“Science in a Democracy”: The Contested Status of Vaccination in the Progressive Era and the 1920s

  title={“Science in a Democracy”: The Contested Status of Vaccination in the Progressive Era and the 1920s},
  author={J. Colgrove},
  pages={167 - 191}
  • J. Colgrove
  • Published 2005
  • Sociology, Medicine
  • Isis
  • In the first decades of the twentieth century, a heterogeneous assortment of groups and individuals articulated scientific, political, and philosophical objections to vaccination. They engaged in an ongoing battle for public opinion with medical and scientific elites, who responded with their own counterpropaganda. These ideological struggles reflected fear that scientific advances were being put to coercive uses and that institutions of the state and civil society were increasingly expanding… CONTINUE READING
    24 Citations

    Topics from this paper

    Resister's logic: the anti-vaccination arguments of Alfred Russel Wallace and their role in the debates over compulsory vaccination in England, 1870-1907.
    • 15
    Are there different spheres of conscience?
    • 7
    • PDF
    Medical Liberty: Drugless Healers Confront Allopathic Doctors, 1910–1931
    • S. Petrina
    • Sociology, Medicine
    • The Journal of medical humanities
    • 2008
    • 2
    Materia Medica: Technology, Vaccination, and Antivivisection in Jazz Age Philadelphia
    • 1
    • PDF
    Public Health Chronicles
    • 2


    On the opposition to expansion in the federal government in this period see Lynn Dumenil
    • J. Amer. Hist
    • 1990
    most of these laws were permissive rather than mandatory-that is, they allowed but did not require localities to enforce compulsory vaccination should officials deem it necessary. See William Fowler
    • Public Health Rep
    • 1927
    Some Reasons for Compulsory Vaccination
    • 3
    Box 7, Folder "Does Health Work Pay?
    • Louis I. Dublin Papers
    • 1922
    Legislative Aspects of Vaccination
    • 1