# A Clarification on the Debate on "the Original Schwarzschild Solution"

@article{Corda2011ACO, title={A Clarification on the Debate on "the Original Schwarzschild Solution"}, author={Christian Corda}, journal={arXiv: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology}, year={2011} }

Now that English translations of Schwarzschild's original paper exist, that paper has become accessible to more people. Historically, the so-called "standard Schwarzschild solution" was not the original Schwarzschild's work, but it is actually due to J. Droste and, independently, H. Weyl, while it has been ultimately enabled like correct solution by D. Hilbert. Based on this, there are authors who claim that the work of Hilbert was wrong and that Hilbert's mistake spawned black-holes and the…

## 9 Citations

The Schwarzschild Solution: A Reply to C. Corda's Rebuttal

- Physics
- 2016

In 2011 a paper by C. Corda was published in the Electronic Journal of Theoretical Physics (A Clarification on the Debate on “the Original Schwarzschild Solution'', EJTP 8, No. 25 (2011) 65-82). On…

On Corda's 'Clarification' of Schwarzschild's Solution

- Physics
- 2016

Then, before launching into his modifications of Schwarzschild's equations, Corda stated, again on page 70, Abstract A paper by C. Corda (A Clarification on the Debate on “the Original Schwarzschild…

Irreversible gravitational collapse: black stars or black holes?

- Physics
- 2011

It is well known that the concept of black hole has been considered very fascinating by scientists even before the introduction of Einstein's general relativity. They should be the final result of an…

Half Truths and Rant Against Black Hole Paradigm by Abhas Mitra Eternally Collapsing Object Debunked

- Physics
- 2020

Abhas Mitra who is by profession, a nuclear physicist and learnt general relativity on his own, had tried to represent multiple maiden proofs of why trapped surface shouldn’t form or why shouldn’t…

On the Geometry of Space

- Physics
- 2015

In this paper, we explore the possibility that black holes and Space could be the geometrically Compactified Transverse Slices (”CTS”s) of their higher (+1) dimensional space. Our hypothesis is that…

Quasi-Normal Modes: The “Electrons” of Black Holes as “Gravitational Atoms”? Implications for the Black Hole Information Puzzle

- Physics
- 2015

Some recent important results on black hole (BH) quantum physics concerning the BH effective state and the natural correspondence between Hawking radiation and BH quasi-normal modes (QNMs) are…

Mass inversion in a critical neutron star : An alternative to the black hole model

- Physics
- 2017

Abstract: In this first part, we present a documented historical background about the Schwarzschild solution to the field equations of general relativity, as originally considered by Karl…

Perihelion advance for orbits with large eccentricities in the Schwarzschild black hole

- Physics
- 2011

We deduce a new formula for the perihelion advanceof a test particle in the Schwarzschild black hole by applying a newly developed non-linear transformation within the Schwarzschild space-time. By…

Analyzing Black Hole Super-Radiance Emission of Particles/Energy from a Black Hole as a Gedankenexperiment to Get Bounds on the Mass of a Graviton

- Physics
- 2013

Use of super-radiance in BH physics, so specifies conditions for a mass of a graviton being less than or equal to 1065 grams, allows for determing what role additional dimensions may play in removing…

## References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 69 REFERENCES

David Hilbert and the origin of the "Schwarzschild solution"

- Physics
- 2003

The very early dismissal of Schwarzschild's original solution and manifold, and the rise, under Schwarzschild's name, of the inequivalent solution and manifold found instead by Hilbert, are…

Book Review: A brief history of time: from the big bang to black holes. / Bantam, 1988.

- Physics
- 1988

Was there a beginning of time? Could time run backwards? Is the universe infinite or does it have boundaries? These are just some of the questions considered in an internationally acclaimed…

Quasiblack holes with pressure: General exact results

- Physics
- 2010

A quasiblack hole is an object in which its boundary is situated at a surface called the quasihorizon, defined by its own gravitational radius. We elucidate under which conditions a quasiblack hole…

Alternative space-time for the point mass

- Materials Science
- 1979

Schwarzschild's actual exterior solution (${g}_{\mathrm{S}}$) is resurrected, and together with the manifold ${M}_{0}={R}^{4}\ensuremath{-}{r=0}$ is shown to constitute a space-time possessing all…

Nature

- MedicineOtolaryngology--head and neck surgery : official journal of American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery
- 2009

Can

- Education
- 1984

It is demonstrated that Ga-PSMA PET/CT has a high overall diagnostic value for LN staging in patients with moderate and high-risk PCa, but the conclusions still require a larger sample size, multi-center prospective randomized controlled trial to verify.

The classical theory of fields

- Physics, Geology
- 1952

The principle of relativity Relativistic mechanics Electromagnetic fields Electromagnetic waves The propagation of light The field of moving charges Radiation of electromagnetic waves Particle in a…

Ann

- Psychology
- 2005

Aaron Beck’s cognitive therapy model has been used repeatedly to treat depression and anxiety. The case presented here is a 34-year-old female law student with an adjustment disorder with mixed…

Lifsits - Classical Theory of Fields (3rd ed.). London: Pergamon

- ISBN 0-08-016019-0
- 1971