“The Real Point is Control”: The Reception of Barbara McClintock's Controlling Elements

@article{Comfort1999TheRP,
  title={“The Real Point is Control”: The Reception of Barbara McClintock's Controlling Elements},
  author={Nathaniel Comfort},
  journal={Journal of the History of Biology},
  year={1999},
  volume={32},
  pages={133-162}
}
  • N. Comfort
  • Published 1999
  • History
  • Journal of the History of Biology
In the standard narrative of her life, Barbara McClintock discovered genetic transposition in the 1940s but no one believed her. She was ignored until molecular biologists of the 1970s “rediscovered” transposition and vindicated her heretical discovery. New archival documents, as well as interviews and close reading of published papers, belie this narrative. Transposition was accepted immediately by both maize and bacterial geneticists. Maize geneticists confirmed it repeatedly in the early… 

A tale of two biographies: the myth and truth of Barbara McClintock

  • E. Shah
  • Art
    History and philosophy of the life sciences
  • 2016
TLDR
This commentary aims to show the relevance and usefulness of psychoanalytical theories for understanding scientific subjectivities and provides a revision to the neo-Kantian idea of scientist subject.

Scientific Discovery and Scientific Reputation: The Reception of Peyton Rous’ Discovery of the Chicken Sarcoma Virus

TLDR
Why Rous’ hypothesis of a viral origin of cancer could not be incorporated into the existing body of knowledge about cancer before the 1950s is considered.

Chromosome rearrangements and transposable elements.

There has been limited corroboration to date for McClintock's vision of gene regulation by transposable elements (TEs), although her proposition on the origin of species by TE-induced complex

Causal-role myopia and the functional investigation of junk DNA

TLDR
It is argued that selectionist reasoning about TE / host coevolutionary dynamics can greatly streamline the search for biologically interesting CR functions, and offers epistemic benefits without placing onerous demands on the investigator.

The Developmental Gene Hypothesis for Punctuated Equilibrium: Combined Roles of Developmental Regulatory Genes and Transposable Elements

TLDR
The developmental gene hypothesis is proposed, which states that developmental regulatory genes are responsible for the orchestration of metazoan morphogenesis and their extreme conservation and mutation intolerance generates the equilibrium or stasis present throughout much of the fossil record.

All about levels: transposable elements as selfish DNAs and drivers of evolution

The origin and prevalence of transposable elements (TEs) may best be understood as resulting from “selfish” evolutionary processes at the within-genome level, with relevant populations being all

Determinism and Underdetermination in Genetics: Implications for Students’ Engagement in Argumentation and Epistemic Practices

In the last two decades science studies and science education research have shifted from an interest in products (of science or of learning), to an interest in processes and practices. The focus of

Variation, "evolution", immortality and genetic instabilities in tumour cells.

The genetic basis of evolutionary change in gene expression levels

TLDR
A systematic integration of ideas that combines global mapping studies, cis/trans tests and modern population genetics methodologies, in order to directly estimate the forces acting on regulatory variation within and between species is proposed.

EXPOsing gender in science: a visual analysis with lessons for gender awareness and science diplomacy

Abstract Worldwide mega-events have a significant political purpose, demonstrating various commitments to topics, such as energy conservation and gender equality. Gendered imagery at these major

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 29 REFERENCES

Genetics and the Physiology of Development

TLDR
The Sedgwick Lecture, given this year at Woods Hole, seems a suitable occasion to discuss some of the problems common to the three fields of research, including genetics, physiology and embryology.

Marginalia to McClintock's Work on Mutable Loci in Maize

TLDR
A discussion of the data in maize show a remarkable parallelism to older work in a completely different field, namely, the analysis of intersexuality, which might help to make some parts of the new work in maize appear less unusual and vice versa, and show how the trend of ideas on the nature of the genic material is consistently going in a definite direction away from the classical theory of the gene.

The Pale Green Mutable System in Maize.

TLDR
This report is an analysis of the pale green mutable gene system and its various components, which is similar in many ways to previously described systems and, in addition, there is evidence for an even closer relationship of component parts.

The Feminine Method as Myth and Accounting Resource: A Challenge to Gender Studies and Social Studies of Science

Some recent feminist analyses of science have focused on the method of science, claiming that it displays stereotypically masculine gender traits, and counterposing it to a putatively alternative

Some Parallels Between Gene Control Systems in Maize and in Bacteria

TLDR
In this article, McClintock attempted to link the regulation of controlling elements to observations made by Francois Jacob, Jacques Monod, and Andre Lwoff on bacterial operons in 1960 to establish her preeminence in the study of gene regulation.

The origin and behavior of mutable loci in maize

  • B. Mcclintock
  • Biology
    Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
  • 1950
TLDR
A phenomenon of rare occurrence in maize began to appear with remarkably high frequencies in the cultures and the terms mutable genes, unstable genes, variegation, mosaicism, mutable loci or “position-effect” have been applied to this phenomenon.

Genetic Control of Biochemical Reactions in Neurospora

TLDR
In investigating the roles of genes, the physiological geneticist usually attempts to determine the physiological and biochemical bases of already known hereditary traits, establishing that many biochemical reactions are in fact controlled in specific ways by specific genes.

Mutable Loci in Maize

The focus of this report is the change in McClintock's thinking about biochemical and physical mechanisms to explain transposition, mutation, and gene expression. These changes were developed in a

Induction of Instability at Selected Loci in Maize.

TLDR
This is McClintock's only research article on controlling units to appear in a peer-reviewed journal and demonstrates that she was able to select a specific gene and make it mutable.

Molecular Structure of Nucleic Acids: A Structure for Deoxyribose Nucleic Acid

TLDR
The determination in 1953 of the structure of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA), with its two entwined helices and paired organic bases, was a tour de force in X-ray crystallography and opened the way for a deeper understanding of perhaps the most important biological process.