‘Introspectionism’ and the mythical origins of scientific psychology

  title={‘Introspectionism’ and the mythical origins of scientific psychology},
  author={Alan Costall},
  journal={Consciousness and Cognition},
  • A. Costall
  • Published 1 December 2006
  • Psychology
  • Consciousness and Cognition

Figures from this paper

Freud’s psychoanalysis, contemporary cognitive/social psychology, and the case against introspection

Although Freud and contemporary cognitive/social psychologists differ with regards to various traditions, vocabularies, methods, and areas of application, they agree in their criticism of the use of

The Decline and Fall of Introspection

A commonly told story about the history of psychology goes like this. Psychology began as a science using introspection as the method for investigating the mind. However, introspection proved to be

“… to rely on first and foremost and always”: Revisiting the role of introspection in William James’s early psychological work

In order to legitimate itself as a science, psychology has faced the ongoing problem of establishing its proper method of investigation. In this context, debates on introspection have emerged that

Historical and Philosophical Foundations of Psychology

Part I. Philosophy of Science: 1. Logical positivism and Popper's falsificationism 2. Kuhn and scientific revolutions 3. Lakatos and Feyerabend: research programmes and anarchism Part II. Historical

The "textbook Gibson": The assimilation of dissidence.

Although Gibson continues to figure in most of the textbooks, his work is routinely assimilated to theoretical positions he emphatically rejected: cue theory, stimulus-response psychology, and nativism.

The Myth of the “Cognitive Revolution”

General introductory textbooks play a major part in moulding students’ conceptions of psychology. A systematic review has been undertaken of the treatment in 40 texts of the term “cognitive

The Problem of Other Minds

The problem of other minds is a problem of modern philosophy that can be traced back to the French seventeenth century philosopher Rene Descartes. Descartes held the dualistic view that, apart from

Psychology and Natural Science: The Relation Between the Natural Scientific Attitude, the Theoretical Attitude and the Life-World in Ethnomethodology and Phenomenology

In this thesis I will revisit debates concerning the use of natural scientific methods in the discipline of psychology. I take the position that natural scientific methods are inappropriate for

Self-Perception Theory, Radical Behaviourism, and the Publicity/Privacy Issue

According to Bem’s self-perception theory, people know their own minds in the same way that they know those of others: they infer their own minds by observing their own behavior and the circumstances



Controlling the Metalanguage: Authority and Acquiescence in the History of Method.

In Naming the Mind, Danziger (1997) analyzed the emergence of the fundamental categories of psychological inquiry. Challenging the implicit assumption that behavior, personality, intelligence,

R.G. Collingwood and the Idea of a Historical Psychology

R.G. Collingwood's antagonism to scientific psychology is notorious. As a philosopher, especially an Oxford philosopher, such antagonism was hardly exceptional. Yet, in fact, Collingwood's attitude

From Soul to Mind: The Emergence of Psychology, from Erasmus Darwin to William James

"Trailblazing history...After presenting a brilliant kaleidoscope of 18th- and 19th-century writings, Reed concludes that philosophy broke away from psychology, not the reverse, and that psychology

Psychology from the Standpoint of a Behaviorist

THERE has been a great deal of controversy, especially in the philosophical journals of America, concerning the theory of behaviourism. Prof. Watson is, we believe, the originator of the term and the

Wundt's psychological experiment in the light of his philosophy of science

SummaryWundt initiated the first systematic psychological research programme. This achievement occurred at the same time as his elaboration of a philosophy of science which was anti-inductivist and

Experience and Nature

IN this brilliant and inspiring book, Prof. Dewey attempts to apply in philosophy the thought which is effective in dealing with any genuine question, from the elaborate problems of science to the


Modern cognitive psychology presents itself as the revolutionary alternative to behaviorism, yet there are blatant continuities between modern cognitivism and the mechanistic kind of behaviorism that

The positivist repudiation of Wundt.

  • K. Danziger
  • Psychology
    Journal of the history of the behavioral sciences
  • 1979
Behaviorism represents a logical development of Wundt's central concepts of voluntarism, value, and psychic causality, which were rejected as metaphysical by younger psychologists.

Imageless Thought or Stimulus Error? The Social Construction of Private Experience

There has been a great deal of discussion about the role of introspection within psychology in recent years. It is generally held that introspectionist methods were once widely used and that the rise