“Entrenched practices and other biases”: unpacking the historical, economic, professional, and social resistance to de-implementation

@article{Montini2015EntrenchedPA,
  title={“Entrenched practices and other biases”: unpacking the historical, economic, professional, and social resistance to de-implementation},
  author={Theresa Montini and Ian D. Graham},
  journal={Implementation Science : IS},
  year={2015},
  volume={10}
}
  • T. Montini, I. Graham
  • Published 13 February 2015
  • Medicine, Political Science
  • Implementation Science : IS
BackgroundIn their article on “Evidence-based de-implementation for contradicted, unproven, and aspiring healthcare practices,” Prasad and Ioannidis (IS 9:1, 2014) referred to extra-scientific “entrenched practices and other biases” that hinder evidence-based de-implementation.DiscussionUsing the case example of the de-implementation of radical mastectomy, we disaggregated “entrenched practices and other biases” and analyzed the historical, economic, professional, and social forces that… 

Implementation and de-implementation: two sides of the same coin?

TLDR
It is suggested that leaders in implementation share some characteristics with leaders in de-implementation when comparing them with laggards, such as more open to new evidence, younger and less time in clinical practice, which may depend on the type of intervention rather than entirely reflecting personal characteristics.

Exemplars Illustrating De-implementation of Tradition-Based Practices.

TLDR
The de-implementation process of discontinuing or reducing the use of tradition-based practices is explored, with an emphasis on the roles of various stakeholders and the need to overcome cognitive dissonance and psychological bias.

Reducing Low-Value Practices a Functional-Contextual Consideration to Aid in De-Implementation Efforts

Through innovation in research and self-correction, it is inevitable that some practices will be replaced or be discredited for one reason or another. De-implementation of discredited and low-value

Defining and conceptualizing outcomes for de-implementation: key distinctions from implementation outcomes

TLDR
Preliminary analysis and guidance on de-implementation outcomes is offered, including how they may differ from or overlap with implementation outcomes,How they may be conceptualized and measured, and how they could be measured in different settings such as clinical care vs. community programs.

Evidence and the Politics of Deimplementation: The Rise and Decline of the "Counseling and Testing" Paradigm for HIV Prevention at the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

TLDR
The history of HIV counseling and testing at the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention for a quarter of a century illustrates the influence of institutional resistance on public health decision making and the challenge of de-implementing well-established programs.

De‐implementation: A concept analysis

TLDR
The analysis provided further refinement of de-implementation as a significant concept for ongoing theory development in implementation science and clinical practice and a definition that can be used by researchers and clinicians to facilitate evidence-based practice.

Using theories and frameworks to understand how to reduce low-value healthcare: a scoping review

TLDR
This scoping review provides a rigorous, comprehensive, and extensive synthesis of theoretical approaches used to understand and/or explain what factors influence efforts to reduce low-value care.

Is the end in sight? A study of how and why services are decommissioned in the English National Health Service.

TLDR
Findings from empirical case studies of three decommissioning processes initiated in the English National Health Service suggest the important role played by institutional factors in determining the outcome of decommissioned processes and in particular the prior requirement of political vulnerability for services to be successfully closed.

Broad Medical Uncertainty and the ethical obligation for openness

TLDR
It is argued that there exists a collective epistemic state of ‘Broad Medical Uncertainty’ regarding the effectiveness of many medical interventions, and an ethical presumption in favour of openness regarding BMU as part of a ‘Corrective Response’.

Implementing Evidence-Based Practices in School Psychology: Excavation by De-Implementing the Disproved

The scientist-practitioner model of practice is the most common approach to the profession of school psychology and embraces evidence-based practices as foundations of clinical practice. The focus on
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 70 REFERENCES

Evidence-based de-implementation for contradicted, unproven, and aspiring healthcare practices

TLDR
A conceptual framework is proposed to guide and prioritize this process of abandoning ineffective medical practices, shifting emphasis toward the principles of evidence-based medicine, acknowledging that evidence may still be misinterpreted or distorted by recalcitrant proponents of entrenched practices and other biases.

Impure Science: AIDS, Activism, and the Politics of Knowledge

  • S. Epstein
  • Political Science, Medicine
    Nature Medicine
  • 1997
In the short, turbulent history of AIDS research and treatment, the boundaries between scientist insiders and lay outsiders have been crisscrossed to a degree never before seen in medical history.

Closing the gap between research and practice: an overview of systematic reviews of interventions to promote the implementation of research findings

TLDR
Systematic reviews of rigorous studies provide the best evidence on the effectiveness of different strategies to promote the implementation of research findings and to assess the quality of the systematic reviews.

Knowledge translation of research findings

TLDR
There is a substantial (if incomplete) evidence base to guide choice of knowledge translation activities targeting healthcare professionals and consumers and there are a profusion of innovative approaches that warrant further evaluation.

The practice of medical technology.

TLDR
It is argued that the logical next step of this paradigm is to move beyond criticism and influence the creation and implementation of medical technologies.

Changing the use of electronic fetal monitoring and labor support: a case study of barriers and facilitators.

TLDR
Investigating factors influencing the successful (and unsuccessful) introduction of an evidence-based fetal health surveillance guideline found that the physical setting, adopter concerns, and the medicolegal issues surrounding the guideline played critical roles in uptake.

Evolution and Translation of Research Findings: From Bench to Where?

TLDR
Some of the evidence (or lack thereof) for the process of evolution and translation of research findings, with emphasis on the biomedical sciences are discussed.

Policy makers' perspectives on tobacco control advocates' roles in regulation development

TLDR
There is an important role for tobacco control advocates in the policy development process in regulatory agencies and policy makers suggested that Tobacco control advocates should present science in a format that is well organised and easily absorbed.

Evidence-based medicine. A new approach to teaching the practice of medicine.

TLDR
An important goal of the medical residency program is to educate physicians in the practice of evidence-based medicine, and strategies include a weekly, formal academic half-day for residents devoted to learning the necessary skills.

Characteristics of successfully implemented telemedical applications

TLDR
The findings of this study support research arguing that technologies are not fixed entities moving from invention through diffusion and into routine use, rather, it is the interplay between technical and social factors that produces a particular outcome.
...