A Conceptual Review of Decision Making in Social Dilemmas: Applying a Logic of Appropriateness

  title={A Conceptual Review of Decision Making in Social Dilemmas: Applying a Logic of Appropriateness},
  author={Jonathan Weber and Shirli Kopelman and David M. Messick},
  journal={Personality and Social Psychology Review},
  pages={281 - 307}
Despite decades of experimental social dilemma research, “theoretical integration has proven elusive” (Smithson & Foddy, 1999, p. 14). To advance a theory of decision making in social dilemmas, this article provides a conceptual review of the literature that applies a “logic of appropriateness” (March, 1994) framework. The appropriateness framework suggests that people making decisions ask themselves (explicitly or implicitly), “What does a person like me do in a situation like this?” This… 

Figures from this paper

Applying a logic of appropriateness to understand behavioral differences between common resource dilemmas and public good dilemmas
Correspondence Welmer E. Molenmaker, Social, Economic and Organisational Psychology Unit, Institute of Psychology, Leiden University, P.O. Box 9555, 2300 RB Leiden, The Netherlands. Email:
The Herdsman and the Sheep, Mouton, or Kivsa? The Influence of Group Culture on Cooperation in Social Dilemmas
This chapter suggests that it is important to incorporate the concept of culture into both the theoretical frameworks and the empirical research on cooperation in social dilemmas. It proposes a
Effective Matrices, Decision Frames, and Cooperation in Volunteer Dilemmas: A Theoretical Perspective on Academic Peer Review
The importance of frame analysis for understanding volunteer dilemmas is addressed and some “obvious” solutions to the volunteer dilemma of reviewing may have paradoxical effects on reviewer cooperation if such frames are not considered.
Bringing the Logic of Appropriateness into the Lab: An Experimental Study of Behavior and Cognition
The logic of consequences and the logic of appropriateness have long been central to understanding behavior in organizations. However, scholarly work on the logic of appropriateness has consisted
Which efficacy constructs for large-scale social dilemma problems? Individual and collective forms of efficacy and outcome expectancies in the context of climate change mitigation
Effective management of climate change risk requires an understanding of how to encourage positive behaviour change at the collective level. The urgency of the problem and the social dilemma nature
Essays on Making Interdependent Decisions and Their Evaluations
Title of Document: ESSAYS ON MAKING INTERDEPENDENT DECISIONS AND THEIR EVALUATIONS. Shweta S. Oza, Doctor of Philosophy, 2007. Directed By: Prof. Joydeep Srivastava, Department of Marketing This
Promoting Cooperation in Social Dilemmas via Fairness Norms and Group Goals
In everyday life, people often encounter situations where their personal interests are at odds with the welfare of a larger collective to which they belong. What seems to be an individually rational


Management Dilemmas and Decisions
This study assesses the impact of decision framing and the anticipated behavior of others on choosing to cooperate in social dilemma problems. Two hundred and eighty-eight students completed a
SOCIAL DILEMMAS: The Anatomy of Cooperation
The study of social dilemmas is the study of the tension between individual and collective rationality. In a social dilemma, individually reasonable behavior leads to a situation in which everyone is
The Emergence of Norms in Competitive Decision-Making Groups.
Kenneth Bettenhausen and J. Keith Murnighan This paper examines the development of norms in newly formed groups. The behavior of 19 decision-making groups provided the basis for a model of norm
A Social Categorization Explanation for Framing Effects in Nested Social Dilemmas.
Using self-categorization theory, it is predicted that members of a collective would cooperate more when they faced homogeneous rather than heterogeneous resource frames and social categorization processes provide a parsimonious explanation for the observed pattern of allocations.
A primer on decision making : how decisions happen
James G. March draws on research from all the disciplines of social and behavioural science to show decision making in its broadest context, and explains key concepts of vital importance to decision makers, such as limited rationality, history-dependent rules, and ambiguity.
Social Norms and Cooperation in Social Dilemmas: The Effects of Context and Feedback.
  • Pillutla, Chen
  • Psychology, Economics
    Organizational behavior and human decision processes
  • 1999
The hypothesis that people behave more competitively in social dilemmas involving economic decisions compared to those involving noneconomic decisions and that people would compete more if they see that others have unexpectedly competed in a prior situation and cooperate more when others have unexpected cooperated in a previous situation is proposed.
Resolving Social Dilemmas : Dynamic, Structural, and Intergroup Aspects
M. Foddy, M. Smithson, Theories and Strategies for Studying Social Dilemmas. Part I. Formal Models and Dynamic Systems Approaches. M. Smithson, Taking Exogenous Dynamics Seriously in Public Goods and
Elastic Justification: How Tempting But Task-Irrelevant Factors Influence Decisions
This research is concerned with task-oriented decision situations where the decision maker faces two options, one superior on a factor directly related to the given task (called the A factor) and the
Might over Morality : Social Values and the Perception of Other Players in Experimental Games
Previous research on social values indicates that individuals' own choices as well as their expectations of others' choices in outcome-interdependent situations varies as a function of the weight
Cognitions and behavior in asymmetric social dilemmas: a comparison of two cultures.
Results indicated that, as predicted, groups of decision makers from Japan were more cooperative, expected others to be more Cooperative, and were more likely to adopt an equal allocation distribution rule to resolve the dilemma.