• DOI:10.1080/10807030802387556
• Corpus ID: 110522982

A Comparative Analysis of Accident Risks in Fossil, Hydro, and Nuclear Energy Chains

@article{Burgherr2008ACA,
  title={A Comparative Analysis of Accident Risks in Fossil, Hydro, and Nuclear Energy Chains},
  author={Peter Burgherr and Stefan Hirschberg},
  journal={Human and Ecological Risk Assessment: An International Journal},
  year={2008},
  volume={14},
  pages={947 - 973}
}

• P. Burgherr, S. Hirschberg
• Published 9 October 2008
• Engineering
• Human and Ecological Risk Assessment: An International Journal

ABSTRACT This study presents a comparative assessment of severe accident risks in the energy sector, based on the historical experience of fossil (coal, oil, natural gas, and LPG [Liquefied Petroleum Gas]) and hydro chains contained in the comprehensive Energy-related Severe Accident Database (ENSAD), as well as Probabilistic Safety Assessment (PSA) for the nuclear chain. Full energy chains were considered because accidents can take place at every stage of the chain. Comparative analyses for the years 1969–2000 included a total of 1870 severe (≥ 5 fatalities) accidents, amounting to 81,258 fatalities. Although 79.1% of all accidents and 88.9% of associated fatalities occurred in less developed, non-OECD countries, industrialized OECD countries dominated insured losses (78.0%), reflecting their substantially higher insurance density and stricter safety regulations. Aggregated indicators and frequency-consequence (F-N) curves showed that energy-related accident risks in non-OECD countries are distinctly higher than in OECD countries. Hydropower in non-OECD countries and upstream stages within fossil energy chains are most accident-prone. Expected fatality rates are lowest for Western hydropower and nuclear power plants; however, the maximum credible consequences can be very large. Total economic damages due to severe accidents are substantial, but small when compared with natural disasters. Similarly, external costs associated with severe accidents are generally much smaller than monetized damages caused by air pollution.