuel Divestment Movement: Effects on Finance, Policy and Public Discourse

The fossil fuel divestment movement campaigns for removing investments from fossil fuel companies as a strategy to combat climate change. It is a bottom-up movement, largely based in university

Shadows of Divestment: The Complications of Diverting Fossil Fuel Finance

  • K. Neville
  • Economics
    Global Environmental Politics
  • 2020
This forum article offers a critical assessment of the strategy of divestment from fossil fuels as climate action, considering the unintended or spillover consequences of reinvestment in other

Anti-fossil fuel norms

Historically, climate governance initiatives and associated scholarship have all but ignored the potential for “global moral norms” to bring about changes in the political conditions for global

Campus Fossil Fuel Divestment (CFFD) Counter-Repertoires

Under the contentious politics theoretical framework the actions of activists are understood metaphorically as a particular set of 'performances' drawn from a broader potential 'repertoire.' The

More planet and less profit? The ethical dilemma of an oil producing nation

Abstract Every oil producing nation is confronted with a complex and fundamental ethical dilemma. On the one hand, there are moral arguments for the nation to use the petroleum resource for the

Fossil fuel divestment: theories of change, goals, and strategies of a growing climate movement

ABSTRACT The fossil fuel divestment movement has developed into an offshoot of the climate change movement in recent years. The movement has become increasingly effective at stigmatizing the fossil



Non-state governance and climate policy: the fossil fuel divestment movement

This article charts the evolution of the divestment movement, a transnational advocacy network that uses a range of strategies to shame, pressure, facilitate, and encourage investors in general, and

Strategic Activism and Nonmarket Strategy

Activist NGOs have increasingly foregone public politics and turned to private politics to change the practices of firms and industries. This paper focuses on private politics, activist strategies,

Can non-state global governance be legitimate? An analytical framework

In the absence of effective national and intergovernmental regulation to ameliorate global environmental and social problems, “private” alternatives have proliferated, including self-regulation,

Constructing and Contesting Legitimacy and Accountability in Polycentric Regulatory Regimes

The legitimacy and accountability of polycentric regulatory regimes, particularly at the transnational level, has been severely criticised, and the search is on to find ways in which they can be

Legitimacy, Institutional Design, and Dispute Settlement: The Case of Eco-Certification Systems

Abstract Certification is becoming a significant global governance instrument for regulating transnational supply chains. The article analyses more than 400 eco-certification systems (CS) on three

Multi-Stakeholder Partnerships for Sustainable Development: Rethinking Legitimacy, Accountability and Effectiveness

The role of transnational partnerships in contemporary global environmental discourse raises larger questions of the legitimacy, effectiveness and accountability of networked governance. This article

The edge of legitimacy: voluntary social and environmental reporting in Rothmans' 1956 - 1999 annual reports

Purpose - The purpose of this paper is to examine the voluntary social and environmental disclosures made in the annual reports of Rothmans Ltd between the years of 1955 and 1999. The first part of

Social Movement Theory and the Prospects for Climate Change Activism in the United States

The issue of climate change poses something of a puzzle. For all the attention accorded the issue, climate change/global warming has spawned surprisingly little grassroots activism in the

When Institutions Fail: Legitimacy, (De)legitimation, and the Failure of Private Governance Systems

Why do institutions fail? With a focus on non-state market-driven governance, this paper explores the failures of the Flower Label Program and the Marine Aquarium Council. To date, research on

Multi-Stakeholder Governance and Voluntary Programme Interactions: Legitimation Politics in the Institutional Design of Corporate Social Responsibility

A variety of innovative institutional forms have emerged within the context of voluntary attempts to address pressing social and environmental issues. Among such institutions, the prevailing wisdom