“Allow natural death” is not equivalent to “do not resuscitate”: a response

@article{Chen2008AllowND,
  title={“Allow natural death” is not equivalent to “do not resuscitate”: a response},
  author={Y-Y Chen and S. Youngner},
  journal={Journal of Medical Ethics},
  year={2008},
  volume={34},
  pages={887 - 888}
}
Venneman and colleagues argue that “do not resuscitate” (DNR) is problematic and should be replaced by “allow natural death” (AND). Their argument is flawed. First, while end-of-life discussions should be as positive as possible, they cannot and should not sidestep painful but necessary confrontations with morality. Second, while DNR can indeed be nonspecific and confusing, AND merely replaces one problematic term with another. Finally, the study’s results are not generalisable to the… Expand

Topics from this paper

Exploring Perceptions of “Do Not Resuscitate” and “Allowing Natural Death” Among Physicians and Nurses
TLDR
Perceptions of physicians and nurses about using the more holistic “allow natural death” terminology in end-of-life care as opposed to the current “do not resusciate” (DNR) order are surveyed. Expand
Allow-Natural-Death (AND) Orders: Legal, Ethical, and Practical Considerations
  • M. Schlairet, R. W. Cohen
  • Medicine
  • HEC forum : an interdisciplinary journal on hospitals' ethical and legal issues
  • 2013
TLDR
Ethical, legal, and pragmatic issues surrounding EOL care decision-making seem to suggest discussion of AND orders as one strategy clinicians could consider at the individual practice level and at institutional levels. Expand
'Do not attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation' or 'allowing natural death'? The time for resuscitation community to review its boundaries and its terminology.
TLDR
A systematially review of the available studies to elucidate ways of improving the use of DNACPR and it is noteworthy that even if the authors aimed at a meta-analysis, studies were so heterogeneous that this aim was not achieved and the quality of the included studies was weak. Expand
Allow natural death versus do-not-resuscitate: titles, information contents, outcomes, and the considerations related to do-not-resuscitate decision
TLDR
The title, information contents, and outcomes may influence the DNR decisions and health-care providers should address the concept of natural death, provide comprehensive information, and help patients and families to overcome the barriers. Expand
Ethical implications of terminally ill and the current state of Do Not Resuscitate orders
  • Heba El Sayed Mostafa, Eman Ahmed Alaa El-Din
  • Psychology
  • 2019
Received Date: Nov 30, 2019 / Accepted Date: Dec 05, 2019/ Published Date: Dec 09, 2019 Abstract Every human being needs to live with no suffering and to survive a satisfactory quality of life,Expand
The Outcome of Patients With 2 Different Protocols of Do-Not-Resuscitate Orders
TLDR
Similar to conventional DNR, DNDCC and DNRCC-Arrest were both associated with the increased risk of death, and patients with D NRCC were more likely to be associated with increasedrisk of death. Expand
Characteristics of patients who refuse do‐not‐resuscitate orders upon admission to an acute palliative care unit in a comprehensive cancer center
TLDR
The frequency and predictors of refusals of do‐not‐resuscitate orders in advanced cancer patients admitted to an acute palliative care unit are determined. Expand
Experience Matters: A Partnership Between Patient and Physician
TLDR
Clinical scenarios that illustrate ethical challenges that often arise during shared decision making are presented, ethical principles that pertain to the scenarios are outlined, and key strategies and skills that physicians need to partner with the patient and family to develop the best plan of care are described. Expand
The over‐interpretation of DNAR
TLDR
There is a reduction in the urgency attached to reviewing a deteriorating patient following institution of aDNAR order, and many doctors and nurses will not perform a range of interventions in the patient with a DNAR order in place. Expand
The ethics of semantics in medicine
In this paper, we discuss the largely neglected topic of semantics in medicine and the associated ethical issues. We analyse several key medical terms from the informed perspective of the healthcareExpand
...
1
2
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 21 REFERENCES
“Allow natural death” versus “do not resuscitate”: three words that can change a life
TLDR
This investigation investigates the impact of a proposed replacement of DNR with “allow natural death” (AND) due to increased likelihood of endorsement with the term AND and results support this proposition. Expand
The continuing ethical dilemma of the do-not-resuscitate order.
TLDR
This article addresses how nurses can be proactive in obtaining answers to these difficult questions and learn how to deal with the dilemma of the do-not-resuscitate order. Expand
Ethical dilemmas and decisions concerning the do-not-resuscitate patient undergoing anesthesia.
TLDR
The topic of DNR orders is addressed as well as some of the moral and ethical dilemmas they pose for the Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetist (CRNA). Expand
Do not resuscitate
TLDR
It must be fully understood by all concerned—patients, doctors, nurses, and relatives—that DNR orders apply only to the decision whether or not to initiate CPR in the event of respiratory or cardiac arrest. Expand
The prevalence and design of hospital protocols limiting medical treatment.
Do-not-resuscitate (DNR) orders and supportive-careonly (SCO) care plans are two ways of implementing limited levels of medical intervention for patients with advanced irreversible diseases. A DNRExpand
Effect of do-not-resuscitate orders on the nursing care of critically ill patients.
TLDR
It is suggested that orders such as "Do not resuscitate" with clearly defined resuscitation plans that are jointly determined by the multidisciplinary team, patient, and family are replaced. Expand
Physicians as healthcare surrogate for terminally ill children
  • P. Weisleder
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Journal of Medical Ethics
  • 2008
TLDR
A straightforward method by which the parents of terminally ill children can entrust the role of healthcare surrogate to the treating physician is presented to mitigate parental guilt and fear of misperception, by self and others, of having given up on their child. Expand
The Effect of Do‐Not‐Resuscitate Orders on Physician Decision‐Making
The effect of do‐not‐resuscitate (DNR) orders on physicians' decisions to provide life‐prolonging treatments other than cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) for patients near the end of life wasExpand
Do-not-resuscitate decisions in a community hospital. Incidence, implications, and outcomes.
TLDR
Intensity of care, as measured by hospital charges, decreased significantly after DNR designation, and it is suggested that the DNR decision should properly become part of a comprehensive patient care plan individualizing treatment goals for patients. Expand
Ethical principles in critical care.
TLDR
Acknowledging that the nature of the intensive care environment makes applying ethical principles difficult, Luce urges physicians to carry out their obligations to serve the interests of their patients. Expand
...
1
2
3
...