‘Why Did MH17 Crash?’: Blame Attribution, Television News and Public Opinion in Southeastern Ukraine, Crimea and the De Facto States of Abkhazia, South Ossetia and Transnistria

  title={‘Why Did MH17 Crash?’: Blame Attribution, Television News and Public Opinion in Southeastern Ukraine, Crimea and the De Facto States of Abkhazia, South Ossetia and Transnistria},
  author={Gerard Toal and John O’Loughlin},
  pages={882 - 916}
ABSTRACT Shock events are often pivotal moments in geopolitics and objects of intense disagreement among conflicting parties. This paper examines the downing of a Malaysia Airlines passenger jet over eastern Ukraine in July 2014 and the divergent blame storylines produced on Russian and Ukrainian television about the event. It then examines results of a question asking why MH17 crashed in a simultaneous survey conducted in December 2014 in six oblasts in Southeastern Ukraine, Crimea, and the de… Expand
14 Citations
Believing Facts in the Fog of War: Identity, Media and Hot Cognition in Ukraine’s 2014 Odesa Tragedy
ABSTRACT How do people form beliefs about the factual content of major events when established geopolitical orders are violently challenged? Here, we address the tragic events of 2 May 2014, inExpand
Does War Change Geopolitical Attitudes? A Comparative Analysis of 2014 Surveys in Southeast Ukraine
In 2014, Ukraine descended into war. The geographically delimited nature of the war in Ukraine, confined to two eastern oblasts, raises the questions of whether war changes geopolitical attitudes inExpand
Clearing the Fog of War: public versus official sources and geopolitical storylines in the Russia-Ukraine conflict
Abstract Military action undertaken by the Russian Federation against Ukraine in 2014 has had enormous geopolitical ramifications. This resulted in what is almost certainly a permanent change inExpand
Reinterpreting the enemy: Geopolitical beliefs and the attribution of blame in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict
Abstract How do geopolitical beliefs affect the attribution of blame for violent conflict? It is usually assumed that citizens in post-conflict societies come to adopt official nationalist discoursesExpand
Strategic humour: Public diplomacy and comic framing of foreign policy issues
  • Dmitry Chernobrov
  • Political Science
  • The British Journal of Politics and International Relations
  • 2021
This article explores persuasive applications of humour in public diplomacy. I propose a new concept of strategic humour – the use of humour by state and proxy actors to promote instrumentalExpand
Dilemmas of Distrust: Conspiracy Beliefs, Elite Rhetoric, and Motivated Reasoning
Conspiracy theories are playing an increasingly prominent role worldwide in both political rhetoric and popular belief. Previous research has emphasized the individual-level factors behind conspiracyExpand
Las operaciones de información rusas en el conflicto del este de Ucrania
The fall of the USSR generated a progressive change in the relations between countries that once were part of the state apparatus of the Eurasian giant. The evolution of this process, within theExpand
Editorial: political geographies of the post-Soviet union -a farewell to Eurasian Geography and Economics from the editors
With this special issue on “Political Geographies of the Post Soviet Union,” two of the journal’s editors take their leave. We (John O’Loughlin since 2002 and Ralph Clem since 1995) have long beenExpand
Change and Continuity in the European Neighbourhood Policy: The Ukraine Crisis as a Critical Juncture
ABSTRACT The Ukraine crisis presented a severe geopolitical challenge to European Union (EU) policies in the neighbourhood. This is because during the course of the crisis, Russia openly challengedExpand
Lessons from the MH‐17 transboundary disaster investigation
Transboundary crises, incidents and disasters, such as chemical spills, airplane crashes and critical infrastructure breakdowns, involving multiple levels and domains of governance pose a particularExpand


Coercion or Conformism? Censorship and Self-Censorship among Russian Media Personalities and Reporters in the 2010s
Federal television is a crucial element of the political system in Putin’s Russia. 88% of the Russian population use television news as their prime source of information, 65% regard the newsExpand
Russian geopolitical storylines and public opinion in the wake of 9-11: a critical geopolitical analysis and national survey
Abstract Examination of the speeches, writings and editorials by the Putin Administration in the aftermath of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks showed a consistent storyline that equatedExpand
Open BUK: Digital Labor, Media Investigation and the Downing of MH17
This article considers the unique forms of digital labor that emerged in the wake of the downing of Malaysian Airlines flight MH17 over Donetsk, Ukraine in July of 2014. Whereas such investigationsExpand
Placing blame: Making sense of Beslan
Abstract The aftermaths of terrorist spectacles are intensely consequential moments in the making of geopolitical meaning. This paper develops a critical geopolitical account of the ways in which keyExpand
Reconceptualizing, Measuring, and Evaluating Distance and Context in the Study of Conflicts: Using Survey Data from the North Caucasus of Russia
How does political violence affect the attitudes and beliefs of affected populations? This question remains of central concern to the discipline of conflict studies. In response, we make the case (byExpand
Global Powers of Horror: security, politics, and the body in pieces
Contemporary dynamics of security and terror seems to be drifting towards a new regime of violence, based on the annihilation of human bodies and lives, beyond and against the idea of humanity andExpand
The rise and fall of “Novorossiya”: examining support for a separatist geopolitical imaginary in southeast Ukraine
Abstract In the spring of 2014, some anti-Maidan protestors in southeast Ukraine, in alliance with activists from Russia, agitated for the creation of a large separatist entity on UkrainianExpand
Conspiracy Theories: Causes and Cures*
The 9/11 attacks had nothing to do with Osama Bin Laden and were actually a plot by influential Americans, a poll conducted in seven Muslim countries found. Expand
Frontline Ukraine: Crisis in the Borderlands
The unfolding crisis in Ukraine has brought the world to the brink of a new Cold War. As Russia and Ukraine tussle for Crimea and the eastern regions, relations between Putin and the West haveExpand
The Polls: Gender and Attitudes Toward Violence
CONSIDERABLE attention in the media and social science community has been focused on the gender gap in President Reagan's popularity. In large part this gap may come from underlying differencesExpand