A Benchmark for Ontologies Merging Assessment

  title={A Benchmark for Ontologies Merging Assessment},
  author={Mariem Mahfoudh and Germain Forestier and Michel Hassenforder},
  booktitle={Knowledge Science, Engineering and Management},
In the last years, ontology modeling became popular and thousands of ontologies covering multiple fields of application are now available. However, as multiple ontologies might be available on the same or related domain, there is an urgent need for tools to compare, match, merge and assess ontologies. Ontology matching, which consists in aligning ontology, has been widely studied and benchmarks exist to evaluate the different matching methods. However, somewhat surprisingly, there are no… 

How Good Is This Merged Ontology?

These criteria cover structure, function and usability of the merged ontology by evaluating General Merge Requirements (GMRs), analyzing the intended use and semantics, and considering the ontology and entity annotation, respectively.

Why the mapping process in ontology integration deserves attention

This work presents a high-level integration workflow as a clear guideline for the whole process of ontology integration, and identifies open issues in this integration step and discusses the ensuing challenges.

Merging and Comparing Ontologies Algebraically

This work shows that the ontology merging system, given by ontology V -alignment pairs and pushouts, satisfies the properties: (I), (C), (A), and (R) so that the merging system is partially ordered and the merging closure of a given repository with respect to pushouts can be computed efficiently.

Integration of Heterogeneous Classical Data Sources in an Ontological Database

This paper provides and develops a semi-automatic integration approach in which ontology has a central role and converts the different classical data sources to local ontologies, then merge these ontologies into a global ontological model based on syntactic, structural and semantic similarity measurement techniques.

Semantic integration of traditional and heterogeneous data sources (UML, XML and RDB) in OWL2 triplestore

A semi-automatic integration approach of classical data sources via a global schema located in database management systems of RDF or OWL data, called triplestore is proposed.

What to Do When the Users of an Ontology Merging System Want the Impossible? Towards Determining Compatibility of Generic Merge Requirements

This paper analyzes in detail which GMRs are (in-)compatible, and proposes a graph based approach to determining and ranking maximum compatible supersets of user-specified GMRs that can be fulfilled simultaneously.

GMRs: Reconciliation of Generic Merge Requirements in Ontology Integration

This work argues that users should be able to select those requirements that are most important to them, but that system support is required to determine a compatible set of requirements based on user inputs, and proposes a graph-theory based approach to determining such sets.

Semantic integration of heterogeneous classical data sources in ontological data warehouse

This paper provides and develops a semi-automatic approach for designing an ontological data warehouse from various sources to convert the different classical data sources to local ontologies (OWL2), then merge these ontologies into a global ontological model based on syntactic, structural and semantic similarity measurement techniques.

A multi-strategy approach for the merging of multiple taxonomies

Experiments indicate that the proposed merging approach is feasible and effective to merge multiple taxonomies and works well in the aspects of limiting the semantic redundancy and establishing high-quality hierarchical relations between concepts.

The Semantic Web: ESWC 2020 Satellite Events: ESWC 2020 Satellite Events, Heraklion, Crete, Greece, May 31 – June 4, 2020, Revised Selected Papers

The design of the Hierarchy of Hypotheses (HoH) core ontology is introduced to semantically capture and model the information contained in hierarchies of hypotheses created for invasion biology.



PROMPT: Algorithm and Tool for Automated Ontology Merging and Alignment

PROMPT, an algorithm that provides a semi-automatic approach to ontology merging and alignment, is developed and implemented and is based on an extremely general knowledge model and therefore can be applied across various platforms.

Towards a Benchmark for Ontology Merging

This work proposes the use of general metrics such as the relative coverage of the input ontologies, the compactness of the merge result as well as the degree of introduced redundancy to evaluate three merge approaches for different merge scenarios.

Multi-mapping based ontology merging system design

A framework for multi-mapping based ontology merging systems (MMOMS), and the functions and working processes of its six composition modules are fully described, reveals that the MMOMS works well in solving the problem of ontology heterogeneity in Semantic Web Services.

FCA-MERGE: Bottom-Up Merging of Ontologies

Techniques from natural language processing and formal concept analysis are applied to derive a lattice of concepts as a structural result of FCA-MERGE for merging ontologies following a bottom-up approach which offers a structural description of the merging process.

Algebraic graph transformations for formalizing ontology changes and evolving ontologies

Towards a Parametric Ontology Modularization Framework Based on Graph Transformation

The ultimate goal of this work is to build a parametric modularization tool, enabling application developers to easily compare, apply and combine different approaches for module extraction, or even create entirely new techniques.

Combining and relating ontologies: an analysis of problems and solutions

This paper tries to classify the problems that may arise into a common framework, and uses that framework to examine several projects that aim at some ontology combination task, thus sketching the state of the art.

Algebraic Graph Transformations for Merging Ontologies

This paper proposes a formal approach for merging ontologies using typed graph grammars using the algebraic approach to graph transformations, SPO (Simple PushOut) which allows a formal representation and ensures the consistence of the results.

The HCONE Approach to Ontology Merging

The HCONE approach on ontology merging is described, based on capturing the intended informal interpretations of concepts by mapping them to WordNet senses using lexical semantic indexing, and exploiting the formal semantics of concepts’ definitions by means of description logics’ reasoning services.

Target-driven merging of taxonomies with Atom