"Therapeutic" bed rest in pregnancy: unethical and unsupported by data.

@article{McCall2013TherapeuticBR,
  title={"Therapeutic" bed rest in pregnancy: unethical and unsupported by data.},
  author={Christine A. McCall and David A. Grimes and Anne Drapkin Lyerly},
  journal={Obstetrics and gynecology},
  year={2013},
  volume={121 6},
  pages={
          1305-8
        }
}
"Therapeutic" bed rest continues to be used widely, despite evidence of no benefit and known harms. In this commentary, we summarize the Cochrane reviews of bed rest and propose an ethical argument for discontinuing this practice. Cochrane systematic reviews do not support "therapeutic" bed rest for threatened abortion, hypertension, preeclampsia, preterm birth, multiple gestations, or impaired fetal growth. This assessment has been echoed in other comprehensive reviews. Prescribing bed rest is… Expand
View on PubMed
conovers.org
41 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
2
Background Citations
8

41 Citations

Citation Type

Citation Type

Bed rest in pregnancy: time to put the issue to rest.
  • J. Biggio
  • Medicine
  • Obstetrics and gynecology
  • 2013
TLDR
Bed rest remains one of the most commonly prescribed treatments to improve reproductive outcomes in complicated pregnancies, despite a lack of evidence that it improves any obstetric or neonatal outcomes. Expand
Experience of Preeclampsia and Bed Rest: Mental Health Implications
TLDR
Six themes emerged including: negative feelings and thoughts, lack of guidelines about their diagnosis, family stressors, Lack of social support, not being heard, loss of normal pregnancy, and physical symptoms that provide insight into improving care for women with preeclampsia. Expand
Maternal activity restriction to reduce preterm birth: Time to put this fallacy to bed
  • C. Walsh
  • Medicine
  • The Australian & New Zealand journal of obstetrics & gynaecology
  • 2020
TLDR
The practice of prescribing bed‐rest in pregnancy is outdated and should be abandoned and be cannot be endorsed, even in women with a short cervix. Expand
Choosing Wisely: Bedrest-A Panacea for All That Ails the Gravida?
  • V. Jain
  • Medicine
  • Journal of obstetrics and gynaecology Canada : JOGC = Journal d'obstetrique et gynecologie du Canada : JOGC
  • 2019
TLDR
There is no evidence of any benefit of bedrest or reduced activity during pregnancy for either of these conditions, and evidence of harm, in addition to the fact that exercise is known to be beneficial in pregnancy. Expand
Bed rest in singleton pregnancies for preventing preterm birth.
TLDR
There is no evidence, either supporting or refuting the use of bed rest at home or in hospital, to prevent preterm birth, and future trials should evaluate both the effectiveness ofBed rest in hospital or at home is widely used as the first step of treatment, there are no evidence that this practice could be beneficial. Expand
What is new in bed rest in pregnancy?: best articles from the past year.
  • R. Lorenz
  • Medicine
  • Obstetrics and gynecology
  • 2014
TLDR
This month, Dr. Lorenz discusses four recent publications in bed rest in pregnancy, and each is concluded with a "bottom line" that is the take-home message. Expand
Prenatal and intrapartum strategies to prevent prematurity: A case study
TLDR
Questions in the study help readers apply module content to Cynthia’s condition to identify and help reduce her risk for premature birth and offer appropriate nursing interventions. Expand
Women's Needs on Bed Rest during High-risk pregnancy and Postpartum Period: A Qualitative Study
Background & aim: pregnancy is a normal part of life, however, high-risk pregnancy that need bed rest can be stressful and affect woman and her family. Therefore, understanding the needs of women on… Expand
Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine (SMFM) Consult Series #50: The role of activity restriction in obstetric management.
TLDR
It is suggested that activity restriction not be prescribed for treatment of pregnancies complicated by FGR, PPROM or hypertensive disease, coupled with evidence of adverse effects of activity restriction. Expand
Maternal Activity Restriction in Pregnancy and the Prevention of Preterm Birth: An Evidence-based Review
TLDR
A review of the literature describes the potential benefits, harms, and efficacy of activity restriction in the prevention of preterm birth. Expand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 16 REFERENCES
Lack of evidence for prescription of antepartum bed rest.
  • J. Maloni
  • Medicine
  • Expert review of obstetrics & gynecology
  • 2011
TLDR
Research indicates that bed-rest treatment is ineffective for preventing preterm birth and fetal growth restriction, and for increasing gestational age at birth and infant birthweight, and it should be discontinued until evidence of effectiveness is found. Expand
BED REST IN PREGNANCY
TLDR
Bed rest remains one of the most commonly prescribed treatments to improve reproductive outcomes in complicated pregnancies, despite a lack of evidence that it improves any obstetric or neonatal outcomes. Expand
Bed rest with or without hospitalisation for hypertension during pregnancy.
TLDR
Although one small trial suggests that some bed rest may be associated with reduced risk of severe hypertension and preterm birth, these findings need to be confirmed in larger trials and bed rest should not be recommended routinely for hypertension in pregnancy. Expand
BED REST IN PREGNANCY
TLDR
Bed rest is used extensively to treat a wide variety of pregnancy conditions, at substantial cost but with little proof of effectiveness, and its use during pregnancy should be curtailed unless randomized trials demonstrate improvement in a specific outcome. Expand
Bed rest in hospital for suspected impaired fetal growth.
TLDR
There is not enough evidence to evaluate the use of a bed rest in hospital policy for women with suspected impaired fetal growth, according to the review of randomised trials comparing a policy of bed Rest in hospital with ambulatory management. Expand
Hospitalisation and bed rest for multiple pregnancy.
  • C. Crowther
  • Medicine
  • The Cochrane database of systematic reviews
  • 2001
TLDR
Routine bed rest in hospital for multiple pregnancy did not reduce the risk of preterm birth, or perinatal mortality, and there is currently not enough evidence to support a policy of routine hospitalisation for bed rest for women with a multiple pregnancy. Expand
Hospitalisation and bed rest for multiple pregnancy.
  • C. Crowther
  • Medicine
  • The Cochrane database of systematic reviews
  • 2000
TLDR
Routine bed rest in hospital for multiple pregnancy did not reduce the risk of preterm birth, or perinatal mortality, and there is currently not enough evidence to support a policy of routine hospitalisation for bed rest for women with a multiple pregnancy. Expand
Bed rest in singleton pregnancies for preventing preterm birth.
TLDR
There is no evidence, either supporting or refuting the use of bed rest at home or in hospital, to prevent preterm birth, and future trials should evaluate both the effectiveness ofBed rest in hospital or at home is widely used as the first step of treatment, there are no evidence that this practice could be beneficial. Expand
Bed rest during pregnancy for preventing miscarriage.
TLDR
There is insufficient evidence of high quality that supports a policy of bed rest in order to prevent miscarriage in women with confirmed fetal viability and vaginal bleeding in first half of pregnancy. Expand
Rest during pregnancy for preventing pre-eclampsia and its complications in women with normal blood pressure.
TLDR
Daily rest, with or without nutrient supplementation, may reduce the risk of pre-eclampsia for women with normal blood pressure, although the reported effect may reflect bias and/or random error rather than a true effect. Expand
...
1
2
...