“I Wanted Time to Myself and He Wanted to be Together All the Time”: Constructing Breakups as Managing Autonomy-Connection

  title={“I Wanted Time to Myself and He Wanted to be Together All the Time”: Constructing Breakups as Managing Autonomy-Connection},
  author={Erin Sahlstein and Tim Dun},
  journal={Qualitative Research Reports in Communication},
  pages={37 - 45}
  • E. Sahlstein, Tim Dun
  • Published 16 October 2008
  • Psychology
  • Qualitative Research Reports in Communication
In the current study, we used a multiple case study method to analyze the dialectic of autonomy-connection in terminated romantic relationships. Eight heterosexual couples discussed their perceptions and management of “I” and “We” during their relationship. Later, they gave individual accounts of their subsequent breakups. We transcribed and analyzed the couple and individual interviews, comparing couples' management of autonomy-connection. Analysis showed two general patterns before relational… 
When "I Do" Becomes "I Don't": Exploring Communication Behaviors and Dialectical Tensions in Broken Engagements
Communication behaviors and precipitating events were studied in accounts provided by 109 heterosexual individuals living in the United States who had experienced at least one broken premarital
“He Was Supposed to be With Me for the Rest of My Life”: Meaning-Making in Bereaved Siblings’ Online Stories
ABSTRACT The present study applied relational dialectics theory to explore the competing discourses that animate bereaved siblings’ online stories about their loss, as well as to understand how the
Spillover Effects: Communication Involved with Dissolved Workplace Romances
This study adds to the understanding of relationships and communication in organizations by studying how and why workplace romances fail – a unique situation given that former romantic partners
Relational coping during deployment Managing communication and connection in relationships
Wartime deployment involves prolonged separation and creates uncertainty, fear, and disorganization in families (M. J. Peebles-Kleiger & J. H. Kleiger, 1994). This study examined how military
Contradictions and Praxis Contextualized by Wartime Deployment: Wives' Perspectives Revealed through Relational Dialectics
With the continued US military presence throughout the world, it is important to understand the struggles of family members left behind during war, because they are important to the “success” of
Big Macs/Peanut Butter and Jelly: An Exploration of Dialectical Contradictions Experienced by the Sandwich Generation
Grounded in relational dialectics theory, this article reports a study exploring the influence of internal relational dialectic contradictions of women who are in the “Sandwich Generation,” or
Making Sense and Moving On
Having control over initiating a breakup at age 22 predicted relative increases in peer-rated internalizing symptoms and autonomy-undermining interactions with a new partner at ages 23–25, while having a greater understanding of the reasons for a breakup predicted lower self-reported internalizing Symptoms and relative decreases in partner-reported romantic conflict.
Extending Relational Dialectics Theory: Exploring New Avenues of Research
Over the years, relational dialectics theory (RDT) has emerged as a prominent theory in the Communication field. Applied primarily in interpersonal and family contexts, RDT has generated valuable
The following individuals read and discussed the thesis submitted by student Ashley Duchow-Moore, and they evaluated her presentation and response to questions during the final oral examination. They


From Divorce to Friendship: A Study of Dialectic Relationship Development
This paper illustrates a dialectic perspective of relationship development, using a case study of a divorced couple who have become friends. This perspective suggests that relationships oscillate
Trajectories of Relationship Disengagement
It was the purpose of this study to explore primarily through qualitative data the process by which personal relationships dissolve. In applying the method of analytic induction to ninety-seven
Emergent Goals at a Relational Turning Point: The Case of Gordon and Denise
The present case study describes textual evidence of the goal of 'breaking up' in a heterosexual dating relationship. The evidence appears in three telephone conversations. In the first conversation,
Communicative strategies used to terminate romantic relationships
Most data‐based research on relationship dissolution has been limited to hypothetical relationships or those in the distant past. This longitudinal study focused on long‐distance romantic
Accounts of relational dissolution: A comparison of marital and non‐marital relationships
Verbal accounts are the principal means by which individuals personally cope with spoiled relationships and socially manage relationship dissolution. The aims of this study are to illuminate the
A typology of disengagement strategies and an examination of the role intimacy, reactions to inequity and relational problems play in strategy selection
An inductive analysis employing cluster analysis and multidimensional scaling was conducted in Study I to develop, in conjunction with previous literature, a five‐factor typology of disengagement
Two sides to the breakup of dating relationships.
Very few studies on the aftermath of relationship breakups have included data from both ex-partners. The major purpose of this study was to examine whether there is any validity to the principle that
The ex-files: Trajectories, turning points, and adjustment in the development of post-dissolutional relationships
Relational scholars often focus on relational life cycles, including the ways in which relationships come apart. The idea that relationships end at a particular stage, however, suggests that former
Attribution and Adjustment to Relationship Termination
Although relationship dissolution is a fruitful context for field studies of attribution processes, only a handful of studies have been conducted and these have often produced contradictory results.
Breakups Before Marriage: The End of 103 Affairs
Factors that predicted breakups before marriage, investigated as part of a two-year study of dating relationships among college students, included unequal involvement in the relationship (as