A Comparison of State-Based Modelling Tools for Model Validation


In model-based testing, one of the biggest decisions taken before modelling is the modelling language and the model analysis tool to be used to model the system under investigation. UML, Alloy and Z are examples of popular state-based modelling languages. In the literature, there has been research about the similarities and the differences between modelling languages. However, we believe that, in addition to recognising the expressive power of modelling languages, it is crucial to detect the capabilities and the weaknesses of analysis tools that parse and analyse models written in these languages. In order to explore this area, we have chosen four model analysis tools: USE, Alloy Analyzer, ZLive and ProZ and observed how modelling and validation stages of MBT are handled by these tools for the same system. Through this experiment, we not only concretise the tasks that form the modelling and validation stages of MBT process, but also reveal how efficiently these tasks are carried out in different tools.

DOI: 10.1007/978-3-540-69824-1_16

9 Figures and Tables

Cite this paper

@inproceedings{Aydal2008ACO, title={A Comparison of State-Based Modelling Tools for Model Validation}, author={Emine Gokce Aydal and Mark Utting and Jim Woodcock}, booktitle={TOOLS}, year={2008} }