‘State Capitalism’ in the Soviet Union

  title={‘State Capitalism’ in the Soviet Union},
  author={Michael Charles Howard and John Edward. King},
  journal={History of Economics Review},
  pages={110 - 126}
  • M. Howard, J. King
  • Published 1 January 2001
  • Political Science
  • History of Economics Review
The aim of this paper is to explore the reactions to the Bolshevik Revolution of one group of critics from the left: those who saw it as ushering in a new form of capitalism. The controversy over state capitalism had both theoretical and practical significance. At the analytical level it presented an important test of Marx’s conception of historical materialism, which had been formulated in a largely successful attempt to explain the transition from feudalism to capitalism in Western Europe but… Expand
The international political economy of 'actually existing capitalism' : rethinking globalisation and the retreat of the state
This thesis presents an alternative tradition of classical Marxism capable of understanding what appears to be a shift in power from states to markets over the last two decades. It provides a theoryExpand
Marx, the Predisposition to Reject Markets and Private Property, and Attractive Alternatives to Capitalism
Abstract Ever since capitalism came to be recognized as a new economic system, its principal institutions of private property and markets have had vociferous critics, of whom none was moreExpand
Construction, reconstruction, deconstruction: The fall of the Soviet Union from the point of view of conceptual history
The fall of the Soviet Union is analysed in conceptual terms, drawing on Reinhart Koselleck’s Begriffsgeschichte. The author seeks to interpret the instrumental role of the concepts perestrojka,Expand
Three Aral Sea Films and the Soviet Ecology
Drawing on analysis of three films that converge on the Aral Sea and span from 1929 to 1988, Alec Brookes engages with Marxist scholarship on the Anthropocene and Capitalocene to argue that theExpand
Russian Politics or Russian Energy Industry Lobbying: European Union Perspectives. A tale of gas and politics
In the current study, a prediction that Russian energy industry lobbying and Russian international politics are related was tested. This prediction was derived from impressions that recentlyExpand
The Middle Classes, Class Places, and Class Positions: A Critical Approach to Nicos Poulantzas's Theory
Through a critical rereading of Marxist class theory, a reexamination of the border line between the working and middle classes is undertaken, focusing on the class identity of middle classes withExpand
Mittelklassen, Klassenstellung und politische Klassenpositionen
A reexamination of the borderline between the working and the middle classes is undertaken, focusing on the class identity of middle classes with respect to the question of class place and classExpand


Post-Revolutionary Society
Much of this book has been concerned with what post-revolutionary society, exemplified mainly by the Soviet Union, is not, rather than what it is. I have argued that it is neither capitalism norExpand
A History of Marxian Economics
The first volume of this critical history covers the social, political, and theoretical forces behind the development of Marxian economics from Marx's death in 1883 until 1929, the year marking theExpand
Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy
Explores the relation between a socialist view of society and the democratic method of government; argues that socialism is probably inevitable, for political rather than economic reasons. The bookExpand
Origins of the Crisis in the USSR: Essays on the Political Economy of a Disintegrating System
Hillel Ticktin has been one of the most controversial figures in Soviet studies for 25 years. His assertions that the Soviet economy was hopelessly inefficient, that the ruble was a sham, and thatExpand
Marx's last battle
ConclusionMarxism developed increasingly from a scientific to a Critical Marxism that was much more voluntaristic and stressed consciousness and conscious organization — rather than emphasizing aExpand
The Theory of Capitalist Development
labor which is represented in the value of commodities is a concept which has an important place in Marx's thinking. It must be admitted, however, that it is not an easy concept to comprehend; andExpand
Marxism and "really existing socialism"
What is the connection between the Soviet system, as developed under Stalin and as modified since his death, and the socialism envisaged by Marx? That there are differences is, of course, bothExpand
One Hundred Years of Socialism: The West European Left in the Twentieth Century
List of Tables List of Figures Acknowledgements List of Abbreviations New Introduction Introduction to the First Edition Book One: Expansion Part One: The Hard Road to Political Power 1. TheExpand
In defence of Marxology: A reply to Meghnad Desai's review of T. Shanin et al., Late Marx and the Russian road
This note defends T. Shanin et al., Late Marx and the Russian Road against the criticism levelled by Meghnad Desai in a previous issue of The Journal of Peasant Studies. It is argued that the ‘lateExpand
Philosophy and Revolution, From Hegel to Sartre, and from Marx to Mao
Throughout Philosophy and Revolution Raya Dunayevskaya never loses sight of freedom and revolution which is the driving force of Hegelian Marxism in its clash with historical and politicalExpand