A Conservative’s View from the Academic Trenches: Reply to Duarte, Crawford, Stern, Haidt, Jussim, and Tetlock (2015)

  title={A Conservative’s View from the Academic Trenches: Reply to Duarte, Crawford, Stern, Haidt, Jussim, and Tetlock (2015)},
  author={Walter Richard Schumm},
  journal={Journal of Behavioral and Brain Science},
  • W. Schumm
  • Published 8 April 2016
  • Education
  • Journal of Behavioral and Brain Science
Although conservative scholars may face a variety of forms of discrimination in academia and other challenges, as elaborated in the first part of this comment, they may also have a set of unique advantages that may facilitate more careful theoretical and empirical scientific work. They may be more sensitive to flawed methodologies in some areas of controversy. In such areas, these assets of conservative scholars may be especially important. 
Reply to Cameron et al.: Mistakes Were Made. Can They Be Corrected?
ABSTRACT Cameron, Cameron, and Proctor (2017) have complained that Cameron and Cameron (1996) were not cited in some articles authored by this journal’s editor. As part of this editor’s policy of
A Review and Critique of Research on Same-Sex Parenting and Adoption
  • W. Schumm
  • Psychology
    Psychological reports
  • 2016
Relationship instability appears to be higher among gay and lesbian parent couples and may be a key mediating factor influencing outcomes for children, and relationship instability in same-sex adoption is higher.


Liberal Privilege in Academic Psychology and the Social Sciences
  • L. Jussim
  • Education
    Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science
  • 2012
This comment refutes (or, at least, vigorously contests) some of the most common arguments that have attempted to defend social psychology from charges of unscientific and distorting liberal biases.
Likes Attract
  • R. E. Redding
  • Psychology, Sociology
    Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science
  • 2012
Recent research suggests that the assumptions underlying psychology’s value system of promoting racial, ethnic, gender, or sexual orientation diversity—that is, that doing so recognizes people�'s personal identities, ameliorates discrimination, and has educational benefits—may be all the more compelling with respect to sociopolitical ideas.
The Anatomy of a Divorce
When there are so many challenges to women’s bodily and reproductive autonomy, it is difficult to select a case that serves as a metonym for the ongoing, everyday war on women that is waged in what
Lessons for the "devilish statistical obfuscator," or how to argue for a null hypothesis: A guide for students, attorneys, and other professionals
Students, lawyers, and other professionals are sometimes unfamiliar with scientific methodology or the proper use of statistics. Even so, it is likely that they will confront attempts to use social
It may be harder than we thought, but political diversity will (still) improve social psychological science.
It is argued that increasing political diversity in social psychology may be harder than previously thought, but it is still believed that it is possible and desirable to do so.
Unmarried Cohabitation: Options, Limits and Possibilities
SynopsisUsing data from Australian and overseas longitudinal studies extending over a quarter of a century, this paper (a) explores the construction and ideological Justification of liberation and
More Heat Than Light: A Critical Assessment of the Same-Sex Parenting Literature, 1995–2013
Regardless of what science ultimately demonstrates about same-sex family structure, it is important to safeguard the research process from political pressures: either anti-gay marriage or pro-gay rights.
Re-examining a Landmark Research Study: A Teaching Editorial
A landmark research study from the 1950s was reanalyzed. Part of the study's results were confirmed, but other parts were found to have been incompletely analyzed and therefore incorrectly reported.
The Aged and Their Families: Towards Integration
The paper discusses the attitudes of 1484 British-Australians, 267 Greek-Australians, and 146 German-Australians regarding the integration of the aged in their kinship and the community. The paper
Husband abuse: fact or fiction
During the last thirty years, ideologies, theories and policies relating to domestic violence have changed radically. As a result of this, community concern and state policies shifted considerably