3. Rational Choice Research on Social Dilemmas: Embeddedness Effects on Trust

  title={3. Rational Choice Research on Social Dilemmas: Embeddedness Effects on Trust},
  author={Vincent Buskens and Werner Raub},
† Stimulating comments of and discussions with Jeroen Weesie and other members of our Utrecht group " Cooperation in Social and Economic Relations " are gratefully acknowledged. We also acknowledge helpful comments from participants of the Russell Sage Foundation " Rational Choice Social Research Workshop " and specifically from our discussant, Simon Gächter. The Management of Matches " and under grant 400-05-089 for the project " Commitments and Reciprocity. " The order of authorship is… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Trust and Partner Selection in Social Networks: An Experimentally Grounded Model
It is shown that dynamic networks lead to more cooperation when agents can create more links and reduce exploitation opportunities by free riders and cast serious doubt about the static view of network structures on cooperation.
Embedding Trust: A Game-Theoretic Model for Investments in and Returns on Network Embeddedness
Social relations through which information disseminates promote efficiency in social and economic interactions that are characterized by problems of trust. This provides incentives for rational
Commitments by Hostage Posting
We survey research on incurring commitments by voluntary hostage posting as a mechanism of cooperation. The Trust Game is employed as a paradigmatic example of cooperation problems. We sketch a very
The Emergence of Social Structure: Employer Information Networks in an Experimental Labor Market
This discussion paper resulted in an article in Social Networks (2013). Volume 35, issue 4, pages 541-560. We use laboratory experiments to investigate how employers develop social structures for
Intermediaries in Trust: An Experimental Study on Incentives and Norms
Trust situations involve a certain amount of risk for trustors that trustees can abuse. Knowing this, rational individuals might not place trust in others. In many real situations, intermediaries
The emergence of conventions in the repeated volunteer's dilemma: The role of social value orientation, payoff asymmetries and focal points.
It is found that groups with more prosocials engage less in turn-taking and no effect of SVO on the emergence of solitary-volunteering and instead that payoff asymmetry with one strong actor is a necessary precondition.
Can Centralized Sanctioning Promote Trust in Social Dilemmas? A Two-Level Trust Game with Incomplete Information
A formal two-level trust game with incomplete information which adds an authority as a strategic purposive actor into the traditional trust game is presented, showing that even a slight uncertainty about the type of the newly introduced authority might facilitate the establishment of trust and reciprocity in social dilemmas.
Intermediaries in Trust: Indirect Reciprocity, Incentives, and Norms
It is found that intermediaries can increase trust if there is room for indirect reciprocity between the involved parties and the effect of monetary incentives and social norms cannot be clearly separable in these situations.
Cooperation: Sociological Aspects
most prominent studies of cooperation in sociology proceed from some kind of rationality assumption. There are basically two groups of studies, one starting from the assumption of rational egoists
The emergence of employer information networks in an experimental labor market
Whether employer networks emerge that facilitate information sharing about the trustworthiness of job candidates are investigated and one type of network is an ‘anonymity network’ where information is anonymously and voluntarily provided as a collective good for all employers to use.


Trust, Reciprocity, and Social History: A Re-examination
Berg et al. (Games and Economic Behavior, 10, pp. 122–142, 1995) study trust and reciprocity in an investment setting. They find significant amounts of trust and reciprocity and conclude that trust
Reputation and Reciprocity: Consequences for the Labour Relation
Recent evidence highlights the importance of social norms in many economic relations. Many of these relationships are long-term and provide repeated game incentives for performance. We experimentally
How Effective are Online Reputation Mechanisms? An Experimental Study
It is found that while the feedback mechanism induces quite a substantial improvement in transaction efficiency, it also exhibits a kind of public goods problem in that, unlike in the partners market, the benefits of trust and trustworthy behavior go to the whole community and are not completely internalized.
Trust, Reciprocity, and Social History
Abstract We designed an experiment to study trust and reciprocity in an investment setting. This design controls for alternative explanations of behavior including repeat game reputation effects,
Cooperation via Social Networks
Abstract Sufficiently frequent interaction between partners has been identified by, a.o., Axelrod as a more-or-less sufficient condition for stable cooperation. The underlying argument is that
Kinds of Third-Party Effects on Trust
The simplest social context for trust is an isolated dyad—two people away from others. The more usual context is two people surrounded by various close friends, foes, and acquaintances. We argue that
Conversation and Cooperation in Social Dilemmas
This article presents an analysis of 35 years of published experiments testing decision making in prisoners' dilemmas. The objective is to begin to reconnect the theory and the evidence of rational
Beyond Rationality in Models of Choice
There is increasing sociological interest in formal models of action driven by a calculus of expected utility. We believe these efforts to extend microeconomic models to extraeconomic exchange can
Exit Threats and Cooperation under Anonymity
A strategy contest in an iterated Prisoner's Dilemma with an exit option after each game is developed. The whole model is assumed to represent the conditions for egoistical cooperation in a large and
The Emergence of Exchange Structures: An Experimental Study of Uncertainty, Commitment, and Trust
  • P. Kollock
  • Sociology
    American Journal of Sociology
  • 1994
An experiment is used to investigate the effects of uncertainty on pattern of exchange. The role of reputation as an important factor related to the formation of stable exchange relations is