‘Saving the phenomena’ and saving the phenomena

  title={‘Saving the phenomena’ and saving the phenomena},
  author={James Bogen},
  • J. Bogen
  • Published 1 September 2011
  • Philosophy
  • Synthese
Empiricists claim that in accepting a scientific theory one should not commit oneself to claims about things that are not observable in the sense of registering on human perceptual systems (according to Van Fraassen’s constructive empiricism) or experimental equipment (according to what I call “liberal empiricism”). They also claim scientific theories should be accepted or rejected on the basis of how well they save the phenomena in the sense delivering unified descriptions of natural… 

Hegel’s Semantics of Singular Cognitive Reference, Newton’s Methodological Rule 4 and Scientific Realism Today (*)

Empirical investigations use empirical methods, data, and evidence. This banal observation appears to favour empiricism, especially in philosophy of science, though no rationalist ever denied their

Nancy Cartwright, Capacities and Nomological Machines. The Role of Theoretical Reason in Science

This chapter introduces Cartwright’s thinking. She holds that explanation is the aim of science and that science should explain real causes using theoretical reason. Stable causes repeatedly linked

Detecting psychological phenomena: taking bottom-up research seriously.

  • B. Haig
  • Psychology
    The American journal of psychology
  • 2013
This article provides a methodologically informative account of phenomena detection with reference to psychology by presenting the important distinctions between data, phenomena, and theory and identifies a number of different methodological strategies that are used to identify empirical phenomena.

In Defence of an Inferential Account of Extrapolation

  • T. Baetu
  • Philosophy
    International Studies in the Philosophy of Science
  • 2021
ABSTRACT According to the hypothesis-generator account, valid extrapolations from a source to a target system are circular, since they rely on knowledge of relevant similarities and differences that

More is Different…Sometimes: Ising Models, Emergence, and Undecidability

Philip Anderson’s seminal paper `More Is Different’ is explicit in its arguments for the failure of construction methods in some areas of physics and inexplicit about the consequences of those

Epistemic representation in science and beyond

In this dissertation, I define epistemic representations to be tools for gaining information about aspects of the target systems they represent, which I call as phenomena of interest. I ask: in

How Scientists Are Brought Back into Science—The Error of Empiricism

This chapter aims to contribute to critically investigate whether human-made scientific knowledge and the scientist’s role in developing it, will remain crucial—or can data-models automatically

The role of disciplinary perspectives in an epistemology of scientific models

  • M. Boon
  • Philosophy
    European Journal for Philosophy of Science
  • 2020
The purpose of this article is to develop an epistemology of scientific models in scientific research practices, and to show that disciplinary perspectives have crucial role in such an epistemology.

Structural Correspondence Between Organizational Theories

Organizational research constitutes a differentiated, complex and fragmented field with multiple contradicting and incommensurable theories that make fundamentally different claims about the social

Can We Make Sense of Relational Quantum Mechanics?

It is claimed that there is currently no adapted locality criterion to evaluate whether the resulting interpretation is local or not, and one of its central claims concerning the possibility for an observer to have knowledge about other observer’s events is clarified.



Saving the phenomena

A according to a widely shared view of science, scientific theories predict and explain facts about "observables": objects and properties which can be perceived by the senses, sometimes augmented by

Evading the IRS

'IRS' is our term for the logical empiricist idea that the best way to understand the epistemic bearing of observational evidence on scientific theories is to model it in terms of Inferential

A Material Theory of Induction

It is argued that there are no universal inductive inference schemas and that a material theory no longer separates the factual and schematic parts of an induction, it proves not to be vulnerable to Hume’s problem of the justification of induction.

Realism and Instrumentalism in Sixteenth Century Astronomy: A Reappraisal

We question the claim, common since Duhem, that sixteenth century astronomy, and especially the Wittenberg interpretation of Copernicus, was instrumentalistic rather than realistic. We identify a

Descartes: The Project of Pure Enquiry

Descartes has often been called the 'father of modern philosophy'.His attempts to find foundations for knowledge, and to reconcile the existence of the soul with the emerging science of his time, are

The Aim and Structure of Physical Theory

This classic work in the philosophy of physical science is an incisive and readable account of the scientific method. Pierre Duhem was one of the great figures in French science, a devoted teacher,

IT Revolutions

  • N. CopernicusJ. Dobrzycki
  • Physics
    Lecture Notes of the Institute for Computer Sciences, Social Informatics and Telecommunications Engineering
  • 2011
In 1973, on the 500th anniversary of Copernicus's birth, the Polish Academy of Sciences announced its intention to publish all of the astronomer's extant works, both in their original Latin and in

A Closer Analysis of the Heat Production of Nerve

The heat production of nerve is believed to occur in two phases, “initial” and “recovery”; the former is presumably an accompaniment of the physical and chemical changes which take place during the

The Scientific Image

In this book van Fraassen develops an alternative to scientific realism by constructing and evaluating three mutually reinforcing theories.

A quantitative description of membrane current and its application to conduction and excitation in nerve.

This article concludes a series of papers concerned with the flow of electric current through the surface membrane of a giant nerve fibre by putting them into mathematical form and showing that they will account for conduction and excitation in quantitative terms.