“Ambiguous citizens”: Kenyan Somalis and the question of belonging

  title={“Ambiguous citizens”: Kenyan Somalis and the question of belonging},
  author={Tabea Scharrer},
  journal={Journal of Eastern African Studies},
  pages={494 - 513}
  • Tabea Scharrer
  • Published 16 June 2018
  • Sociology
  • Journal of Eastern African Studies
ABSTRACT This paper deals with the way a “politics of belonging” has been enacted in recent years in Kenya, and what this means for the Somali population of the country. Even though Kenyan Somalis have been treated as “ambiguous citizens” since independence, the question for many of them is not so much if they belong to Kenya, but rather how. In the multi-ethnic state of Kenya, there are other groups as well who are “ambiguous citizens” – including Asians, Whites, Nubians and Arabs – for whom… 
Who are Kenya’s 42(+) tribes? The census and the political utility of magical uncertainty
ABSTRACT The idea that Kenya is made up of 42(+) tribes is widespread, but the origins, nature and consequences of any list are not well-known. This article compares ethnic classifications in all
Urban subjects: Somali claims to recognition and urban belonging in Eastleigh, Nairobi
ABSTRACT After more than a century of mutually constructed strangerhood, relations between the Somali community and the Kenyan state are strained. Following the concomitant developments of the
Being a Kenyan-Somali: A Security Threat or Neglected Citizen?
A Somalia government-backed militia, the Shifta, which called for the secession of Northern Frontier District in Kenya, was defeated by Kenyan forces and the Arusha Agreement on Ending Kenya-Somalia
Managing Belonging, Bodies, and Mobility in (Post)Colonial Kenya and Tanzania
Th is article examines the ways in which both colonial and postcolonial migration regimes in Kenya and Tanzania have reproduced forms of diff erential governance toward the mobilities of particular
Ambivalent Belonging: Born-Again Christians between Africa and Europe
Historically entangled with nation, race, and religion, questions of belonging are pressing and affective ones in Africa and Europe. Against the backdrop of anti-migrant hostility, globalization,
“It Is Better to Do Business in Africa than in Europe” – Socio-Economic Positionings among Business-Minded European Somalis Moving to Kenya
Abstract Using the example of European Somalis moving to Kenya, this article argues that although these middle class return migrants share many similarities, they also differ in significant ways.
Laborers, Migrants, Refugees
This article examines the ways in which both colonial and postcolonial migration regimes in Kenya and Tanzania have reproduced forms of differential governance toward the mobilities of particular
‘Madmen, womanizers, and thieves’: moral disorder and the cultural text of refugee encampment in Kenya
Abstract Kenya's refugee camps have evoked spectacular imaginaries of terrorism and humanitarian crisis. Drawing on everyday discourses and shared knowledges among camp administrators, this article
Creating an atmosphere of intellectual superiority: Islamic missionary work in Kenya as staged competition in a climate of religious diversity
ABSTRACT This article deals with a very visible form of Islamic missionary work in Kenya: the public comparison of the Bible and the Qur’an. The argumentative structure of these public debates share
‘Ethnic Neighborhoods’ and/or Cosmopolitanism? The Art of Living Together
  • Tabea Scharrer
  • History
    Refugees and Forced Migrants in Africa and the EU
  • 2018
This chapter probably differs from other contributions in this edited volume in so far as it has neither a clear European nor a clear African perspective – instead it draws on both backgrounds. My


Soil, Work, Civilisation, and Citizenship in Kenya
Abstract What does Kenya's crisis say to academic discussion about globalisation and the rise of local claims to ‘belong’, as autochthonous ‘sons of the soil’? The Kenya case supports the view that
Marginal Actors? Diaspora Somalis Negotiate Their Citizenship
This chapter illustrates the discrepancies between citizenship as a universal discourse of equal rights and the realities of socio-economic marginalisation for certain groups of citizens. This point
Counting as Citizens: Recognition of the Nubians in the 2009 Kenyan Census
This article uses the case of the Nubians in Kenya as an ethnic minority, and the 2009 Kenyan census as a particular form of recognition, to engage in a particular aspect of the debates surrounding
Navigating ethnicity and electoral politics in northern Kenya: the case of the 2013 election
In the 2013 elections, northern Kenya – previously seen as peripheral to national politics – took on great significance as a potential ‘swing’ region, and became the focus of much campaigning and
A New Model Village?: Nairobi Development and the Somali Question in Kenya, c. 1915–17
Kenya has a problem with its urban ethnic Somali population. Those who reside in suburbs of Nairobi are assumed to have entered the country illegally from Somalia, or to have migrated from the large
The fourth point: An examination of the influence of Kenyan Somalis in Somalia
Abstract The consequences of insecurity in Somalia to the government of Kenya and its citizens is well documented: massive flows of refugees since the collapse of the Siyad Barre regime in 1991;
Autochthony and “Family”: The Politics of Kinship in White Kenyan Bids to Belong
For white Kenyans descended from colonial settlers, the question of how to establish their right to belong in Kenya provokes considerable anxiety. Some whites attempt to suture themselves to Kenya
Abstract In 2010, the Kenyan government annulled national census results due to concerns that Somalis in the country had been over-counted. This article traces the genesis of this recent demographic
Accidental Citizens: Etherealizing Securitized Identities of Somalis in Kenya; Contesting Representation, Identity and Belonging
The Kenyan security apparatus has undergone immense transformations particularly after Kenya’s military incursion into Southern Somalia in 2011. The intervention dubbed ‘Operation Linda Nchi’ was an
Territorializing ethnicity: the imposition of a model of statehood on pastoralists in northern Kenya and southern Ethiopia
Abstract The idea of the nation state has penetrated Kenya and Ethiopia deeply at a level much below the ‘nation’ state. In the colonial period districts and grazing reserves were delineated