'Rough Consensus and Running Code' and the Internet-OSI Standards War

@article{Russell2006RoughCA,
  title={'Rough Consensus and Running Code' and the Internet-OSI Standards War},
  author={Andrew L. Russell},
  journal={IEEE Annals of the History of Computing},
  year={2006},
  volume={28},
  pages={48-61}
}
  • A. Russell
  • Published 1 July 2006
  • History
  • IEEE Annals of the History of Computing
Internet historians recognize the technical achievements but often overlook the bureaucratic innovations of Internet pioneers. The phrase, "We reject: kings, presidents, and voting. We believe in: rough consensus and running code," was coined by David Clark in 1992. This article explains how the phrase captured the technical and political values of Internet engineers during a crucial phase in the Internet's growth 
“We Reject: Kings, Presidents, and Voting”: Internet Community Autonomy in Managing the Growth of the Internet
ABSTRACT The Internet is currently facing the gravest challenge in its 30-year history as IPv4 addresses, the fundamental numbers required for a machine to connect to the Internet, run out. Despite
The Restructuring of Internet Standards Governance: 1987-1992
  • C. Partridge
  • Business
    IEEE Annals of the History of Computing
  • 2016
TLDR
This article revisits the preceding five years to show that the IETF, at least initially, sought to avoid the crisis that forced a restructuring of the Internet standards governance process.
Standard Setting Committees: Consensus Governance for Shared Technology Platforms
Voluntary Standard Setting Organizations (SSOs) use a consensus process to create new compatibility standards. Practitioners have suggested that SSOs are increasingly politicized and perhaps
The Political Nature of TCP/IP
TLDR
This thesis attempts to shed light on the historical, political, and technical context of TCP/IP and examines aspects of the social and developmental record of this technology using STS theoretical approaches such as Hughesian systems theory, Social Construction of Technology (SCOT), and Langdon Winner’s brand of technological determinism.
Power and the internet
TLDR
This paper shows how the internet moves power from governments and private entities to individual citizens, restructuring the authors' societies and creating a new global stakeholder class – individual users of the internet, and connects the advent of this stakeholderclass with a traditional principle of internet governance, “rough consensus”.
The history of the internet: the missing narratives
TLDR
It is shown that history matters for understanding why information systems function in the way they do and the rise of various technologies, including the Transmission Control Protocol/Internet Protocol and the World Wide Web, as ‘dominant designs’ should be interpreted within the economic framework of industries with network effects.
Why then did the X.400 e-mail standard fail? Reasons and lessons to be learned
  • K. Jakobs
  • Computer Science
    J. Inf. Technol.
  • 2013
TLDR
The paper looks at the various reasons that led to X.400's failure to gain the widely expected level of market acceptance, and proposes and discusses alternative reasons, including poor timing of the standardisation activity, inadequate first implementations, and an ill-advised paradigm shift that occurred in the cause of events.
Morning dew on the Web in Australia: 1992–1995
TLDR
The story of the Web in Australia is traced from its beginnings in 1992, up to 1995, identifying key players and what they did, set within the broader context, and reflecting the insights of the theories of innovation and innovation diffusion.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 76 REFERENCES
FYI on "What is the Internet?"
TLDR
This FYI RFC answers the question, "What is the Internet?" and contains a modified chapter from Ed Krol's 1992 book, "The Whole Internet User's Guide and Catalog".
The internet religious war
Government, Business, and the Making of the Internet
In 1969, when few commercial communications networks existed, a U.S. Defense Department research agency created an experimental system that would eventually become the Internet. Driven by both
Code and Other Laws of Cyberspace
Code and Other Laws of Cyberspace. Lawrence Lessig. New York: Basic Books, 1999. 230 pp. $21 hbk. Lawrence Lessig's Code and Other Laws of Cyberspace is perhaps the most original book yet written
Rethinking the design of the Internet
TLDR
There is a risk that the range of new requirements now emerging could have the consequence of compromising the Internet's original design principles, and the Internet might lose some of its key features, in particular its ability to support new and unanticipated applications.
Coordinating Technology: Studies in the International Standardization of Telecommunications
Theorizing standards: actor-centred institutionalism - a social-shaping perspective on standardization and the co-ordination of technology standards and technical development institutionalized and
'Tension between Standardisation and Flexibility' Revisited: A Critique
TLDR
It is concluded that an anti-OSI stance in the OSI-TCP/IP debate clouds the view on the problem of flexibility in network evolution and shows that flexible solutions have had little impact on the development of the Information Infrastructure.
Architectural Principles of the Internet
TLDR
A snapshot of the current principles of the Internet architecture, intended for general guidance and general interest, and in no way intended to be a formal or invariant reference model.
The design philosophy of the DARPA Internet Protocols
TLDR
This paper attempts to capture some of the early reasoning which shaped the Internet protocols.
...
...