“Western” Versus “Islamic” Human Rights Conceptions?

  title={“Western” Versus “Islamic” Human Rights Conceptions?},
  author={Heiner Bielefeldt},
  journal={Political Theory},
  pages={121 - 90}
Au-dela de l'alternative entre le relativisme et l'imperialisme culturels, l'A. etudie le moyen de preserver l'universalite des droits de l'homme tout en faisant place a la diversite des interpretations culturelles et religieuses. Rejetant la position essentialiste, l'A. confronte la tradition occidentale issue de l'histoire de l'Europe et de son ideal d'emancipation, d'une part, a la tradition islamique revendiquant un pragmatisme humanitaire dans l'esprit de la sharia, d'autre part. 
Socioeconomic Rights: A Dialogue With Islam
There are some who believe that there will be an inevitable “clash of civilizations” between the Muslim world and the West. By contrast, this article contends that there are many opportunities forExpand
Women’s Rights in Islamic Shari’a: Between Interpretation, Culture and Politics
Abstract This article analyses existing biases – whether due to misinterpretation, culture or politics – in the application of women’s rights under Islamic Shari’a law. The paper argues that thoughExpand
Meeting the Challenge: Redefining Europe's Classical Model for State Intervention in Religious Practices
This article challenges the affirmation that the State has an increasing obligation to interfere in religious practices in order to establish harmony between these practices and human rights. UsingExpand
Universal Human Rights: The Contribution of Muslim States
It is often supposed that international human rights standards were negotiated without active participation by Middle Eastern and Muslim states. That was not the case. United Nations records documentExpand
Overcoming Eurocentrism in Human Rights: Postcolonial Critiques – Islamic Answers?
Abstract Human rights are a contested concept. One important strand of criticism concerns the charge of their Eurocentrism, formulated in particular by postcolonial theorists and scholars. AlthoughExpand
Framing Secular Women’s Rights in Contemporary Britain and Beyond: Challenges and Implications (MA Thesis)
This thesis argues that a group of women from Muslim majority communities campaigning against Sharia law in Britain is challenging group rights multicultural discourse, and that this challenge isExpand
The enlightenment project has not completed its prescribed mission entirely since it prefers keeping its close position to Western cultures and believes. However, the enlightenment’s original purposeExpand
Is the idea of human rights a universal concept
While human rights is not a universal concept, its construction as a form of Western cultural imperialism represents an unfounded and inaccurate reading of civilisation. The idea of human rights asExpand
The Human Right of Religious Freedom in International Law
The majority of constitutions written after World War II have proclaimed religious freedom as one of the most fundamental human rights. Yet, despite numerous proclamations from the United Nations andExpand
Whose Gender Equality? On the Boundaries of Islam and Feminism in the MENA Region
  • Ilyass Bouzghaia
  • Political Science
  • Double-Edged Politics on Women’s Rights in the MENA Region
  • 2019
In contemporary Muslim postcolonial countries, the term gender equality resonates as an appealing international principle for many politicians. However, for many Islamist and conservative forces, theExpand


On Human Rights and the Qur'anic Perspective in Human Rights in Religious Traditions.
L'A. enumere les nombreux droits exprimes par le Coran, qui composent une somme des droits de l'homme. Elle met en garde contre la tendance a considerer le Coran comme la seule conception legitime deExpand
Autonomy and Republicanism
Examinant les principes de l'ethique kantienne: l'autonomie morale, l'imperatif categorique, le respect et la dignite de l'etre humain, l'A. montre que la philosophie politique de Kant, fondee sur leExpand
Deconstruction of the Rule of Law : Carl Schmitt's Philosophy of the Political
Etude du developpement de la philosophie politique de C. Schmitt sous la Republique de Weimar. Examinant la subordination du normativisme liberal au pouvoir et les motifs existentialistes de laExpand
An introduction to Islamic law
An Introduction to Islamic Law presents a broad account of our present knowledge of the history and outlines of the system of Islamic law. It is not intended in the first place for specialists,Expand
Human Rights and the Search for Community
Human Rights and the Search for Community Liberal Society Cultural Absolutism and Nostalgia for Community Rights, Dignity, and Secular Society The Modern Community Honor and Shame Social ExclusionExpand
Toward an Islamic Reformation: Civil Liberties, Human Rights, and International Law
Toward an Islamic Reformation: Civil Liberties, Human ...Toward An Islamic Reformation : Civil Liberties, Human ...Toward an Islamic Reformation by An Na'im, Abdullahi (ebook)Bing: Toward An IslamicExpand
A Critique of An'Na'im's Assessment of Islamic Criminal Justice," in Islamic Law Reform and Human Rights: Challenges and Rejoinders, ed
  • Tore Lindholm and Kari Vogt (Copenhagen: Nordic Human Rights Publications,
  • 2000
Duncker & Humblot, 1963), 71
  • See also Heiner Bielefeldt, 'Deconstruction of the 'Rule of Law': Carl Schmitt's Philosophy of the Political," Archivfiir Rechts und Sozialphilosophy (Archives for Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy) 82 (1996): 379-96; David Dyzenhaus, Legality and Legitimacy: Carl Schmitt, Hans K
  • 1997
Human Rights and the Search for Community (Boulder, CO: Westview
  • 1995